New ideas regarding Clan Perks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by UnknownIdentity

By the way you can toggle these features on or off, I forgot to mention that

---

It still doesn't make these ideas viable or good.

Care to explain why you need these ideas? Perhaps if we knew the problems better we can find better more realistic and reasonable solution.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ProfChaos

It still doesn't make these ideas viable or good.

Care to explain why you need these ideas? Perhaps if we knew the problems better we can find better more realistic and reasonable solution.

---

My ideas are the solution to the "trust issues" whenever I run my own clan as the leader

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ProfChaos

It still doesn't make these ideas viable or good.

Care to explain why you need these ideas? Perhaps if we knew the problems better we can find better more realistic and reasonable solution.

---

Prof, OP recently created a topic in Clan Talk and mentioned that a very high level player left his clan during a clan war because he announced to his clan that he will never promote anyone to elder or Co because OP wanted all the control. That thread picked up more criticism than support for OP and the general consensus was that promotions do help clans. Considering OP is trying to suggest strange clan perks that appears to protect him as a leader and debilitate clan members, it appears that he's still hurt by that high level player leaving his clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PyroJames

Prof, OP recently created a topic in Clan Talk and mentioned that a very high level player left his clan during a clan war because he announced to his clan that he will never promote anyone to elder or Co because OP wanted all the control. That thread picked up more criticism than support for OP and the general consensus was that promotions do help clans. Considering OP is trying to suggest strange clan perks that appears to protect him as a leader and debilitate clan members, it appears that he's still hurt by that high level player leaving his clan.

---

Ah, I see. Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by UnknownIdentity

My ideas are the solution to the "trust issues" whenever I run my own clan as the leader

---

Well that's a bit vauge but as I think I stated before not everyone should nor deserves to be a clan leader.

It seems it is not for you, but the good news is there are loads of clans looking for members & you can always belong to one of them.

At this point is say conversation is over as this is clearly a you problem and not a game problem.

Best of luck.

What clan (except yours) would ever do this? This is nothing but an excuse you can use to blame SC so your members don't leave.

Create 9 more accounts then you have total control.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tollboothwillie

What clan (except yours) would ever do this? This is nothing but an excuse you can use to blame SC so your members don't leave.

Create 9 more accounts then you have total control.

---

Or be alone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by UnknownIdentity

Or be alone

---

That's kinda my point. Maybe you could add that to your list.
Members cannot chat or request troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by UnknownIdentity

By the way you can toggle these features on or off, I forgot to mention that

---

well it still bad idea, just please next time please just think about how your idea would work in the game.

I gotta ask, can you see past the end of your own nose with this shortsightedness?

You know what's funny is those first three are attainable by not promoting anyone in the first place. I mean, if you don't want these people to help you run your clan, what's the point in giving them rank in the first place?

You're looking to build the ultimate North Korea clan. UnknownIdentity holds all of the power and no one within his sphere is allowed to see the outside world.

You have to understand how horrible of an idea this comes off as to anyone who isn't you, right?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by UnknownIdentity

New ideas regarding Clan Perks

You must sacrifice your clan level in order to get new features for your own clan.

Disable Kick Feature - This will NOT allow elders or co-leaders except the leader to kick someone one rank below the elder/co-leader. Cost: 2 levels

I prefer to demote people who don't understand when to kick or demote. When demoting, I say why. When elders explain these things to new people, they are more likely to be promoted to co-leader.

Disable Start War Feature for all Co-leaders - This will NOT allow any co-leaders except the leader to start a war at anytime, anywhere. Cost: 3 levels

As with kick. All co-leaders have been around long enough to know when a war search is due, and who to include. NB Red/Green opt status helps. Co-leaders who get it wrong should not have been promoted. I demote them, and demote the co-leader who promoted them.

Disable Promote/Demote Feature for all Co-leaders - This will NOT allow any co-leaders except the leader to promote or demote anyone who is an elder or a member. Cost: 3 levels

Admittedly, it took a while early on to learn that promotions to co-leader should not be cheap. Now I expect co-leaders to know the culture of my clan, which means they know when to promote, and if they don't I demote them.

Increase maximum members by 10 (Up to 100 members, can be purchased 5 times) - It will make more room for new members to join your clan so no need to make a feeder clan. Cost - 5 levels for first purchase, 6 levels for second purchase, 7 levels for third purchase, 8 levels for fourth purchase, and 9 levels for fifth purchase.

Apparently this is "ruled out" and Aspex will grump at me if I encourage you, but I do want room for more members. I have suggested an extra space for every clan level above level 10 (way less than you ask for). If you can get your clan to level 10, you must have some experience in clan management. Alternatively, easier sister-clan transfers, or a holding space for real life friends and family who go inactive, and who I would like to have return whenever they want, except that we keep closing the clan for wars because some people are scared of spies.

see: https://forum.supercell.com/showthread.php/1691-READ-BEFORE-POSTING-Ideas-ruled-out-subforum-guidelines

Currently Ruled Out:
Clan Related:
*Increase clan size: 75 or 100 are most common requests

Disable Leave Feature - This will NOT allow any member, elder or co-leader except the leader to leave the clan anytime, anywhere. Cost: 14 levels

This is widely agreed to be the worst sort of idea ever. Someone in your clan, restrained against their wishes, they can and would do bad things until you relented and let them out.

By the way you can toggle these features on and off.

That's all the ideas I could think about. Any more ideas?

---

Nearly everything is so easily managed in a way that it is self-reinforcing. As Leader, I very very rarely need to intervene any more. Details interspersed above in blue.