Best donations for greater involvement

Since clash of clans has been released, clan donations (both basic and warlike) are made only to help people in their attacks in exchange for little experience and a slight reimbursement of elixir depending on the troop Donated. The problem is that not everyone feels involved in spending precious elixir and especially time for troop creation, then hoping for comrade trust, to let this remain in the clan and do the same.




That's why I thought of a more objective idea: instead of receiving only a little experience in the rewards,would be better to receive a very small reward for the booty that he earned in battle, and where used he clan troops from Donate?




Free Bottle, in the sense that it is not subtracted from those who attack with the troops of the clan, and the attacked victim. I know there would be problems with the proper distribution of the gained booty, one that gives 5 archers gains as one who gives a golem, so I thought a very simple method similar to that of shareholders: donation requests must mark the troops That you want to get, you have to transcribe troop, number (and even the level) as your first choice, then you must also make a secondary choice where it may require less expensive troops or simply with little difference from the first if you want to have those specific troops And nothing else can simply copy the troops he chose as the first choice. Donors will then make the donations and according to the percentage of expenses they have made compared to the total cost, they will receive a much or less high booty also expressed with the same percentages.
Example :
I require 5 giants 5 archers who require 11,000 total elixir to do them, Marco gives me 5 giants spending 10,000 elixirs, so 90%, Giulio gives me 5 archers spending only 1,000, 10% of total expenses. The attack is fruitful, earning 400,000 gold and elusing using the troops of the clan, Marco and Giulio receive their reward that must be rich enough to be able to earn donors for their kindness, so earn a number between 3 -5% of the booty I did with my attack (including alloy bonus) so a bonus of 12,000-20,000 gold and elixir finishing directly into the clan castle. Marco having spent 90% of the cost and therefore having also given a very large part of the troops, receives 10800-18,000, while Giulio who has spent only 10%, would earn between 1,200-2,000 of the booty.




Since the donated troops can be used both in defense and in attack, I thought that in addition to determining the troops as first and second choice, in the donation request it will also be necessary to choose whether this will be used to defend or attack if the idea It is too uncomfortable to have many other solutions, such as simply preventing troops losing when they are killed in a village defense.




This will greatly increase the number of donations also in those low-level clans where he is full of inactive people and people leaving the clan after 2 minutes, will give a big prize to those who gave up an attack to help their friends And it would be an incentive to lose some more time in creating troops that should be donated in order to gain that precious booty.




To this idea is also a bit more ambitious: to modify the roles of a clan and to put new ones with specific classes like: the donor class, which receives extra bonuses from donations compared to others; The class soldier or fighter, who receives more bonuses from attacks or simply by the booty of war. These 2 will be selected according to their own statistics, or after reaching a number of donations in the case of the donor, or a number of wars in the soldier case, a player can reach both classes but may only have one title to be chosen Or by him and / or by the boss or co-leader every end of the season. Exiting the clan for more than a day or even immediately would mean losing these privileges and, in order to repurchase them, they will have to regain the same goals.




I apologize in advance for the bad grammar, I am Italian and the English language is not my strong suit :( anyway, these ideas do not pretend to be taken in the letter and probably have other secondary issues related to the game, so I just ask for your answer.

There's already achievements for donating troops and spells. Clan members should be motivated in donating to other members just because and not for a reward system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IceBird1

There's already achievements for donating troops and spells. Clan members should be motivated in donating to other members just because and not for a reward system.

---

^^^^
This.

Plus too many clans don't actively encourage lower level players to donate because they don't want inferior troops. We do and if people still.don't donate to raiding requests (and contribute to the clan), we just don't keep them.

This is only in some clans, especially in the high class clan, because everyone has to do a good attack and so each one requires. In the low or middle class clans, this is not the case, and even if it has been motivated, it does not make sense to give those 5 points of experience in exchange for the donated troop, at this point you can give something more. Please also try to respond to the second idea, those of the classes.
This is only in some clans, especially in the high class clan, because everyone has to do a good attack and so each one requires. In the low or middle class clans, this is not the case, and even if it has been motivated, it does not make sense to give those 5 points of experience in exchange for the donated troop, at this point you can give something more. Please also try to respond to the second idea, those of the classes.

I know that many clans do not want too much trout from the low levels, so I have been guessing the idea of ​​specifying troop level and number. The problem is that in many high-level clans some do not give others, those who feel motivated are the leaders and leaders chiefly
I know that many clans do not want too much trout from the low levels, so I have been guessing the idea of ​​specifying troop level and number. The problem is that in many high-level clans some do not give others, those who feel motivated are the leaders and leaders chiefly

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pingotumbo

This is only in some clans, especially in the high class clan, because everyone has to do a good attack and so each one requires. In the low or middle class clans, this is not the case, and even if it has been motivated, it does not make sense to give those 5 points of experience in exchange for the donated troop, at this point you can give something more. Please also try to respond to the second idea, those of the classes.
This is only in some clans, especially in the high class clan, because everyone has to do a good attack and so each one requires. In the low or middle class clans, this is not the case, and even if it has been motivated, it does not make sense to give those 5 points of experience in exchange for the donated troop, at this point you can give something more. Please also try to respond to the second idea, those of the classes.

---

My clan has from th5 to th11.

Encouraging clan participation through donation, where possible of course, assists everyone to gain achievements, fosters communication and solidifies the clan.

There is nothing wrong with valuing a level 2 giant equally to a level 7 giant..Especially when it's the only one available.

Automated self rewarding systems fir individuals don't do anything for clans and clans are why we play together.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

My clan has from th5 to th11.

Encouraging clan participation through donation, where possible of course, assists everyone to gain achievements, fosters communication and solidifies the clan.

There is nothing wrong with valuing a level 2 giant equally to a level 7 giant..Especially when it's the only one available.

Automated self rewarding systems fir individuals don't do anything for clans and clans are why we play together.

---

I disagree, mine is a th5-th11 clan and only 4 donate, some do not ask, others do not give too much. The reason why clans exist is because they give far more advantage to those who do not have it and donate simply to receive troops in turn is not enough. I repeat in high clans level and even in your case you find it ok because your clan is reasonable but many clans are misguided on this point of view. I 've played Clash since 2013, I've seen a lot of clans and only half satisfied the troops I needed. In any case try not to counter only a small part of my discussion. I also talked about: modifying requests so as to require specific troops that prevent donating troops that they do not want; I've talked about new classes in the clan. And before counter-striving, try to deepen the subject. Requesting specific troops in requests might be negative in some cases and positive in others, as well as for everything.So also try to find some positive solution to every negative thing you see in such a way that we focus on that argument and discard the old one.

It seems to me that your issue is clan management. If members are donating wrong troops constantly they should be kicked. You have came up with a new system with "classes" that will only complicate the game. It is not needed. I have been a member of several well run clans and I know that there hundreds of thousands more out there. Just because you have problems running your clan does not mean that the games donation structure needs to change. Leaders get bad members and instead of booting them they want to change the way the game works. I'll never understand this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pingotumbo

I disagree, mine is a th5-th11 clan and only 4 donate, some do not ask, others do not give too much. The reason why clans exist is because they give far more advantage to those who do not have it and donate simply to receive troops in turn is not enough. I repeat in high clans level and even in your case you find it ok because your clan is reasonable but many clans are misguided on this point of view. I 've played Clash since 2013, I've seen a lot of clans and only half satisfied the troops I needed. In any case try not to counter only a small part of my discussion. I also talked about: modifying requests so as to require specific troops that prevent donating troops that they do not want; I've talked about new classes in the clan. And before counter-striving, try to deepen the subject. Requesting specific troops in requests might be negative in some cases and positive in others, as well as for everything.So also try to find some positive solution to every negative thing you see in such a way that we focus on that argument and discard the old one.

---

Nothing you have suggested has a positive light. Your clan has poor discipline and your experience is jaded by this fact. Clans that don't resolve discipline have few future prospects, just like real world organizations

Learn to lead, exercise the power to kick slackers and leeches who offer nothing to a clan and perhaps respect the fact that people actually know what they are talking about when they give advice.

Did I mention learn to lead ? It doesn't automatically come with the title and 40k gold.

A leader hunting for members to improve the clan and also to educate them not to re-make such actions, I think the game should teach them first these rules, being hunted is something that annoys those who are undergoing it and then makes it acnhe Reduce the urge to play clash. I think and I hope you all agree that it should be the game to understand these rules through: bans (like not being able to write panties in the globals) and PRIZES. The prizes are fundamental to the game, they do not serve to simplify it but to make actions that improve everyone's play. For example the bonus alloy, without the bonus alloy all th 11 would be in bronze alloy against th 2-3.The booty bonus of war forces us to commit ourselves to winning and the high booty makes everyone run the wars.For this reason to give a prize to those who give it is not a bad idea, people would be more fond of donating, it's like clash teach that giving is right and the reason is simple, it is more convenient for you and your friends.Regarding the speeches on specific requests , This is a dictum, it is not about donating wrong troops, but to reducing the risk of being mistaken, it's something that often happens to give a wrong potion or a giant too, requiring specific troops is not something supercell does not put . Did you mind if you can write a message? That is to specify which troop you want to request and not to talk to the clan. Setting the ability to request a specific troop in the request means improving what is already in clash of clans . Have you understund now ?

the example u made it is wrong becasue driving is an action that will benefit you. The position it takes in relation to my text is therefore apparent to those who receive the request for donation, using your example what should be rewarded is who teaches you to drive, so the driving school that actually earns money .

No?
In real life ( which you've made the comparison before) nothing is free when a friend makes a gift for you in turn another and if this does not bicker with your friend. You make a comparison to real life when I was the first to say what to do with the shareholders. Even now when you make inquiries and players do what you do is not for sympathy but because they expect you to do the same. You do the same because you are constrained by the fact that if they could hunt you. Not in all clans this way and you are all criticizing my clan, my clan is not bad and anyway I did a universal reflection not about my clan so you should not guess it.In clashes still in many clans you are bound to donate but that does not detract from the fact that some would not want because we lose time and elixir. There must be a gain because although it is bound, donating remains a plus for everyone and this is a fact. Moreover, giving the possibility of requesting specific troops also prevents you from taking advantage of those benefits (which are already there), however, without paying attention to what is required. Maybe you've read my post too fast, anyway, remember, you do not have to look for counterpoint to what I say, but to improve a common problem: the weight of donations, because even if it does not cost you anything, the fact remains that At that time, you do not have any advantage if only to others's trust and the clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

You have came up with a new system with "classes" that will only complicate the game. It is not needed.

---

Making new classes would also allow a leader to choose what kind of new members to take in the clan. Specializing also means having player-specific recognitions. You see only negative things without giving space positive things

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

It seems to me that your issue is clan management. If members are donating wrong troops constantly they should be kicked. You have came up with a new system with "classes" that will only complicate the game. It is not needed. I have been a member of several well run clans and I know that there hundreds of thousands more out there. Just because you have problems running your clan does not mean that the games donation structure needs to change. Leaders get bad members and instead of booting them they want to change the way the game works. I'll never understand this.

---

Making new classes would also allow a leader to choose what kind of new members to take in the clan. Specializing also means having player-specific recognitions. You see only negative things without giving space, positive things

All of your reasoning is just excuses for bad clan management. Sounds like you have issues getting people to donate and to donate the right troops. Low level clans often face this problem and it's something any long term player has had to deal with. It all comes down to good leadership. Not everyone is fit to run a clan. You propose to change the game to fit your narrow requirements that will help you. Perhaps you should look closer to home for the real problem. Changing the game won't help.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

All of your reasoning is just excuses for bad clan management. Sounds like you have issues getting people to donate and to donate the right troops. Low level clans often face this problem and it's something any long term player has had to deal with. It all comes down to good leadership. Not everyone is fit to run a clan. You propose to change the game to fit your narrow requirements that will help you. Perhaps you should look closer to home for the real problem. Changing the game won't help.

---

For you am I inviting apologies?I took 4 hours to translate from English to Italian, and I still continue to do so, I have long thought about the donation issue, I talked to so many people. I'm not interested in my clan, if it's a well-organized clan, I'm staying away or I'm going to find one better.Enough with discussions on my clan, if you do not know anything about me and my clan, so why do you judge? If for you the problem of donations does not exist, gifts always with no problems and every time, if for you my idea I regarding the demands of specific troops is not important, give me a logical explanation and not judge me as an individual, you aren't here for this but to explain why my idea is not good and because everything I say to you is not good even though I seem to have given an intelligent answer for any of your answers. If instead you should change your mind about it, please smallow the proud and try to help me spread these ideas .

I never said to change the game but to improve something that already exists

just say thanks to marco and gulio and they will be happy