Printable View
We need this feature that what we mention ( Troops) in Clan Castle request Only that troops could available to donate for the clan members... and rest all troops will be unavailable like that can't donate that troops...!! so this way we might get rid of that wrong donators..!!
If members of your clan are always donating wrong troops, they should be kicked out. That's how you solve your issue. The game doesn't need to change because the leadership of your clan won't kick members who disobey rules.
Well.. You will only be able to find the name of wrong donators till when you are online.. once you went offline you won't find that donator.. so if you dont know who was that member then even leader can't do anything.. thank you mate..
If you have a diverse range of Town Halls, then you can at least narrow down the list of suspects based on the level of troops being donated. Monitor donation statistics and see whose stats have increased after an infraction occurs. You can scout the suspects' villages to see who typically cooks those troops. You can also set a trap when you believe the suspect is online by posting a request for troops and simply watch your screen waiting for them to donate. If your elders/coleaders participate in the investigation, you'll find the offender very quickly.
Bro.. !! I'm playing for fun.. I don't have time to watch all this things as i dont stay online 24/7 .. so all this things is for jobless players.. 🤔
Well, instead of analyzing the request text then comparing all clan members' troops, it might be a little better to restrict members with lower town hall levels.
If you create the clan YOU are the leader, if you want SC to manage your clan then maybe you should give leader to someone else. Unless you are in a clan with mature player that understand the game leadership needs to be on more that couple minutes a day. I would rather be in a small clan with 10 players that understand this than in a large clan where over half do whatever they want because leadership doesn't care/never on.
This would ruin clashofstats because no one wants 4 barbarians but on cos its required to confirm your account
It is a problem, and some help with detecting wrong-troop donators, normal play and war maps, would be appreciated.
Suggestions saying to not accept junior players are very short sighted. We need junior players to keep the game alive. They just haven't got used to the game, and think donating must be good. They don't appreciate that donations prevent receiving the right troops from someone else.
Who said don't accept junior players?Quote:
Originally Posted by George1971
We accept th6-7 all the time, BUT we explain our rules and what will happen if they break them. We don't threaten to kick them 15-20 times and still do nothing to them. You get 1 reminder then a "donated wrong troops, good luck in next clan" kick message.
We accept TH3+. Sometimes more than one at a time. When there is more than one at a time, and one mis-donates, it is hard to know which it is. To complicate things, they change TH level and troop level quite rapidly. It would be nice if it were easier to work out who it is. Yes, when identified they get one warning. Then a kick with an explanation.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
But isn't that the same thing? Not accepting them and kicking them is pretty much the same because your ground is wrong troop donations.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
A solution might be to be able to clear out wrong troops that were donated WITHOUT making a new donation request. So, for example if you request troops with 25 slots and someone donates you 5 level 1 barbarians, then clear out the brabs so that you'd have 25 remaining slots in the same request.