Max badge

Printable View

March 14th, 2017
Samy318

Max badge

This badge would be awarded to a player when he/she maxes a certain town hall level. However this would be independent of the current level - if th2(I'm using th2 because less buildings) requires one level 4 cannon and a level 4 barracks (it's probably not, but suppose) and someone rushed to th3 but then started upgrading, he would get the th2 badge as soon as she/he gets a level 4 cannon and a level 4 barracks.

The badge would look like a bigger version of the max troop icon and would show on a profile to the top left corner of the town hall icon.

50, 250 and 1000 gems will be awarded as part of an achievement for getting the 5th, 8th and 11th badges. Open to suggestions.
March 14th, 2017
SMAEL

I dont think achieving max Th 5 is worth mpre than achieving max th9
March 14th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by SMAEL

I dont think achieving max Th 5 is worth mpre than achieving max th9

Going by that logic, release the beasts II is wall breaker and III is dragon... But is getting wall breakers worth more than wizards?
Anyway, the gems can be changed to be given with each badge - 20, 30, 40, ...
March 14th, 2017
Tiler

Quote:

Originally Posted by SMAEL

I dont think achieving max Th 5 is worth mpre than achieving max th9

This is not a good objection to this idea.

My objection is that it promotes a certain style of gameplay, which SC seems to not want to do. And how would higher level players work? I'm already a TH11, does that mean I'm out of luck? And if someone doesn't max out TH5, are they stuck on the achievement because they can't go back to do it?

All current achievements are something that can always be worked towards. They aren't something that can be missed out on and never attained. And the flaming number/badge things can never be recovered if they're missed
March 14th, 2017
HaveANiceDay

Quote:

Originally Posted by Samy318

This badge would be awarded to a player when he/she maxes a certain town hall level. However this would be independent of the current level - if th2(I'm using th2 because less buildings) requires one level 4 cannon and a level 4 barracks (it's probably not, but suppose) and someone rushed to th3 but then started upgrading, he would get the th2 badge as soon as she/he gets a level 4 cannon and a level 4 barracks.

The badge would look like a bigger version of the max troop icon and would show on a profile to the top left corner of the town hall icon.

50, 250 and 1000 gems will be awarded as part of an achievement for getting the 5th, 8th and 11th badges. Open to suggestions.

Interesting idea. I like it. Just make the display of the badge optional. Also i do not mind an optional rushed badge. In my base, goblins are rushed. I would love to have a rushed badge on my profile indicating that my base is rushed on account of goblins.
March 14th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiler

I'm already a TH11, does that mean I'm out of luck? And if someone doesn't max out TH5, are they stuck on the achievement because they can't go back to do it?

If you go back to the post, I have mentioned that a max badge of a lower than can be attained at a higher level. The mechanics for a th11... I'm not too sure, but maybe when it's introduced all those who have already completed it get it immediately?
March 14th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by HaveANiceDay

Interesting idea. I like it. Just make the display of the badge optional. Also i do not mind an optional rushed badge. In my base, goblins are rushed. I would love to have a rushed badge on my profile indicating that my base is rushed on account of goblins.

I don't think that's a good idea. An engineered base would have to list 100s of rushed badges. If it is rushed only die too goblins, you'll just have the badge of the highest town hall that you have maxed.
March 14th, 2017
Tiler

Quote:

Originally Posted by Samy318

If you go back to the post, I have mentioned that a max badge of a lower than can be attained at a higher level. The mechanics for a th11... I'm not too sure, but maybe when it's introduced all those who have already completed it get it immediately?

Ah, I missed that bit. My bad. How would it handle new structures? My TH stopped being maxed for a TH8 when the bomb tower was released. As far as I know, they can't edit achievement criteria (because of how game center, etc needs to approve them), so max bases could get away with not building new structures and still get the achievement
March 14th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiler

Ah, I missed that bit. My bad. How would it handle new structures? My TH stopped being maxed for a TH8 when the bomb tower was released. As far as I know, they can't edit achievement criteria (because of how game center, etc needs to approve them), so max bases could get away with not building new structures and still get the achievement

Yes, I haven't thought about that... Maybe instead of achievements it uses the system I posted in my reply to SMAEL... But new buildings would not affect higher players who already have the badge... This is compensation for all those cost reductions that SC brought in recently XD
March 15th, 2017
Samy318

And a max badge could also unlock a decoration which gets better in appearance with level of the badge.
March 15th, 2017
lonewolf1234

I am all for some kind of indication of someone's % of maxed current townhall level. But for some reason this does not make me jump for joy. Let us keep it simple.

A ruler on the bottom of the profile area right above first achievement. It would have 11 marks indicating at what %of completion of the climb up the ladder you are.

A maxed th level would put you right below the next th level. Could show the whole .5 thing.

A engineered th 8 base would be indicated low on the ruler like a 3.

And rushed bases would indicate a little below the prior th level.

If you want a achievement that could be done but any badge system seam to complicated than needed.

This ruler way is for ourself and others to at a quick glance you can determine what kind of player someone is. And how much someone has dedicated to completing the game....THE WAY IT WAS INTENDED TO BE PLAYED. (Non-engineered)
March 15th, 2017
Samy318

I just called it a badge, in reality it's just an icon. Your system doesn't sound bad either, it's just a question of sc trying both and adding the one which looks better.
March 15th, 2017
Alphagamer456

Not a great idea
March 15th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alphagamer456

Not a great idea

Explain why. Don't just pass your opinion.
March 15th, 2017
PhilISuppose

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiler

This is not a good objection to this idea.

My objection is that it promotes a certain style of gameplay, which SC seems to not want to do. And how would higher level players work? I'm already a TH11, does that mean I'm out of luck? And if someone doesn't max out TH5, are they stuck on the achievement because they can't go back to do it?

All current achievements are something that can always be worked towards. They aren't something that can be missed out on and never attained. And the flaming number/badge things can never be recovered if they're missed

If you maxed TH8, we can still tell that you maxed TH8 when you are a TH11 because you still have all those things that were part of being a max TH8...

The game could easily calculate which achievements you had already achieved and reward you. Your objection is moot.
March 15th, 2017
Tiler

Quote:

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

If you maxed TH8, we can still tell that you maxed TH8 when you are a TH11 because you still have all those things that were part of being a max TH8...

The game could easily calculate which achievements you had already achieved and reward you. Your objection is moot.

Yes, this was corrected by the OP following that post. I'll publicly rescind that particular objection, though I won't delete what I said. The feasibility objection is one I maintain though. Regarding new structures
March 15th, 2017
SylX

I don't think this is a very fair way to do things. Many people are farmers, rushers, and trophy players, not just maxers.
March 15th, 2017
PhilISuppose

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiler

Yes, this was corrected by the OP following that post. I'll publicly rescind that particular objection, though I won't delete what I said. The feasibility objection is one I maintain though. Regarding new structures

Yeah

That'll teach me for not starting at the end of the thread.
New structures is a fair point, but not an obstacle to an idea that has potential.

(wish I'd never built bombtowers!)
March 16th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by SylX

I don't think this is a very fair way to do things. Many people are farmers, rushers, and trophy players, not just maxers.

It's not something that has to be done. I'm not trying to enforce maxing, but to discourage engineering (note: not end it). Nothing wrong with rushing either... If you're a 9.5 have the th9 badge. If you're a fairly rushed th10 you have the th8 badge. It's that simple.
March 18th, 2017
Samy318

Quote:

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

A engineered th 8 base would be indicated low on the ruler like a 3

In the badge system, if she/he hasn't upgraded the cannon, only the th1 badge will be seen at any level of troops.
March 19th, 2017
Weedbeast10

Do even troops count?
March 19th, 2017
Samy318

Yes, troops also count. Welcome to the forums.