Build.a.Clan.💥New.Feature.Request ! Best.Idea.is.Here👍

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

An angry trapped hopper can screw up a clan in 7 days easily. Especially a brand new one. Probably do it in one day if the clan is only that old. Im sorry but you are going to have to drop any sort of restriction on movement. The rest of your idea might work but only for a guy trying to get his first few guys and he is going to need some lucky hits.

what if instead of trapping guys trying to force them to be good members the fact that everyone can come and go as they please allows for watching to see who decides to stay under those circumstances. Then you are getting your first guys that are there because they want to be. Unless you get guys that want to be in the clan there is no chance for it so thats the sort of thing you want to filter for.

---

OK point noted.How About whoever leaves after using the feature Cannot Request for troops for 3 days.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dvs

OK point noted.How About whoever leaves after using the feature Cannot Request for troops for 3 days.

---

Then they will go for the "annoy everyone till we get kicked" option. Just so they get past that restriction.

If you then put the restriction on kicked players as well, we will see a whole new type of trolls on global that lures people into a clan promising them "a pot of gold" just to kick them 2 sec after they joined the clan.

Is it just me or is there an unusual amount of capital letters through this post?

"i appreciate your constructive criticism not the imaginary issues stated above" -Dvs

Let me first get something clear. The whole post is a big "what if". You see, this is a imaginary idea that you want in the game, so of course there is going to be imaginary issues that fellow browsers will post. Actually, "imaginary issues" isn't the right word, their replies and ideas to your thread should be known as realistic reasoning. That is, we imagine the idea actually in the game, and think about what would happen if we were in the situation.

And so far, their reasoning and responses have been quite helpful and realistic. I've been reading through the comments and they basically highlight the concerns that I would have for the idea.

I'll give it to you, your idea is somewhat original. However, I do not believe that it will make the game better or friendlier. Apologies for being blunt, but as you appreciate constructive criticism, I aim at making my post as helpful and though-provoking to you as possible.

To me, it seems unnecessary. There's a subsection in the clash of clans forums dedicated to requiting for clans for a reason. As a dev has explained before, there are tons of servers for global chats. You can join the chat in one server, leave, join again and be in an entirely different server. Thus, posting a recruitment request on global is quite pointless. It's probably going to just be a bunch of people spamming chat with their own clan recruitment. If you are desperate for a clan to stay, go to the forums instead.

What is my point? It's that the idea is just an extra step that might not achieve it's goal. It can breed a whole new levels of trolls, both the recruiters and the joiners. When there is already a section dedicated to clan recruitment on the forums, there is no need to have this option in-game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BrianHotshot

"i appreciate your constructive criticism not the imaginary issues stated above" -Dvs


Let me first get something clear. The whole post is a big "what if". You see, this is a imaginary idea that you want in the game, so of course there is going to be imaginary issues that fellow browsers will post. Actually, "imaginary issues" isn't the right word, their replies and ideas to your thread should be known as realistic reasoning. That is, we imagine the idea actually in the game, and think about what would happen if we were in the situation.

And so far, their reasoning and responses have been quite helpful and realistic. I've been reading through the comments and they basically highlight the concerns that I would have for the idea.

I'll give it to you, your idea is somewhat original. However, I do not believe that it will make the game better or friendlier. Apologies for being blunt, but as you appreciate constructive criticism, I aim at making my post as helpful and though-provoking to you as possible.

To me, it seems unnecessary. There's a subsection in the clash of clans forums dedicated to requiting for clans for a reason. As a dev has explained before, there are tons of servers for global chats. You can join the chat in one server, leave, join again and be in an entirely different server. Thus, posting a recruitment request on global is quite pointless. It's probably going to just be a bunch of people spamming chat with their own clan recruitment. If you are desperate for a clan to stay, go to the forums instead.

What is my point? It's that the idea is just an extra step that might not achieve it's goal. It can breed a whole new levels of trolls, both the recruiters and the joiners. When there is already a section dedicated to clan recruitment on the forums, there is no need to have this option in-game.

---

i have read your post and the solution you have suggested that to restart the app and change Global again and again this is no secret at least i knew it.
i have tried recruiting in forums as well but it didn't work as well. so i wonder if you are satisfied with the current situation or Maybe you already have a good Clan is that why you don't like the idea? please do tell.
i Still disagree with you this step may actually help.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dvs

i have read your post and the solution you have suggested that to restart the app and change Global again and again this is no secret at least i knew it.
i have tried recruiting in forums as well but it didn't work as well. so i wonder if you are satisfied with the current situation or Maybe you already have a good Clan is that why you don't like the idea? please do tell.
i Still disagree with you this step may actually help.

---

I have joined a clan a month before. Before that, I roamed from clan to clan trying to situate myself.
Whether someone is happy with their clan or not is more or less irrelevant. There is already a "suggested clans" tab in-game.

If you can't find good clans on the forum, there is much lower chance that you will in global chat. People are jumping around between servers, spammers are doing their stuff, and if we have another option to allow players to advertise their own clan (not that they don't anyways) with this join/reject option, it's just going to complicate things.

Posts on the forum will stay there, and they will be maintained and will be edited/deleted if need be. Chats on global servers are the exact opposite. It's full of trolls, inappropriate behavior, and spam. Adding an option for an official invitation isn't "useless", it's just "unnecessary".

I think not to interrupt in this kind of things.Because this kind of stupid update could ruin clan.😁

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazz596

I think not to interrupt in this kind of things.Because this kind of stupid update could ruin clan.��

---

Yeah sure��& brianhotshot I still don't see what's your problem with the idea itself all you are doing is pointing out the existing problems.

The point is that this idea will have little (if not negative) impact on the game itself as global chat is a mess already. It is also quite frankly pointless as the Forum already has a section for this.

If the forum isn't helping you, there is much less chance that global chat will.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazz596

I think not to interrupt in this kind of things.Because this kind of stupid update could ruin clan.😁

---

Oh it may be my fault last re-edit of the post deleted a part of the post so I guess it didn't make sense. Corrected it now.