Please Remove the Elder Kick Cooldown

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bobbychan193

Are you kidding? This was implemented in the first place to prevent / slow down mass kickings of everybody in the clan. In the past, many clans have suffered one elder kicking the rest of the clan, leaving it destroyed.

You should set your clan to "Invite Only" to prevent kicked people from coming back. Also, you should have multiple elders; the demand for kicking shouldn't be THAT high, should it?

---

I agree that this whole cool down thing kinda stinks. This yes ik prevents destroying clans but it makes rules less strict and yes now that this update is one kick per 30min the demand for kick has gone up and well I feel elder is less special :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Engl1shmage

The thing is, smart players wouldn't kick both by "mistake." If they would, they shouldn't be designated as Elder in the first place. The problem remains that cooldowns don't allow Elders the necessary force behind them to protect the clan against certain individuals who seek to destroy the clan. A leader should have more options to give kicking power to certain individuals and the LEADER HIM/HERSELF should decide if a cooldown is even necessary for their clan. Many leaders only promote people they know in real life, so what purpose does an overreaching cooldown serve for them? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. What needs to be implemented is a cooldown toggle switch for each indolividual elder. That way, Elders who already have WARRANTED trust from the leader CAN enforce the rules without a cooldown hindrance, and NEW Elders can be given a cooldown time for as long as the leader determines. It is completely ridiculous that an Elder who has been one for months should have a cooldown same as a newly promoted Elder. This also supports an argument for MORE RANKS. SC has yet to recognize and implement this, but its necessary for the smooth functioning of a clan. I appreciate the goal of a cooldown and what it's intended purpose is, but this is a better way to handle those sporadic elder kickings that people seem to fear. Don't take away power from trusted Elders to solve your problems, figure out how to dispurse it in a more effective, strategic way.

---

That is always the same thing i said before they make the cooldown... SMART PLAYER... And yet i believe there is numerous thread complaining about the SMART TRUSTED WARRANTED ELDERS destroying a clan.... I guess SC already getting sick of those things and decided to make the cooldown...

"If the issue of SMART TRUSTED WARRANTED ELDERS destroyed a clan is resolved before the update, i believe they won't make the cooldown at all" why would they do that just to annoy us.....

We need this call down. Also leeches can still be stopped... Dont donate, if there a leech they go

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nymphoma

As is fairly common, my clan requires donations from its members. Furthermore, we try to protect ourselves from hoppers and leeches by kicking people as soon as they have requested troops more than once with zero donations.

That said, any "kick cooldown" imposed on our elders makes it very difficult to effectively enforce our clan's rules. Also, since many of our elders have lives, there are times when only one elder is available to weed out the hoppers.

I can appreciate that a cooldown helps to prevent elders from abusing their priviledges but, in my opinion, the problems this cooldown causes far outweigh any potential benefits.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Camja11

I hear you, but our clan has been devastated by a clan assassin a couple of times in the last few seasons. While the cool down does limit the elders ability to manage the clan, it prevents heavy damage from clan assassins.

it would be nice if there were more than 3 ranks (leader, elder, member) which you could have your most trusted members able to help manage the clan, but still recognize other members for donations or time served. I think that would be better than a cool down.

---

I agree with both u and that is exactly why supercell should add new roles so we could avoid these assasins and at the same time manage our clan

He only wants to get rid of it,

because he's really pet bear undercover!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SleazyDemon

Unfortunatly i disagree, if this had been implemented at an earlier stage then i might have been able to save 29 memebers of my clan, on three seperate occasions. With this new feature i can have clan mates notify me so i can kick the meneace, or they have time to promote everyone so no more can be kicked. That's all

---

I'm sorry your clan got destoyed this has happened to me 3 times aswell but I still think the cool down is jacking things up

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Archers

I'm sorry your clan got destoyed this has happened to me 3 times aswell but I still think the cool down is jacking things up

---

I think it should stay the same for elders but clan leaders can kick as many as they want.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Archers

I'm sorry your clan got destoyed this has happened to me 3 times aswell but I still think the cool down is jacking things up

---

Well surely if the time is 30 mins you have plenty of time to contact the leader.

Lame, like 2 week ago all my clan is kicked, NO SO PLZ

Please DON'T remove the elder kick cooldown. It's our best defense for stopping the idiots who find decimating clans fun.