"Surrender" option in war

I think a 'surrender' option should be added. During clan war if one of the clans have gave up because they know they cannot win, then they should be able to surrender.
It will result in end of war so that new war would be started. It is better than waiting for battle day to end, knowing that the clan won't win under any circumstances.
Only leader shouldn't be allowed to do it. There should be a voting system in which members in war can vote if they want to surrender or not.
If a clan surrenders than a request should be sent to the opponent clan that if they want to accept it or not.

This is a good idea, though I don't know about the voting part.

What good does it do? You still gave to wait until the end of the war period before collecting winnings and starting another (so a cool down timer would be needed). Otherwise they would have to reduce bonus and xp if clans are collecting faster than every 2 days. As the winning clan I would not want to give up anything. Plus some of the remaining guys might want to snipe.

About the only use I could see is if it freed up guys to do a freindly war while they waited for the cool down timer to run out. If thats what you mean then all good.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

What good does it do? You still gave to wait until the end of the war period before collecting winnings and starting another (so a cool down timer would be needed). Otherwise they would have to reduce bonus and xp if clans are collecting faster than every 2 days. As the winning clan I would not want to give up anything. Plus some of the remaining guys might want to snipe.

About the only use I could see is if it freed up guys to do a freindly war while they waited for the cool down timer to run out. If thats what you mean then all good.

---

You are right but every opponent clan won't surrender in war while some might do. Atleast in some cases war will end earlier if not in every case. And this is a suggestion supercell can do some modifications in it.

it's like nexting on another level

This has already been suggested and there have been reasons for not doing it.
It could lead clans to do a few attacks, surrender and start a new war just for xp.
It also promotes cowardice.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NAWOR14

This has already been suggested and there have been reasons for not doing it.
It could lead clans to do a few attacks, surrender and start a new war just for xp.
It also promotes cowardice.

---

This is tru, and, i think that only the leaders should decide, but it requires both clans to agree to surrender, but the clan which offers to surrender first, should lose the war, and not get any xp, therefore this will not promote xp spamming, or cowardess, also, one clan should have to send the request, the others can choose to accept it, so u cant just opt out. U can send a reason why if u want, but the clan will lose, and not get any xp and loot, and the clan the accept will get all xp and loot.

There should also be a system of marking cowardly clans, clans that surrender alot, like a "Coward" stamp or something, on the description, or somewhere else, somewhere where any1 viewing the clan will be able to see it.

I think that's a good idea

even if this happens and my clan will lose, i wont hit the surrender button and let them wait till the war ends

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hauntedhound

You are right but every opponent clan won't surrender in war while some might do. Atleast in some cases war will end earlier if not in every case. And this is a suggestion supercell can do some modifications in it.

---

The modification would have to be either forfeiting loot (which almost guarantees the winning clan wont agree, its not 'some' like the OP says, it will be almost all that refuse) or a cool down timer before war can start again. And the OP should explain what the purpose is if they have to wait for a cool down timer anyhow.