A simple solution to end engineering

This has been suggested 100000 times

Also, there is a whole forum where you can post these ideas

Hey guys,
I cant believe none of us had this idea before.
(Or i am complete idiot and this is already the way war matchmaking is)

Why not take defensive weight and offensive weight separately and match with a clan with similar defensive and offensive weight. And not adding it as total war weight.

This means that most likely an engineered clan with get matched with engineered clan. So there is no benefit of engineering!


Explained by BbaBaba (better then i ever could):

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BbaBaba123

Under a double weight system if it takes the offensive weight of a TH11 and the defensive weight it would match with with someone that has similar weight to yours.

A defenseless max offense 11 would get matched with a defenseless max offense 11, the matchups would take longer to find but for a far more balanced war it might be necessary. I wouldn't mind it.

They also can't be offensively engineered either because they would be a liability, being unable to attack and pulling equal weights yet.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sheedy17

This has been suggested 100000 times

Also, there is a whole forum where you can post these ideas

---

Why u hijacked my post😢

And if this has been suggested before, it is perfectly good idea..i cant see any problem with it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by divyam121

Why u hijacked my post

---

he did not, other threads here behaves somewhat like bugged. I wonder why. Look at other threads and you will see that the thread starter is not in #1

Under your proposed system, what type of player does an engineer with a single cannon and only one troop maxed out match against? This is an extreme example, but it'll be a super weak base. A base so weak that a camp full of max, say, PEKKAs would be able to steamroll 100% of the time

Just do it based on TH level. The end, problem solved.

There is no need for a solution since there is no problem.
There are just people angry because they want to win in war but they dont't want to make a war oriented village

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by QueenBeeq

Just do it based on TH level. The end, problem solved.

---

A combination approach would be the best... to start off, a base should always at least weigh as much as the previous TH level maxed.

After that if ya want to add either offense of defense stats whichever is greater is fine. However just pairing TH together makes it hard for non maxed TH to even participate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

Under your proposed system, what type of player does an engineer with a single cannon and only one troop maxed out match against? This is an extreme example, but it'll be a super weak base. A base so weak that a camp full of max, say, PEKKAs would be able to steamroll 100% of the time

---

So isnt it the fault of the owner for only focusing on 1 troop or defense?
As long in war a bases
Def = Def
Off= Off

Its fair fight

It can reduce the win of those clans!! great