CLAN VILLAGES, CLAN WARS, HERO UPGRADES, and MUCH more! (with some pictures)

*Just realized this thread was bumped for some reason. Not my best work at all, so hopefully it doesn't stay bumped! Stay tuned for a new (actually decent) idea thread soon :) *

Update 2 (edited some)

Sorry for the ALL-CAPPED title, figured it might get your attention :) Before I start, I just want to say I love this game and love everything Supercell provides to us for free! The suggestions I am sharing are things I think would improve the fun factor of the game greatly and add more replay value to keep people playing for a long, long time!

Also, I realize most of if not all of these topics have been brought up before by others, and much of it is in the sticky, but this was a list I made of all the things I think would be great to add (WITH DETAIL).

So here it goes, and let me know what you think! Will update more of this later with pictures, want to make some for the Clan Village and Wars idea.

CLAN VILLAGE

• Every clan has a separate village they can visit to test attack strategies, attack clan mates' villages, and have their own village attacked.

• From the clan village, all clan mates can enter, customize it's aesthetics, and be given several different options:

1. Attack specific clan mate (then can choose who to attack, no troops lost and no resources stolen)
2. Troop donation farm (clan mates who visit the clan village can choose which troops they want from a list of available troops and put them in their own clan castle. So if I go to the clan village and donate 10 dragons (will be a max per day), then a clan mate can visit the village and take 1 dragon for their own. This would help against getting troops you don't want/level 1 troops in a wide-range clan.
3. Decorate clan village (if given permission)

• This whole option could be tweaked and perfected until clan wars are implemented, then the clan village could have other uses as well in defending.

CLAN WARS

• There are several ideas out there for clan wars (one I saw recently was one similar to my idea, with a little different twist at 4 clan members attacking was Tillie002's idea, which would help with lag issues I'd imagine, check it out here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...e-of-your-clan! ).

• My idea for clan wars would be more active and real time rather than most ideas, which would still be attacking individual bases 1vAI. It would involve the clan village. Clan villages can be attacked by other clans! Clans leaders could scope out and choose another Clan Village they would want to attack, and if they are able to (shield isn't down, they are not currently battling another clan, etc.) then the attacking Clan could prompt a JOIN ATTACK QUEUE in clan chat. The QUEUE would last for 30 minutes, and people in the clan could have the option on their iPhone to receive a push notification that an attack would be underway in 30 minutes, just so they know and could join.

• The same push notification would be sent to the clan of the village being attacked! This way they could defend their base and use their troops as well to defend (they'd come out of the Clan Castle/Town Hall for the Clan Village).

• Depending on lag issues, 1 option is to have a few members attack and a few defend, but the replay could be shared.

• Once people join the QUEUE, they would be looking at the soon-to-be-attacked Clan Village with a countdown timer at the top (for 30 minutes). If someone joined with 5 minutes to go, then it would say 5 minutes. Clan chat would also appear on the left so clan mates could talk about points of attack, strategy, or how to defend.

• Once the timer reaches 0, the attacking team can send out troops and try to take it over much like a normal base. As mentioned in the above section, Clan Villages would be a little bigger, but the thing that would make it much, much harder would be the defending team's troops.

• If the attacking team 3 stars the opposing village, they CLAIM the village and get a bonus for however long they keep it under their control. The bonuses could range from 1%-10% bonus to personal base defense, personal attacks, loot received, etc. The % would be determined by the level of the base. If someone takes over the top clan for instance, they would receive the highest bonus. The lower clan villages would receive a low bonus.

• If the attacking team receives 1 or 2 stars, they don't claim it but get Clan-wide loot (maybe 10,000 gold each-100,000 gold each depending on the difficulty and number of stars).

• If the defending team prevents a CLAIM, they are rewarded with a week long shield and loot as well (depending on how many stars).

• Clan Bases can only be attacked by the minimum of 10 people to prevent 1 person attacking a friend's base for free loot. Also, Clans could only attack a set number of bases a week (1-3).

CLAN OPTIONS/CLAN CHAT OVERHAUL

• Separate donation requests/replays from chat tab, and give Elder Chat

• Different titles besides Elder and Leader (Co-Leader, Veteran, etc.)

• Options custom set for various positions (number of invites/kicks, chat options, clan village options, etc.)

SINGLE PLAYER MISSIONS

• Complete overhaul of the single player game

• People who complete all 150 stars of the original single player game get a unique decoration/trophy for their base

• The last level of the new missions would have a giant treasure chest appear in the middle after 3 stars and once destroyed, would give a reward. The reward could be as common as a large chunk of gold or as rare as a Hero Item! Could be redone once every week/month.

HERO UPGRADES

• Ability to name your heroes (minimal, but adds more customization to the game)

• Hero Items would be rare drops from the last single player mission OR from completing new Achievments, and could be equipped to your Hero (like a flaming sword, ice bow, dragon scaled chestplate, etc) that would give minor stat boosts, decreased sleep time, but mostly a cool look to show off. Would give incentive to do new single player missions or complete hard achievements.

Such as:

For Barbarian King
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/f/20...99-d47uh6y.jpg
For Archer Queen
http://www.g-wiki.net/images/thumb/9...w_defenses.png
http://i42.tinypic.com/13z3n2v.jpg

• Heroes at Level 40 look a lot more intimidating and different aesthetically than at Level 1 (besides just gauntlet and pad)

http://www.comicbookreligion.com/img...arian_King.jpg

• New Hero (Goblin Hero) but can only have 2 active heroes at once (click altar to cycle/choose)

http://coolvibe.com/wp-content/uploa...oblin-Lord.jpg
OTHER TWEAKS

• Daily/Weekly/Monthly Rewards!!!! I think it would be great for the game like attacking 20 bases in 1 day for 5 gems, or donate 500 troops in 1 week for 5 more gems, etc.

• Off/on option for mines/pumps to turn off auto collect with click (EDIT: Extra note because this was somehow confusing to various posters... I am NOT suggesting to allow us to turn off the production of resources. I am suggesting to allow us to either choose to collect our resources by touching the mine/pump once (automatically, like how it is now), or to have no coin/elixir appear above the mines/pumps so that we have to click them AND THEN hit collect resource (such as it is now if you are below the automatic retrieval).

• Customizable/preset queues for troop creation

• LEAGUE BONUSES DRAMATICALLY INCREASED

• Dark Elixir loot bonuses at Gold League

• Walls/Hero upgrades/troop upgrades gives experience

• Every 10 levels gained of experience gives a better prize (gems, unique decorations, etc.)

• Balloons, Hog Riders, and Valkyries increased in power (since they are extremely rarely used in fights)

• Balloons move faster

• Level 8 Wizard Towers

• Level 7 Mortars (might be level 8, will have to check)

• VILLAGE BUILDING SCREEN LIKE ON CLASHOFCLANSBUILDER.COM

Edit: Took out some of the tweaks after hearing back from some of the intelligent and mature posters in this thread, like Sevans, etc. Took out

• Traps don't require builders

• Walls don't require builders
• Can use elixir to also upgrade walls but costs 2x as much
• Barracks can still be used while upgrading
• Heroes can still be used when upgrading (like campfires)

All of these bullet points I have reconsidered and changed my stance on, so I excluded them from the suggestions. Thanks!

i liked your pics and the ideas are awesome too.

Thanks :) Will add more pics later, maybe should have split this up into a couple separate treads hehe

Love the idea,Really good.

cool defiantly the best clan villa/war post ive seen

Sorry to rain on this parade, adding pictures and bullet points isn't going to sugar coat that these have all been suggested and are in the sticky. And not much detail has been expanded on as it kinda of days it in the request.

That aside.

🔹whats the point in naming heros? Just keep them how they are!
🔹I like the introduction of new weapons, but they are hero representations of tier one troops, they are bigger and badder, but having weapon changing option will make this post at the end, include normal troops have the ability to switch out their weapons. But I like the SP reward.
🔹Dont have upgrading heros able to fight, its all about making the choice to do so or not, upgrading means you won't have them, but they will be stronger, also to max out the hero takes nearly 300 days of downtime, and we all know this is a gem introduced troop, and you forget we also had a huge reduction in price, and in time to upgrade. Once again SC gives players something cool, and its under looked and yet players want more, I doubt you will max heros, so why asking for a change in appearance at level 40? Keep them how they are.

🔸Barracks upgrading but still being used, once again its choice, the new troop, and extra training space or barracks down for a few days, nope everyone has had to make these choices why change it now? Because it easier for you.
🔸An on off button on pumps? Your kidding right? When players quite they will turn of pumps, as when they sleep, when they are away, this would litrally kill the community! Silliest idea ever! Please save yourself and say a friend who is Th1 level one made this suggestion.
🔸Traps don't require builders, and if they do i wouldn't know, always save one builder for walls!
🔸Valks have litrally just had a damage update in the previous update.

🔺Upgrade walls with elixir? And without a builder, these are two game changing updates it would rid players of loot in multiplayer searching only bases that would be attacked is abandoned bases

Single player does need a revamp!
The clan base i think is in the works, and I know that SC have a clan vs clan idea they are waiting for the community to die before introducing, it must be their their big idea to bring players back.
Seperate clan chats is a great idea, but will be implemented as a side update in a slow update season i think.

i think I have highlighted the stuff that sticks out to me.

Apologies if this post is negative, I'm a level 94 player who understands the big picture, and the diffrence between needed updates and I want suggestions.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gulyas1

Sorry to rain on this parade, adding pictures and bullet points isn't going to sugar coat that these have all been suggested and are in the sticky. And not much detail has been expanded on as it kinda of days it in the request.

That aside.

whats the point in naming heros? Just keep them how they are!
I like the introduction of new weapons, but they are hero representations of tier one troops, they are bigger and badder, but having weapon changing option will make this post at the end, include normal troops have the ability to switch out their weapons. But I like the SP reward.
Dont have upgrading heros able to fight, its all about making the choice to do so or not, upgrading means you won't have them, but they will be stronger, also to max out the hero takes nearly 300 days of downtime, and we all know this is a gem introduced troop, and you forget we also had a huge reduction in price, and in time to upgrade. Once again SC gives players something cool, and its under looked and yet players want more, I doubt you will max heros, so why asking for a change in appearance at level 40? Keep them how they are.

Barracks upgrading but still being used, once again its choice, the new troop, and extra training space or barracks down for a few days, nope everyone has had to make these choices why change it now? Because it easier for you.
An on off button on pumps? Your kidding right? When players quite they will turn of pumps, as when they sleep, when they are away, this would litrally kill the community! Silliest idea ever! Please save yourself and say a friend who is Th1 level one made this suggestion.
Traps don't require builders, and if they do i wouldn't know, always save one builder for walls!
Valks have litrally just had a damage update in the previous update.

Upgrade walls with elixir? And without a builder, these are two game changing updates it would rid players of loot in multiplayer searching only bases that would be attacked is abandoned bases

Single player does need a revamp!
The clan base i think is in the works, and I know that SC have a clan vs clan idea they are waiting for the community to die before introducing, it must be their their big idea to bring players back.
Seperate clan chats is a great idea, but will be implemented as a side update in a slow update season i think.

i think I have highlighted the stuff that sticks out to me.

Apologies if this post is negative, I'm a level 94 player who understands the big picture, and the diffrence between needed updates and I want suggestions.

---

Not sure if you noticed, but I state just that in my intro, that these ideas have been suggested and are in the sticky. I'm trying to present it in a different way and provide ideas I personally like. Not sure why the fact that I try to make it more enjoyable to read with pictures and bullet points is so offensive to you (not to mention you complain about me using bullet points and use them yourself :confused:), but as I'm sure Supercell knows, no matter what you do, someone will find fault with whatever you do.

Now onto your ideas.

I understand and see your points about the hero/barracks upgrades and not being able to use them while upgrading. Fair enough.

I mentioned an update to mines and pumps, but you misread what I wrote. You said: "An on off button on pumps? Your kidding right? When players quite they will turn of pumps, as when they sleep, when they are away, this would litrally kill the community! Silliest idea ever! Please save yourself and say a friend who is Th1 level one made this suggestion." What I was actually suggesting was an option to allow us to click on mines and pumps without collecting resources. Allow us to be able to manually collect resources because sometimes I don't want to collect resources and accidentally do. Or sometimes they block the view of something I'm trying to move. Seems like a simple fix. Obviously I wouldn't suggest what you thought.

Your post was negative yes, much of it could have been stated much more critically and maturely, but whatever. Many of your suggestions were good however. I too understand the big picture and have been playing for about 10 months constantly. I too understand the difference between the needed updates and I want suggestions, but as you can see very clearly from my intro, this is one of those I Want Idea Threads. These are ideas I subjectively would like, and not everyone will. Nature of the game. And at the end of the day, it's a thread on a forum, about a game :P Just some ideas. Thanks for your reply though.

Lol most of them r in the sticky lol

I think these would change the feel of the game too much that people can have customizable heroes

i just stopped reading after a while, too many flaws:
1. traps can already be placed/made without builders
2. SC clearly ruled out anything resembling a sandbox mode because that would ruin any form of learning attack strategies without cost to the user
3. SC clearly ruled out any overlap between the usage of elixer and gold, so why would they allow both to be used on walls
4. being able to use barracks/heroes while theyre upgrading takes away the need to spend gems to finish their production and therefore would take money away from SC
5. turning off mines and collectors? who could possibly benefit from that? the economy of the game is way too low already and even if someone quits, who cares then if they lose resources that they are never going to return to collect?
abandoned village resources are the only aspect of the game that keeps it playable otherwise resources would be even more scarce

there were ideas that I like so dont think im just sitting here being negative about everything. but Im not going to be optimistic about countless requests for things SC has already stated will never happen. If you say you looked through the sticky for most of it then you would know what on your list was rules out.

Mastermind you handled that well, IMO in post #7

I agree with (almost) all of what you're saying!

I'd love to see clan wars implemented somehow, if for no other reason than because this game is called clash of CLANS and currently the only clan activity is requesting/receiving troops (that, and/or getting a bunch of people with high trophy counts to win the season, but that applies to a tiny percent of people that are playing (and it doesn't apply to me I'm a TH7 upgrading to 8))

naming heroes and blades would be nice they are supposed to be epic troops! getting to name yours would make it more than a statistic and let you customize your game more. the only problem I see in letting people name anything on a game where others will see it is having the name be a curse or a dis or something of the like.

about your other tweaks section, I have a comment for most of the ideas so I'm reposting it here

OTHER TWEAKS

• Daily/Weekly/Monthly Rewards!!!! I think it would be great for the game like attacking 20 bases in 1 day for 5 gems, or donate 500 troops in 1 week for 5 more gems, etc. {Okay this could work with just little rewards like that, as long as it's not worth too many gems}

• Barracks can still be used while upgrading (hate upgrading barracks because of this) {nope sorry but definitely not... this is one of those things that could have been different when Supercell made the game, but should remain as it is to be fair}

• Off/on option for mines/pumps to turn off auto collect with click {I've never had a problem with collecting resources always, but as long as the on/off button wasn't put in an annoying spot where i could click it accidentally, I wouldn't have a problem with this being implemented}

• Can use elixir to also upgrade walls but costs 2x as much {NOPE it is how it is, like the barracks...}

• Customizable/preset queues for troop creation {YES. this would be step one of having presets. step 2 would be having preset village setups}

• Traps don't require builders {they already don't}

• Walls don't require builders {Nahhh it is how it is. stuff like this that people ask to change would change the game not in a good way (not in a bad way either, necessarily. It would just change the game for little purpose other than individual whims XD)}

• LEAGUE BONUSES DRAMATICALLY INCREASED {Yeah the looting bonus is very minimal}

• Dark Elixir loot bonuses at Gold League {yes please!}

• Walls/Hero upgrades/troop upgrades gives experience {meh I don't really care about exp. so this would be fine}

• Every 10 levels gained of experience gives a better prize (gems, unique decorations, etc.) {and this would be the thing that makes me care about exp.}

• Balloons, Hog Riders, and Valkyries increased in power {okay idc}

• Balloons move faster {meh it is how it is but speed upgrading would be okay... it's just one of their drawbacks (try a rage spell + balloons!)}

• Level 8 Wizard Towers

• Level 7 Mortars {aren't these a thing already?}

• VILLAGE BUILDING SCREEN LIKE ON CLASHOFCLANSBUILDER.COM {yes. with save for at least two base designs you can switch between}

I love how Supercell actually listens to this stuff usually it's great that they are so willing to hear the community!!!

NOTE TO MASTERMIND(user):
if you edit your original post to get rid of errors or things that have been ruled out then more people will read what you are saying instead of just the errors

Welcome to the forums please read mr sticky

Maybe the barb kings blades like the ice blade should have effects as the ice blade would act as a freeze spell.:cool:

I think there should be a town hall level 11 like the walls are level 11 (electric!) and when you get attacked it should send a gigantic shock that would do like 100 to 200 damage to all troops and you could upgrade the damage (not the town hall!) and it would have x2 for pekka since its weakness is electricity. You could put it like the Xbow: ground units at long range and all units at reduced range. And it is only 1 shock.

They are all good, tho in sticky, you went in detail unlike people that go, I want Clan Wars as a thread and that's it, this is very detailed. Except no elixir for walls then everyone would have max walls, and less money for SC.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

Lol most of them r in the sticky lol

---

He knows that.....hes just explaining it in more detail....

Thanks all, appreciate all the answers! I don't mind at all that people disagree with some of my points if you respond in a mature way and tell me why (and in many cases even change my position on the issue) like many of you have done here on page 2. It's when people, like the poster on page 1, respond in an extremely negative way that makes me question the maturity and state of the poster.

• I have changed my opinion about barracks/heroes being upgraded and being able to train/use troops. Thanks for the thoughts about that! I agree.
• For some reason, I had no idea about traps not requiring builders. Not sure why it took me 10 months to figure out, silly of me. 1 benefit of this thread.
• Some people still don't understand what I meant about the on/off switch for mines/pumps, even though it is stated rather clearly. I am NOT suggesting to allow us to turn off the production of resources. I am suggesting to allow us to either choose to collect our resources by touching the mine/pump once (automatically, like how it is now), or to have no coin/elixir appear above the mines/pumps so that we have to click them AND THEN hit collect resource (such as it is now if you are below the automatic retrieval).
• I will update the original post to include some changes.
• Just about every thread has posters write "sticky" or a sarcastic, smart-Alec comment about "welcome to the forums". I clearly stated at the top that most of these ideas are written in the sticky, but the sticky includes one simple idea like "clan wars" and I go into detail about how I PERSONALLY would like to see it implemented. The rest of the tweaks are things, once again, that I personally would like to see included of the things in the sticky. The nature of this post, like most, is subjective. If it offends you too much, simply don't respond. Thanks. Lots of negativity in this sub-forum, appreciate the few mature posters however.

i like the pics.

There should be a barracks level 11 and the troop should be a ninja. It should throw ninja stars and it can throw them over the wall like an archer can shoot her arrows over the wall. And there should be a mortar level 8.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaz456

There should be a barracks level 11 and the troop should be a ninja. It should throw ninja stars and it can throw them over the wall like an archer can shoot her arrows over the wall. And there should be a mortar level 8.

---

Interesting idea :) Just like a buffed up archer than? Kind like a wizard then hehe. Not sure they'd make that, but appreciate the input!

Read sticky. Improvement for barb king should be nxt time cuz its fine now we need more time to continue uograding and catch up to the updates :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Streamshot004

Read sticky. Improvement for barb king should be nxt time cuz its fine now we need more time to continue uograding and catch up to the updates :)

---

As stated many times throughout this thread, I have read it many times, but once again stating the things I PERSONALLY would like to see and which of the stickies I think would make the game better, as well as going into detail about many of the issues, something the sticky doesn't do.

Fair point about the king, all these ideas don't have to be in the next update or even several, just down the road. Plus the ideas I am suggesting for heroes have nothing to do with upgrading them as you suggest. They involve naming them, aesthetic updates, and hero items. Nothing to do with levels. Thanks for your input though!

Like your clan village ideas, but im not so sure about the clanwars system......

I like the goblin hero idea. I got to say the pictures are what make your threads stand out!

hey mastermind it's me titan i really like your idea.i think supercell should do this things so the barbarian king can be cooler and yes i really like your idea!I want some Clan Wars i wanna see how our clan goes with it!

I love all of you ideas. BUT I am no entirely sure about the Clan war and Clan village. It is kind of choppy maybe the rest of us posters and you can come up with some stuff to put more detail to it.

You've got some interesting ideas for sure.

The thing I want more than anything right now is clan alliances.

I like the idea for switching between a wide variety of heroes, by tapping their alters to rotate between them.

It would add a lot more variety to the game if we could choose two active heroes from a selection of several different choices.

I also like your hero upgrade ideas.

These are some of the things that will lead to a mature COC down the road.

Questions--What would you do with a captured village? Do you just take as many as you can, to see how many you can take? I imagine the strongest clans would hold the most property. If someone takes yours, how would you get a new one?

Awh, i thought this was a new mastermind post so was kind of disappointing there are no clan war pics :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ptow

i just stopped reading after a while, too many flaws:
1. traps can already be placed/made without builders
2. SC clearly ruled out anything resembling a sandbox mode because that would ruin any form of learning attack strategies without cost to the user
3. SC clearly ruled out any overlap between the usage of elixer and gold, so why would they allow both to be used on walls
4. being able to use barracks/heroes while theyre upgrading takes away the need to spend gems to finish their production and therefore would take money away from SC
5. turning off mines and collectors? who could possibly benefit from that? the economy of the game is way too low already and even if someone quits, who cares then if they lose resources that they are never going to return to collect?
abandoned village resources are the only aspect of the game that keeps it playable otherwise resources would be even more scarce

there were ideas that I like so dont think im just sitting here being negative about everything. but Im not going to be optimistic about countless requests for things SC has already stated will never happen. If you say you looked through the sticky for most of it then you would know what on your list was rules out.

---

Guys,stop reviving old threads.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shadowkungfu

Guys,stop reviving old threads.

---

You just revisited the revisited thread... It was almost off the list now its back. I think mastermind will make a updated version of this soon though

Hahaha! I was wondering why Mastermind was asking for a level 7 mortar!

I love your idea about the heroes

Lol, why did this thread get bumped? :) Uggg, definitely not my best work, just kinda blurted out ideas back then instead of making detailed proposals. Wish I could delete it! Let's all agree to let it die hehe.

On a brighter note, just starting a new (actually decent compared to this one) thread, like the Quests and Base Builder one, so stay tuned!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Lol, why did this thread get bumped? :) Uggg, definitely not my best work, just kinda blurted out ideas back then instead of making detailed proposals. Wish I could delete it! Let's all agree to let it die hehe.

On a brighter note, just starting a new (actually decent compared to this one) thread, like the Quests and Base Builder one, so stay tuned!

---

Amazing work MasterMind!

They should add more single players maps until you reach the last map where you fight a base with the Goblin King. Once you defeat it, you control it.

The only thing I liked was that you can attack clan mates and upgrade barackz while training troopz. The new heroes will ruin the game by making the game harder for newcomers and changing the look of the game. Also I like the winning 5 gems ...... Nice thoughts though