Need new way to determine opponent in war.

Printable View

April 28th, 2017
pilo72

Need new way to determine opponent in war.

There needs to be a better way to find war opponents. Should be based on town hall level not defenses. There are so many rushed bases with no defense which is creating a huge disadvantage for clans with more developed bases defensively. Not fair to have an opponent with 4 townhall 11 offensively vs 1 townhall 11. Make it based more on townhall level not defense
April 28th, 2017
BrotherCarey

Quote:

Originally Posted by pilo72

There needs to be a better way to find war opponents. Should be based on town hall level not defenses. There are so many rushed bases with no defense which is creating a huge disadvantage for clans with more developed bases defensively. Not fair to have an opponent with 4 townhall 11 offensively vs 1 townhall 11. Make it based more on townhall level not defense

Welcome to the forums, there is and has been an ongoing debate of this topic for like a year. This post belongs in the war subform. And that is also where you will find all the debates and insights to this topic.

Good luck.
April 28th, 2017
Zegaloft

The TH based MM system is flawed.
April 28th, 2017
2222

Quote:

Originally Posted by pilo72

There needs to be a better way to find war opponents. Should be based on town hall level not defenses. There are so many rushed bases with no defense which is creating a huge disadvantage for clans with more developed bases defensively. Not fair to have an opponent with 4 townhall 11 offensively vs 1 townhall 11. Make it based more on townhall level not defense

It also wouldn't be an even match if a max th11 matched a brand new th11, or a max th9 matched a brand new day 1 th9. Your suggestion just exchanges one uneven type of match for another and it has been suggested and discussed many times. Check out the war forum thread and you will find a lot of good discussion about engineering.
April 28th, 2017
pilo72

But at least the new th 9 or 11 would have legit defenses. Huge difference between that and no defense with stacked army
April 28th, 2017
George1971

Yes, but I think this is how:

Rank the line-up by offensive strength; up against the enemy ranked by defensive strength.
April 28th, 2017
femiairboy94

Quote:

Originally Posted by pilo72

There needs to be a better way to find war opponents. Should be based on town hall level not defenses. There are so many rushed bases with no defense which is creating a huge disadvantage for clans with more developed bases defensively. Not fair to have an opponent with 4 townhall 11 offensively vs 1 townhall 11. Make it based more on townhall level not defense

This is an ongoing debate in COC, I've complained about this myself, there has been ideas in form of weight tax, that is, the greater the difference between offense and defense the greater the weight tax. So town halls with high weight tax will be matched up against th with high weight tax which will bring a lot of balance to the game. People will also know the weight tax of course before entering CW's.
April 28th, 2017
Tollboothwillie

Quote:

Originally Posted by George1971

Yes, but I think this is how:

Rank the line-up by offensive strength; up against the enemy ranked by defensive strength.

Just because you have stronger troops than me doesn't mean you can attack better; enemy already ranked by defensive strength.

Most would still think that is my mirror who I should attack.
April 28th, 2017
Roas

Quote:

Originally Posted by femiairboy94

People will also know the weight tax of course before entering CW's.

And you think Supercell will give that information to every player? And if they do, then how long do you think it will take before engineers find the right difference to keep the advantage?