An easy solution to stopping engineered bases is to add war weight to the town halls. Ex: If you're a th9, your war weight would be a minimum of a maxed th8. Let's see some fair play in wars for a change.
Printable View
An easy solution to stopping engineered bases is to add war weight to the town halls. Ex: If you're a th9, your war weight would be a minimum of a maxed th8. Let's see some fair play in wars for a change.
This would penalise the numerous rushed players that there are and just give the advantage to maxers so is another unacceptable solution to add to the pile.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donnie1308
BTW, engineering is as FP as any other playstyle.
So it's fair that in a 20v20 war, an engineered th11 with max troops who is #16 in their lineup can 3* my max th9 who is #4 in my lineup? Why should I waste my time and effort actually playing a game when someone who takes shorcuts is the victor? Not my fault they can't hold their own at their level.
And its not their fault you got out played by a better strategyQuote:
Originally Posted by Donnie1308
engineering a defenseless account is not a shortcut. It's a miserable experience.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donnie1308
Is the victor ?? Come on, clan wars are not the only thing in CoC, their strategy is good only for wars, nothing else.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donnie1308
If you want a discussion on engineering you should post in the Clan Wars sub-forum. That said, what you describe is a wasted attack, IMO.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donnie1308
First; I feel like the engineered problem is heavily overstated.
Next; In our last 5 wars my villages were really the only engineered bases, a 9.5 & a 9 with mostly th7 defenses, and they matched (yes I know that's not exactly how it works) against maxer style bases that had ITs & x-bows respectively.
IMO esems like SC is doing a good job in match making without resorting to more draconian measures as proposed.