Which attack is better golaloon vs witch slap

Was looking at youtube videos on witch attacks and learned about witch slap. Like any attack seems good depending on the right base. So I tried a few raid attacks and did really good. Made the decision to try it in war and i 3 stared the base. Told one of my fellow clanmates to check out my witch slap and that it seem to me a little easier than golaloon. Thats when one of the th11 posted that laloon was alot better and didn't rely on luck and didn't time iut as often. My reply was dont know what luck has to do with anything in this game and thought this game was about strategy. So im looking for your opinion on this attacks. Does witch slap time out alot? Want to learn and practice both attacks. But i really struggle with golaloon. hope to get good info here in the forum. Thanks

I think there is more room for troops to wander with witch slap. With GoLaLoon you have alot of control of the troope for most of the attack while witch slap you are at the mercy of the pathing for most of the attack.

They both have their place but GoLaLoon i think can be understood and perfected more so than witch slap.

All attacks are base dependent. Certain attacks won't work for certain bases. That said witch slap is a fairly reliable spam attack on the right bases. Especially those newer anti air bases with external clumped up ad's.