Printable View
We need a donations tab for troops and spells, the current system complicates the flow of farming troops or war troops especially when you go offline and come back on to see the troop you made for a mate has been donated and you're left to discard the troop or wait till that troop is requested again. it will be cool if it's implemented in the next update or future updates. Cheers
This idea is currently ruled out. Please read sticky threads at the top of page before posting
*Separate tab in chat for troop requests
I don't think that ruled out item and the OP are talking about the same thing.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
The ruled out item refers to a having one tab for global, one tab for clan chat, and one tab to show all current troop requests. This way a conversation in the chat won't push your troop request up and out of view.
The OP I believe is talking about a separate training tab where you can train troops specifically for donation. Currently, if you train a specific troop for a clanmate, it goes into your camps, but someone else already filled the request, then you're stuck with this troop you can't untrain or donate.
This isn't ruled out, it's not a chat feature. It's an additional tab for donations. Ex like quick train tab, spell tab etc.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
Yes that's exactly what I'm talking about. Adding an extra tab in your barracks for donations, where troops made for donations can be housed and will be the same housing space as the barracks level. It'll significantly make donations more effective and efficientQuote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyPC
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyPC
My bad must have stopped reading after donation tab for troops and spells. Your talking about something like theseQuote:
Originally Posted by femiairboy94
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...onation+troops
I think what you would mean is a seperate camp sized cc (or whatever they might want to call it) that you yourself cannot ever use the troops from, once they go there you cant move them to your camps (so this cant be exploited to store auxiliary army) and once they go there they can only be donated or deleted (so you cant exploit this for resource hiding) and all your donations come from there. If so thats not bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by femiairboy94
Exactly what I have in mind, they can review it in order to discourage exploitation but your idea doesn't seem bad as well. An extra army camp to keep troops for donations seems legit.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Yes where we can have a special place just for donating troops. Of course it'll need tweaks here and there to avoid exploitation.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie
It can be a tab or an extra camp or whatever, thats just schemantics. The important thing is troops that go there are non refundable and can only go to donations. Those two things kill any exploits I think.Quote:
Originally Posted by femiairboy94
Hopefully supercell devs will add it master onQuote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Maybe they live in a separate quarters of the Clan Castle and when donated , they go off to the receiver. The idea is not so bad , but I doubt that we need a separate space just for not having the troops when the request is gone. That has not frequently happened with me. The second trained army is the place where my troops to be donated get stored and can also work as the idea you want.
Yeah that can work as well, as long as there's a space to keep the troops for donation incase any other person requests and doesn't affect your current training army. It'll be very useful for people who don't come online regularly but still want to help out.Quote:
Originally Posted by PokeManiac