Please Remove the Elder Kick Cooldown

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kingliam725

How long is the cooldown ?

---

The cooldown time is 30 Mins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kingliam725

How long is the cooldown ?

---

30 minutes between each kick, and I agree, there should be a timer set by leader how long cooldown lasts.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...g-clan-members
my solution on removing it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bobelement

Maybe leaders can turn on/off elder cooldown for certain people they trust, so no clan destroying, and trusted people can still kick

---

+10 :) I definitely support this over having a 30 minute break between kicks. Suppose two people get into an argument in the clan, and you're the only Elder on. Then who do you kick? Elders need to be able to enforce clan rules for all members of the clan. A cooldown severely limits what an Elder can do when the Leader isn't on. For those clans who gave out "Elder status" for joining or some other absurd reason, maybe an Elder kicking everyone will teach them (and the leader) to only give power to those you can trust. Why would you promote someone and give them rank unless they've earned it and you can trust them to manage the clan IN YIUR ABSENCE?! This is madness, I tell you. Remove the general cooldown, and allow the clan Leader to set the specific period and a toggle switch for each Elder. Problem solved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Engl1shmage

+10 :) I definitely support this over having a 30 minute break between kicks. Suppose two people get into an argument in the clan, and you're the only Elder on. Then who do you kick? Elders need to be able to enforce clan rules for all members of the clan. A cooldown severely limits what an Elder can do when the Leader isn't on. For those clans who gave out "Elder status" for joining or some other absurd reason, maybe an Elder kicking everyone will teach them (and the leader) to only give power to those you can trust. Why would you promote someone and give them rank unless they've earned it and you can trust them to manage the clan IN YIUR ABSENCE?! This is madness, I tell you. Remove the general cooldown, and allow the clan Leader to set the specific period and a toggle switch for each Elder. Problem solved.

---

I still don't see any urgent need to remove them... If two people are arguing, you just have to kick the one that is making the problem..... And if the other one is still going, ask another elder to kick them as well....
the main problem in this is there are people who mass kick.... And what is the point of toggling the cooldown off, it's just like promoting members to clan elders before the update which defeat the purpose of the cooldown....

i've seen numerous thread before about people complaining that their TRUSTED ELDERS (full donate, active) suddenly kicking all of the members out of the blue.... It is the same as toggle.... If it is implemented, just think of it as the same.... You give the previlage of someone to be able to mass kick.... It will be the same as before the updates.... Leaders giving members a previlage of TRUSTED ELDER (toggle cooldown) to be able to mass kick people, and worse enough it's like giving members ability to kick people as well (elders who aren't toggled) and normal members will just sit there waiting someone to kick them.....

Hey rid of it its part of the game u have to chose wisely who to promote

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mikaru

I still don't see any urgent need to remove them... If two people are arguing, you just have to kick the one that is making the problem..... And if the other one is still going, ask another elder to kick them as well....
the main problem in this is there are people who mass kick.... And what is the point of toggling the cooldown off, it's just like promoting members to clan elders before the update which defeat the purpose of the cooldown....

i've seen numerous thread before about people complaining that their TRUSTED ELDERS (full donate, active) suddenly kicking all of the members out of the blue.... It is the same as toggle.... If it is implemented, just think of it as the same.... You give the previlage of someone to be able to mass kick.... It will be the same as before the updates.... Leaders giving members a previlage of TRUSTED ELDER (toggle cooldown) to be able to mass kick people, and worse enough it's like giving members ability to kick people as well (elders who aren't toggled) and normal members will just sit there waiting someone to kick them.....

---

How can you ask another Elder if you're the only one online at the time? What if both of them are arguing and there is no clearcut instigator? I shouldn't have to wait half an hour to kick the other offender. No "trusted" Elder should have to. A cooldown isn't needed. Better clan management tools/systems need to be available to leaders. I agree that the purpose of a cooldown is good, and sometimes it DOES ITS JOB. But if it's a hindrance to others who are upholding the rules of the clan (which it is), it NEEDS TO BE TWEAKED/CHANGED. I'm still surprised this issue hasn't been resolved yet, considering clans aren't all that new.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Engl1shmage

How can you ask another Elder if you're the only one online at the time? What if both of them are arguing and there is no clearcut instigator? I shouldn't have to wait half an hour to kick the other offender. No "trusted" Elder should have to. A cooldown isn't needed. Better clan management tools/systems need to be available to leaders. I agree that the purpose of a cooldown is good, and sometimes it DOES ITS JOB. But if it's a hindrance to others who are upholding the rules of the clan (which it is), it NEEDS TO BE TWEAKED/CHANGED. I'm still surprised this issue hasn't been resolved yet, considering clans aren't all that new.

---

Kick one of them and wait for the other one to either go out or wait for other ppl to kick them... If two people are arguing and you take one of them there will be no argument.... Either you get rid of them later or not is your own choice.....
I will go to a new what if... What if only one of the people who is at fault and the other just defend theirself, and you kick them both by mistake.... Don't say that they'll come back....

what i'm against the toggling is then it will be the same as before the update.... Elders that has been toggled mass kick clan members..... Thus rendering the update useless.....
maybe a shorter cooldown will do the job, but as to toggling them, that would just defeats the purpose of cooldown on the first place..... I'm currently an elder as well... And i don't see any problem so far....

I like it and how it stops hopper but it is annoying when u have hoppers join your clan and you can only kick them once

Yup,agreed the hoppers,non-donaters and recruiters may be back soon,just the clan where i am gets bombed by recruiters