End War Button

The way it would work would be if one clan presses their end war button a notification is sent to the opposing clan, if they confirm then war is ended then and there so we can get on to the next war search.

Button and confirmation only accessible to Leader/COs

The reason for this? There are so many wars where either both clans have got all of their attacks in or one clan has clearly won and the other clan doesn't intend to get anymore attacks in and we're just waiting for war to end before kicking off the next search.

Please see any of the other threads where this has been suggested for reasons why it is a pointless exercise and likely will never be implemented.

Briefly, given SC's position of not wanting clans to gain XP any faster than is currently possible, there would likely be a cooldown until 47 hours from the start of the terminated war so an end war button would be pointless.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aspex

Please see any of the other threads where this has been suggested for reasons why it is a pointless exercise and likely will never be implemented.

Briefly, given SC's position of not wanting clans to gain XP any faster than is currently possible, there would likely be a cooldown until 47 hours from the start of the terminated war so an end war button would be pointless.

---

Couldn't find any with my brief search with my suggestion of how it would work. Also if XP is a problem, fine, unlock the feature at Clan Level 10 as XP really doesn't matter after that level. Cooldown is fine but shouldn't be more than 12 hours.

This has already been mentioned several times. I doubt and hope it will never happen. To many clans would see the mismatch and drop out. Easy clan xp. This would also upset serious war clans who are looking for loot. So what is supercell gonna do about loot? Give maximum loot to the winners? Cheat them out of it? Half loot? It just doesnt work.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spaceraceb2014

This has already been mentioned several times. I doubt and hope it will never happen. To many clans would see the mismatch and drop out. Easy clan xp. This would also upset serious war clans who are looking for loot. So what is supercell gonna do about loot? Give maximum loot to the winners? Cheat them out of it? Half loot? It just doesnt work.

---

Firstly serious war clans looking for loot? That's an oxymoron if I've ever heard one, war clans only care about war not loot.

If you want me to type up a full methodology you'll have to pay me, that's for SC to do. Put simply, there'd be criteria set in place - like I said in my original post if all attacks are done or one clan has completed their attacks and it's not possible mathematically for the opposing clan to win. Both of which involves both clans attacking.

Even if the opposing clan only gets a couple of attacks in, but your clan gets all of their attacks in and requests to end war, that's fine if the opposing clan ends war - that's no different to what we have now, only that we have to wait hours for the war to end with the opposing clan having given up.

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...r-early-button

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...tacks-are-used

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-leaders-agree

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...arly-Surrender

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-End-War-early

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...rly-end-of-war

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...r-early-button

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...tacks-are-used

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-leaders-agree

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...arly-Surrender

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-End-War-early

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...rly-end-of-war

---

Thanks for those links, some the same as my feature idea. Although old requests, so this particular feature request needs a bump.

Some of the comments are interesting, but all are insignificant concerns and are easy to address. The moderators comment about how loot/xp is calculated is a floored argument and speaking as a software developer, if it was the case that loot/xp is calculated over 47 hours it's easy to change that.

So far there's no good arguments against adding this feature. Good arguments that can't be handled that is.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icarus75

Thanks for those links, some the same as my feature idea. Although old requests, so this particular feature request needs a bump.

Some of the comments are interesting, but all are insignificant concerns and are easy to address. The moderators comment about how loot/xp is calculated is a floored argument and speaking as a software developer, if it was the case that loot/xp is calculated over 47 hours it's easy to change that.

So far there's no good arguments against adding this feature. Good arguments that can't be handled that is.

---

There haven't been any good arguments as to why it should be. So until then SC says no thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icarus75

Firstly serious war clans looking for loot? That's an oxymoron if I've ever heard one, war clans only care about war not loot.

If you want me to type up a full methodology you'll have to pay me, that's for SC to do. Put simply, there'd be criteria set in place - like I said in my original post if all attacks are done or one clan has completed their attacks and it's not possible mathematically for the opposing clan to win. Both of which involves both clans attacking.

Even if the opposing clan only gets a couple of attacks in, but your clan gets all of their attacks in and requests to end war, that's fine if the opposing clan ends war - that's no different to what we have now, only that we have to wait hours for the war to end with the opposing clan having given up.

---

One it could be either or.
2 any smart war clan wants its members to have loot to upgrade troops and defence.
3 i have a good point anyway

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spaceraceb2014

One it could be either or.
2 any smart war clan wants its members to have loot to upgrade troops and defence.
3 i have a good point anyway

---

The only loot you really get from war is gold. Elixir and DE is such a tiny profit after cost of army. In reality you can do 1 barch raid on a dead base and get more loot than you can in war and in less time.

Spending a few hours setting up and doing a war in comparison to spending 30 minutes raiding is no comparison, you'll get much more loot from the raids than you would in war. Makes no sense to waste more time to get less loot on a war.

So I don't buy the loot argument at all. Using war as a loot cow is simply a falsehood.