Printable View
As its a troop that can repeatedly attack wall we should figure out a fair time that it would take to destroy a section.
with current dps it doesn 3200damage every 5 seconds at lvl 1.
This results in it killing lvl 1-8 wall in 5 seconds(1shot), lvl 9 and 10 wall in 10 seconds, and lvl 11 in 15 seconds
Personally i think 10 seconds to destroy a wall is fair, what do you guys think?
5 seconds to destroy a wall means it will just make walls pointless in my oppinion
This is what i was thinking about:
lvl 1 ( Damage per shot WB lvl 4 )
Damage per shot 1280, Dps 6,4 * 40
lvl 1-4 Wall 1 Shot 5 sec lvl 5-7 Wall 2 Shots 10 sec lvl 8 Wall 3 Shots 15 sec lvl 9 Wall 4 Shots 20 sec lvl 10 Wall 5 Shots 25 sec lvl 11 Wall 6 Shots 30 sec
lvl 2 ( Damage per shot WB lvl 5 )
Damage per shot 1840, Dps 9,2 * 40
lvl 1-5 Wall 1 Shot 5 sec lvl 6-8 Wall 2 Shots 10 sec lvl 9-10 Wall 3 Shots 15 sec lvl 11 Wall 4 Shots 20 sec
lvl 3 ( Damage per shot WB lvl 6 )
Damage per shot 2400, Dps 12 * 40
lvl 1-6 Wall 1 Shot 5 sec lvl 7-9 Wall 2 Shots 10 sec lvl 10-11 Wall 3 Shots 15 sec
This means that at lvl 3, you can at max destroy a lvl 6 wall in 1 shot.
And with 2 shots you can kill a reasonable lvl of wall depending on the lvl of the ''wall destroyer''
What do you think?
Keep in mind that this may likely be for th10 only, so most of the players using this troop will be attacking people only with level 8 walls and higher. Most of the time it will take 10 seconds at least to destroy one wall, and this troop is meant to continue going and destroy multiple layers of walls. That means it will be usually 20 seconds for this troop to do what it's supposed to do. I think that is very fair, and not OP whatsoever. At high levels, 20 seconds could be the difference between 2 and 3 stars, so this troop would not be OP and it would still leave room for strategy. 10 seconds is very reasonable for this troop and I do not think there is any reason to change it.Quote:
Originally Posted by MCBoes
Well i was talking about the lvl 1 wall destoyer, and i agree that if that was used on th10 it probably wouldnt be OP.Quote:
Originally Posted by waymond
You probably just missed my post because you were typing, but the current lvl 1 kills wall in about the same time as the lvl 3 i made up.
But the stats on the current lvl 2 and 3 make it very OP on TH10
Yes I agree it is to high. I wanted to do the same as a level 2 wall breaker. And a 5 sec delay between shots.Quote:
Originally Posted by MCBoes
level 1 - 16 x40 = 640 with a 5 sec. Delay/reload between shots.
Level 2 - 22 x40 = 880
Level 3 - 30 x40 = 1200
These were the numbers I meant. I just had per second because that what it say in the game.
I think I like your damage a little better than mine. Lol. I may change to yours.Quote:
Originally Posted by MCBoes
16/5 = 3.2 DpsQuote:
Originally Posted by Georgegroeg
3.2 * 40 = 128 dps on wall
128 * 5( rate of fire) = 640 damage per hit
Thank you, it might not be perfect but i did put alot of thought into itQuote:
Originally Posted by Georgegroeg
Pretty good idea but it should have a rate of fire like a balloon to make it fair