My Idea of How Clan Wars Should be Done

Printable View

August 26th, 2013
RMG

My Idea of How Clan Wars Should be Done

Okay so I did a little thinking and came up with an idea for clan wars. So here it is:

-So you have the clan castle with normal capacity of 50 members. Each clan member will have a contribution of 5 troop capacity. For a total of 250 troops. *could be tweaked a little bit.

-So troops can be donated into the "Clan War Troops" category.

-Now in order for this to be fair, you're gonna need to make sure that both clans accept to the battle. You could send a "battle request" that lasts a given time (maybe 5 hours). Now loot is up for argument, not sure if it should be at a deduction or if it should be a full capacity of loot grab.

Okay, so I came up with the *Loot idea for this whole thing

*So, to implement the "You're only as good as your weakest link", I figured that what if the loot was controlled by how many people donate to the "Clan Battle Troops". Where as this would do one of two things: 1.) Being it would make everyone get involved, instead of having all the top players donating the best troops. Sure, you can do it, but you would only get 50% loot, or something like that. Now if you have majority of your clan donate troops it will increase handsomely. 2.) This would really incorporate friendly teamwork in the clan aspect of the game. Everyone is gonna be trying to help all the clan mates with lower troops; giving help, tips and what not so this way everyone is at the same level. Overall a huge team work kind of thing. What do you guys think?

*1st Idea on the base of battle - So, what I was thinking originally was the clan will vote for a base to defend the clan. Must need a minimum of half the people to vote for the base. (Prevents trolls from voting for each others lower bases) So once this is picked one clan will be termed "ready for battle" and once the other clan is "ready for battle" it will begin. The overall loot could be 1.) Amplified, so this way it could be divided into all the members of the clan. (Amplified to make it enough to want to do this for loot)

2nd Idea for the base of battle - So the clan could build a "Clan Base" and this is the only time where gold/elixir/dark elixir can be donated. You build a base by a people who are voted to build it, almost like a "Clan Council". Now here is the catch to this whole clan base thing, since of course with everyone donating you could build a maxed base in no time. *The bases' cost is amplified by in my opinion 5-10 times the normal cost. The time to build things could be altered, this is touchy, but it would definitely require the "clan teamwork" mentality. The bases' loot would go according to what was above this, but again this is touchy so maybe your suggestions could finalize an idea.

Here is my idea of clan wars, hope you liked the idea, please drop your suggestions I would love to hear your thoughts about this

Thanks everyone, RMG :)
August 26th, 2013
konmal

If i was a developer, which i am not, but if i was my head would be absolutely spinning and reeling at the idea of trying to implement this grandiose idea into clash of clans...
August 26th, 2013
RMG

Quote:

Originally Posted by konmal

If i was a developer, which i am not, but if i was my head would be absolutely spinning and reeling at the idea of trying to implement this grandiose idea into clash of clans...

Wow! Thank you for the great compliment! :)
August 27th, 2013
Calzs34

Quote:

Originally Posted by RMG

Okay so I did a little thinking and came up with an idea for clan wars. So here it is:

-So you have the clan castle with normal capacity of 50 members. Each clan member will have a contribution of 5 troop capacity. For a total of 250 troops. *could be tweaked a little bit.

-So troops can be donated into the "Clan War Troops" category.

-Now in order for this to be fair, you're gonna need to make sure that both clans accept to the battle. You could send a "battle request" that lasts a given time (maybe 5 hours). Now loot is up for argument, not sure if it should be at a deduction or if it should be a full capacity of loot grab.

Okay, so I came up with the *Loot idea for this whole thing

*So, to implement the "You're only as good as your weakest link", I figured that what if the loot was controlled by how many people donate to the "Clan Battle Troops". Where as this would do one of two things: 1.) Being it would make everyone get involved, instead of having all the top players donating the best troops. Sure, you can do it, but you would only get 50% loot, or something like that. Now if you have majority of your clan donate troops it will increase handsomely. 2.) This would really incorporate friendly teamwork in the clan aspect of the game. Everyone is gonna be trying to help all the clan mates with lower troops; giving help, tips and what not so this way everyone is at the same level. Overall a huge team work kind of thing. What do you guys think?

*1st Idea on the base of battle - So, what I was thinking originally was the clan will vote for a base to defend the clan. Must need a minimum of half the people to vote for the base. (Prevents trolls from voting for each others lower bases) So once this is picked one clan will be termed "ready for battle" and once the other clan is "ready for battle" it will begin. The overall loot could be 1.) Amplified, so this way it could be divided into all the members of the clan. (Amplified to make it enough to want to do this for loot)

2nd Idea for the base of battle - So the clan could build a "Clan Base" and this is the only time where gold/elixir/dark elixir can be donated. You build a base by a people who are voted to build it, almost like a "Clan Council". Now here is the catch to this whole clan base thing, since of course with everyone donating you could build a maxed base in no time. *The bases' cost is amplified by in my opinion 5-10 times the normal cost. The time to build things could be altered, this is touchy, but it would definitely require the "clan teamwork" mentality. The bases' loot would go according to what was above this, but again this is touchy so maybe your suggestions could finalize an idea.

Here is my idea of clan wars, hope you liked the idea, please drop your suggestions I would love to hear your thoughts about this

Thanks everyone, RMG :)

I will say this again and again to supercell it's clash of CLANS, not gems, not players! Come on supercell nearly everyone is in favour of these ideas. You tweak them to your liking.