Apple Trees Specifically

Hey everyone... been enjoying this game and ran into a question. My wife and I both play, and on her game, she has a couple of apple trees that died? She can't post for help, it just shows the saw icon. She saw "shout out" once, but her facebook is business related and she doesn't want game info posted to it.

Do trees just die and cant be helped? I tried to help her but when I try to select them, they don't select, there isn't a ! symbol over it ...

Let me know.. do some trees just die or what?

Thanks!

Happy Gaming!

Joe

Trees and bushes each give 3 harvests, then you can attach the ! sign to have them revived. They can be revised once, and then must be replaced.

Thanks.. She said thats disappointing and they are expensive! She said makes her not want to harvest them.

When she harvests them to the point of asking for help, she can put out the sign to request help and when she does that, the next option will give her a loudspeaker/megaphone option to select. If she chooses NOT to use it, it wont post to friends, but the "!" sign will still be out so whoever happens by can help you out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joeinFL

Thanks.. She said thats disappointing and they are expensive! She said makes her not want to harvest them.

---

Hi there, There is actually a chart on hay Day wiki that tells you the cost effectiveness of every tree and bush according to its fruit yield and sale value. Here's a tip if you don't want your farm to be covered with dead trees. All trees and bushes can be harvested three times after which they will wither. You then have the option either to cut them down or affix an exclamation mark which alerts your friends to come and revive them for you. The megaphone is to alert friends through Facebook. Once revived, the tree or bush will fruit again for one final harvest after which it will die and has to be removed by using a saw or axe to cut it down. If, however you leave just one piece of fruit on the tree it will stay alive. You can move it to somewhere on your farm where it remains decorative. What I do is move all my revived trees out around the boundary then I know they are there in an emergency and I can pinch a piece of fruit off them if I desperately need it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woozle

Hi there, There is actually a chart on hay Day wiki that tells you the cost effectiveness of every tree and bush according to its fruit yield and sale value.

---

I Googled the Hay Day Wiki, but couldn't find the chart. Could you post the link for it, please?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kmm04

I Googled the Hay Day Wiki, but couldn't find the chart. Could you post the link for it, please?

---

The link is in my signature... :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kmm04

I Googled the Hay Day Wiki, but couldn't find the chart. Could you post the link for it, please?

---

Hi, sorry neither can I! I believe it was KOLONISTJE1 (moderator) That did the analysis. But I can't find it at the moment.

darn apple tree's :mad: burn them!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MarySC

The link is in my signature... :)

---

thank you! I already found the wiki page but couldn't find what I was looking for on it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woozle

Hi, sorry neither can I! I believe it was KOLONISTJE1 (moderator) That did the analysis. But I can't find it at the moment.

---

Alrighty, I'll search through their posts.. Or maybe just send them a PM lol. Searching through the amount of posts a mod has would be harder than finding a needle in a haystack.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joeinFL

Thanks.. She said thats disappointing and they are expensive! She said makes her not want to harvest them.

---

I try to make all my trees last as long as possible by only taking what I need from them only when I need it. Just because the tree is full of apples doesn't mean it has to be harvested right away. Sometimes if I'm making something and I find I'm one or two apples short, I will just pull the one or two apples and leave the rest on there. That way the trees last longer and my silo doesn't fill up too quickly.

Thanks for the link and the hint about keeping a fruit on it to keep it alive. I just hope the over planting of the crop land doesn't render 'it' useless.. lol.. I know it won't but why can't the fruit trees just keep producing? lol

Thanks again!

Joe

It seems like I am a contrarian on this one! I plant and harvest trees with high turnover. They are high profit items, both in terms of coins and XP, and the rate at which I go through them is limited only by the number of saws I get. In other words, I don't do a big harvest of fruits unless I have enough saws to cover the orchard maintenance, and conversely, if I have lots of saws filling up my barn, I go pick some apples! The whole thing with the apples seems just wrong until you do the math, and then you will see that there is a logic to it.

~powdermonkey

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Patches

I try to make all my trees last as long as possible by only taking what I need from them only when I need it. Just because the tree is full of apples doesn't mean it has to be harvested right away. Sometimes if I'm making something and I find I'm one or two apples short, I will just pull the one or two apples and leave the rest on there. That way the trees last longer and my silo doesn't fill up too quickly.

---

Same here. I do not harvest to sell in the shop. I know is high XP and coins but I just like to save them until I need them for production and boat.

Last night into this morning I got a boat with double order of apple. When I opened HD this morning, my boat asked for total of 6 crates with 12 apples each. OMG. I know I can cast away but I decided to keep it (last night) since I had 30 saws in my barn.

But since I hate being low in saws I bought apples from other farms :))hehe. I only had to cut down 6 trees. I know, I know ... not cost effective but my coin count is high. Coins support my relief in seeing a high number of saws, hehe.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rojocf

Same here. I do not harvest to sell in the shop. I know is high XP and coins but I just like to save them until I need them for production and boat.

Last night into this morning I got a boat with double order of apple. When I opened HD this morning, my boat asked for total of 6 crates with 12 apples each. OMG. I know I can cast away but I decided to keep it (last night) since I had 30 saws in my barn.

But since I hate being low in saws I bought apples from other farms :))hehe. I only had to cut down 6 trees. I know, I know ... not cost effective but my coin count is high. Coins support my relief in seeing a high number of saws, hehe.

---

I am just the same!! I can't cope without plenty of saws and axes in the barn, just in case............:o

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Patches

I try to make all my trees last as long as possible by only taking what I need from them only when I need it. Just because the tree is full of apples doesn't mean it has to be harvested right away. Sometimes if I'm making something and I find I'm one or two apples short, I will just pull the one or two apples and leave the rest on there. That way the trees last longer and my silo doesn't fill up too quickly.

---

I do this too and on the final harvest I try to leave a couple on and move the tree to a 'woodland' area. Same with cherry trees and I buy berries and fruit also.:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spanielgirl

I am just the same!! I can't cope without plenty of saws and axes in the barn, just in case............:o

---

Erm, you do realise the whole point of the saw is to cut things down?! ;) You can always buy more if you suddenly find you need need them, someone will always trade them.

I too hoard them (and get really annoyed with the little people for continually offering to buy them!) but I hoard them to actually use on the trees, and find I always get a few more shortly after using the, anyway.

Early in in the game the fruit trees and bushes are very expensive, but you do need them so it's worth buying a few at a time. Later on they seem almost cheap compared to other items you need to buy.

I do the same thing with axes that I do with saws. Once my saw number approaches the number of trees I have, I go all powdermonkey on 'em because I know I'll be able to remove the deadwood. But if axes or saws are low in number, I just leave the fruit on the plant until it levels out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tweezle

Erm, you do realise the whole point of the saw is to cut things down?! ;) You can always buy more if you suddenly find you need need them, someone will always trade them.

I too hoard them (and get really annoyed with the little people for continually offering to buy them!) but I hoard them to actually use on the trees, and find I always get a few more shortly after using the, anyway.

Early in in the game the fruit trees and bushes are very expensive, but you do need them so it's worth buying a few at a time. Later on they seem almost cheap compared to other items you need to buy.

---

I have apparently misrepresented myself. I hoard saws and axes as I could never have a dead tree or bush if possible, sad but true, but I do use them regularly, when I harvest crops for boat orders of truck orders.
i do sometimes buy fruit, just in case, but I just have to have extra saws and axes for security......Lol