one of the better ways to make wars more fun

We all are facing one problem in clash of clans, It's mini-maxes or engineered bases in wars. I have a suggestion to reduce effectiveness of such engineered bases. If we reduce DPS and HP of higher town hall level troop when a higher town hall level player is attacking lower town hall level base, we cancel out the advantage of high level troops.Let me explain it through an example, Let's say a Town hall 11 attacks a Town hall 10 or 9 base, then DPS and HP of troops of Town hall 11 player would be reduced by some percentage. Reduced DPS and HP will stop Town hall 11 from bullying lower town halls.What will happen if a lower town hall player attacks a higher town hall?a troop cannot do more DPS and have more HP than100% of it's original DPS and HP,that is,troop's DPS or HP will not increase to more than 100% of it's original value in any condition.
meaning a rushed th11 doesnt get a very high benefit on lower town halls.
(this is similar to the penalty the higher ths get on loot while raiding a lower town hall base in multiplayer)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Imtruecrusher22

We all are facing one problem in clash of clans, It's mini-maxes or engineered bases in wars. I have a suggestion to reduce effectiveness of such engineered bases. If we reduce DPS and HP of higher town hall level troop when a higher town hall level player is attacking lower town hall level base, we cancel out the advantage of high level troops.Let me explain it through an example, Let's say a Town hall 11 attacks a Town hall 10 or 9 base, then DPS and HP of troops of Town hall 11 player would be reduced by some percentage. Reduced DPS and HP will stop Town hall 11 from bullying lower town halls.What will happen if a lower town hall player attacks a higher town hall?a troop cannot do more DPS and have more HP than100% of it's original DPS and HP,that is,troop's DPS or HP will not increase to more than 100% of it's original value in any condition.
meaning a rushed th11 doesnt get a very high benefit on lower town halls.
(this is similar to the penalty the higher ths get on loot while raiding a lower town hall base in multiplayer)

---

This would hurt clean up attacks in wars when it is needed to attack lower (strategy). Not to mention would hurt all new th upgrades, if I'm a new th6 and opponents have th5 then my troops DPS and HP are reduced .

You cannot say this only applies to th10-11 this would have to apply to all town halls.

Your idea is nothing like the loot penalty for raiding.

Just make the health points based on the attacks defence %. So a maxed th with maxed troops for that th level would get 100% health. A rushed to would say get 70% of maxed a engineered base would get 1% to 10% health. Based on the worst case of a one level one cannon.

This would completely destroy engineered bases by reducing all advantage in war.

Wars would be more fun do to the fact engineered bases would be out of wars because they are the ones sucking the fun out of wars.

Or maybe just simpler just to require a certain % of th completion before someone can war. A war ban for engineered bases.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

Just make the health points based on the attacks defence %. So a maxed th with maxed troops for that th level would get 100% health. A rushed to would say get 70% of maxed a engineered base would get 1% to 10% health. Based on the worst case of a one level one cannon.

This would completely destroy engineered bases by reducing all advantage in war.

Wars would be more fun do to the fact engineered bases would be out of wars because they are the ones sucking the fun out of wars.

Or maybe just simpler just to require a certain % of th completion before someone can war. A war ban for engineered bases.

---

You seem to still not understand that engineering is not against TOS. Do you feel the same about rushers as you do engineered or are they ok because you can 3 star them but they cannot 3 star you?