Is this a good design?

Attachment 16705
Is this a good base/defense?

Mine used to be:
Attachment 16707



BTW:
Pls join my clan, The Big Orange.

sorry buddy they are both not that good, also upgrade your defences, check out the one ring th7 design also wrong section

Couple of things, first off, on your original base, there's a big level-up icon on it covering everything. Idk if you were hiding your traps or whatever but I can't really review it unless I can see the whole thing. Secondly, your new defense won't win a single battle if they are spread out like that. All that range on the archer towers and mortars that aren't covering anything gets wasted, which brings up to my third thing. Your town hall is exposed. There is no doubt that anyone could get it if they used their full army, if they even use the whole thing. And last of all, wrong section of the forums. You might want to put this in general section.

Now, here's what you can do to solve those things. I like your idea of splitting the base and stretching it out. The problem with that is that the defenses won't be able to take down the troops fast enough. If you somehow merge the three pods, and put a pod in front of your town hall then you should be okay. Idk if I saw this butI thought of this so I'll throw it out to ya. Your barracks, spell factory, and other offensive buildings (the ones that you pay elixir to upgrade) are useless. Put them outside your walls so that your defenses can get a couple of shots at them before they start tearing down walls. Use the walls to make more segments in your base.