Introducing: The Forum Reputation System

Has this started already? I have more than 50 posts but no ability to add reputation ratings to posts.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gw2kpro

Has this started already? I have more than 50 posts but no ability to add reputation ratings to posts.

---

Are you on mobile?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by N1NJ4W4RR10R

I think that (at least in terms of pointing out trolls or great forumers) this was intended to help those newer to the forums who may be fooled easily by trolls, or just don't know which forumers are....less trolly I guess. Right now it seems that a fair few of the fresh spawns check the post count and base their assumptions off that (eg, a fresh spawn sees a forumer with 5k posts and assumes they must be great forumers). The rep system could (potentially) change that to the fresh spawn checking the rep of a forumer and basing their assumptions off that.

Hopefully that makes sense, sorry if it doesn't.

---

That's what post count does already; I think reason 1 in my mega post earlier makes more sense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Are you on mobile?

---

No, regular PC. Scrolled through a lot of pages on here seeing if I was the only one and didn't see any discussion on it.

i really don't get the idea of launching this feature since i believe that title shows the reputation enough for a person, however, like forum senior or superstar or legend cant be achieved through 3-4 days even earning the title takes time then why this reputation system? albeit i'm not against it i'm just curious.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DiDAcTicAl

i really don't get the idea of launching this feature since i believe that title shows the reputation enough for a person, however, like forum senior or superstar or legend cant be achieved through 3-4 days even earning the title takes time then why this reputation system? albeit i'm not against it i'm just curious.

---

well, i got ur point... but spammer like me (did i call myself a spammer!!) can achieve Forum Elder/Superstar within 2-3 months !

but the idea that keeping Reputation system alive is to distinguish between forumers like me (spammers) and those who really deserve special titles/honor for their great contributions for this forum :)

note: i didn't wanna say someone spammer, that's why gave example as 'I'

Sorry if this has been asked but... is there a way to check your own reputation data? I saw something about a reputation tab in your profile, but mine doesn't appear to have one. (Unless I am looking in the wrong spot). Does it show up if nobody has given you any reputation adds yet?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TommyTx

Sorry if this has been asked but... is there a way to check your own reputation data? I saw something about a reputation tab in your profile, but mine doesn't appear to have one. (Unless I am looking in the wrong spot). Does it show up if nobody has given you any reputation adds yet?

---

yes, u'll not get reputation tab until u get one :)

same as infraction tab i guess :)

So, we got official SC staff, mods, game specialists, post counts and forum titles...why the reputation system again?

I see this being manipulated by the buddy system, especially when the message you get for giving a reputation point states," congratulations on giving a reputation point and now I hope you receive one in kind."Sounds like a scratch my back I'll scratch yours set-up to me

I think i'll fail big time on this :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by up2gutsNglory

I see this being manipulated by the buddy system, especially when the message you get for giving a reputation point states," congratulations on giving a reputation point and now I hope you receive one in kind."Sounds like a scratch my back I'll scratch yours set-up to me

---

Or we will get the forum wolves who group attack issues they don't want heard. Down vote the snot out of a the OP post and upvote the snide comments that follow.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

yes, u'll not get reputation tab until u get one :)

same as infraction tab i guess :)

---

Thank you for the clarification!

Where reputation points will have a real effect is on posts from members who want up the food chain of status. Those of us that post what we think and read what is relevant to us will carry on doing so.Members that spam or troll will wear a red square with pride and members with polarizing views/opinions will be easy to spot and thus lead you too the best threads

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

I will make a case for keeping this system out of off-topic (if it isn't abandoned all together).

This forum is for Clash of Clans. Reputation should be earned for game knowledge and not quick witted comments in a sub-forum not related to the game.

---

I'm still waiting on that case, just saying. Not trying to be rude, but I really would like to have a shot at justifying my stance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

I'm still waiting on that case, just saying. Not trying to be rude, but I really would like to have a shot at justifying my stance.

---

I am not sure what you want out of this. It was my opinion. My opinion is people come to a game forum to discuss the game. The Reputation system (which I think is an astronomical joke) should reflect people having a sound reasoned comment about game and/or device issues to make the game work. My opinion, from what I have seen, Aspex should have a huge reputation. I doubt that happens, but should.
This feature is new and I don't go to OT/games very often anymore but I don't think a funny comeback to a comment there should advance someone's reputation.
Strictly my opinion. I don't have any specific happenings.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

I am not sure what you want out of this. It was my opinion. My opinion is people come to a game forum to discuss the game. The Reputation system (which I think is an astronomical joke) should reflect people having a sound reasoned comment about game and/or device issues to make the game work. My opinion, from what I have seen, Aspex should have a huge reputation. I doubt that happens, but should.
This feature is new and I don't go to OT/games very often anymore but I don't think a funny comeback to a comment there should advance someone's reputation.
Strictly my opinion. I don't have any specific happenings.

---

So your case for no reputation in OT is that witty comments shouldn't be upvoted.

Ergo two things:
1. Witty comments shouldn't be upvoted anywhere at any time because they don't deserve to be.
2. Off-Topic consists of nothing but spam and witty comebacks.

Since clearly neither are true, the basis for your case is completely and utterly flawed, and thus has no ground. Clearly, giving off-topic the reputation system is nothing but a good thing, as it would allow for OTers to honor those who provide insight into theories on games such as TvMs, and provide incentive to add to discussion in Off-Topic.

I'm borderline on downvoting your post because that's pretty offensive to OTers to make such an assumption.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

So your case for no reputation in OT is that witty comments shouldn't be upvoted.

Ergo two things:
1. Witty comments shouldn't be upvoted anywhere at any time because they don't deserve to be.
2. Off-Topic consists of nothing but spam and witty comebacks.

Since clearly neither are true, the basis for your case is completely and utterly flawed, and thus has no ground. Clearly, giving off-topic the reputation system is nothing but a good thing, as it would allow for OTers to honor those who provide insight into theories on games such as TvMs, and provide incentive to add to discussion in Off-Topic.

I'm borderline on downvoting your post because that's pretty offensive to OTers to make such an assumption.

---

Again, it is about something other than Clash of Clans in those forums. It isn't about COC. If you think that is offensive Down vote me. I could note care anyless. It won't change what I post. Let them earn docates........

Radiating, another forum I am on, you don't get an increase in post count for anything posted in the off-topic area. As Martvol said, OT has nothing to do with the game. That forum has a strong OT community, no one cares about getting anything in return for posting in OT.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

Again, it is about something other than Clash of Clans in those forums. It isn't about COC. If you think that is offensive Down vote me. I could note care anyless. It won't change what I post. Let them earn docates........

---

That's just as flawed an assumption. There is NOTHING in the OP that saying even a hint about Clash of Clans, not even a mention or an implication that it's meant just for Clash of Clans. Ergo, there's zero reason not to implement it in OT, even after the arguments that you have made.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

That's just as flawed an assumption. There is NOTHING in the OP that saying even a hint about Clash of Clans, not even a mention or an implication that it's meant just for Clash of Clans. Ergo, there's zero reason not to implement it in OT, even after the arguments that you have made.

---

You are involved in a thread in OT where Lach discusses it. I will let you go read his Easter egg thread for his comments.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

You are involved in a thread in OT where Lach discusses it. I will let you go read his Easter egg thread for his comments.

---

Huh. Funny you mention that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by brandonpj21

Not a fan of the tease, Lach. Posting the sneak peek in OT for all of us to get excited about, and then telling us that we are the only subforum that won't be allowed to have it.

All I can do is kindly ask that you reconsider, but the reasoning behind not giving OT the reputation system works equally well for any other subforum.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bresn

The hypocrisy is that OT is denied because we would vote each other like a contest despite the fact we're literally the mature part of the forum and would know better than to downvote and upvote for petty things. The same reasoning to disable this feature backfires because people in generals would follow mob mentality for rep and let's just say this will basically make the forums more toxic. Either enable for OT or disable the thing completely.

it's almost disbelief that we would get teasered on a feature we're actually excluded from and I don't know how anyone who cares about the rep system would react here.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by brandonpj21

I'm sure the mods see all of this; well-put Bresn. Please, just consider it guys. :)

@Rad - *starts "VC" chant* :smirk:

---

Lach gives no response to either of these responses. The source you cite doesn't even give a substantial response to any of the two/three posts that I quoted above. You still have no ground, and in fact if we're actually looking to this thread then we should be looking toward my arguments 100%, not yours.

The end goal of this feature is to give an incentive to forum members to be more helpful, provide quality posts/threads and receive some kind of "recognition" from other forum members.

Off topic, as mentioned before, has nothing to do with the actual games. I frankly cant see how upvoting a post in off topic, where all non game related discussions are, could somehow benefit Clash of Clans, CR, BB or Hay Day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Manyolo

The end goal of this feature is to give an incentive to forum members to be more helpful, provide quality posts/threads and receive some kind of "recognition" from other forum members.

Off topic, as mentioned before, has nothing to do with the actual games. I frankly cant see how upvoting a post in off topic, where all non game related discussions are, could somehow benefit Clash of Clans, CR, BB or Hay Day.

---

I agree with your last statement however, it would help improve the Forums as all forum only threads which aren't tied to a game get moved there.

To make reputation points truely about post content alone then the amount givrn per member per day needs to be drastically cut.Having ten points a day does nothing to discourage pointing up friends and ganging up if however only 10 points per month with a use them or lose them system then only posts of worthy content or truely toxic/spam nature will be given points thus the true intention of its implementation is ensured

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by up2gutsNglory

To make reputation points truely about post content alone then the amount givrn per member per day needs to be drastically cut.Having ten points a day does nothing to discourage pointing up friends and ganging up if however only 10 points per month with a use them or lose them system then only posts of worthy content or truely toxic/spam nature will be given points thus the true intention of its implementation is ensured

---

Ten per day is good enough in my opinion.

Many people so far have stated that down votes are going to happen on threads for people who start to talk about something that has conflicting veiw points with others (Posts that should not have been down voted).

How many of you have had this happen to you since the rep system came out and what section was it in?

I find that createing a poll and stickying it asking this question, in all sections and all games, would be very very helpful in determining the course of action (Do this around day 30 or so?)

This way there will be less guessing on how the rep system works and more knowing. See how all the sections have been effected, and not just general, would be very helpful to know also.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thecoolkyle

Many people so far have stated that down votes are going to happen on threads for people who start to talk about something that has conflicting veiw points with others (Posts that should not have been down voted).

How many of you have had this happen to you since the rep system came out and what section was it in?

I find that createing a poll and stickying it asking this question, in all sections and all games, would be very very helpful in determining the course of action (Do this around day 30 or so?)

This way there will be less guessing on how the rep system works and more knowing. See how all the sections have been effected, and not just general, would be very helpful to know also.

---

The first beat down thread I have seen. OP got several down votes.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...o-be-played%21

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Manyolo

The end goal of this feature is to give an incentive to forum members to be more helpful, provide quality posts/threads and receive some kind of "recognition" from other forum members.

---

But what about off-topic? Literally helping people with TvMs fits all three of these criteria.

For anyone wondering why Radiating edited their last post it said this. (And mods can check if they wish)

Also @the person who down voted me- if you're going to downvote me, at least have the guts to say why I'm wrong or being condescending in the thread... I know who you are but I won't witch hunt you.

Exactly why this rep system is a joke as immature and egomaniacal people simply can't handle it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoyaleV

For anyone wondering why Radiating edited their last post it said this. (And mods can check if they wish)

Also @the person who down voted me- if you're going to downvote me, at least have the guts to say why I'm wrong or being condescending in the thread... I know who you are but I won't witch hunt you.

Exactly why this rep system is a joke as immature and egomaniacal people simply can't handle it.

---

If I were an "immature and egomaniacal" person, as you seem to imply, why would I be asking people to explain their criticism?

Remember everyone this is a trial run. They are testing it out to see what works and doesn't work. The very nature of a trial like this is to expect some things won't work well. They can then figure out ways to improve them. I think overall this could be a good thing, but I worry it will be too much work for the mods to keep up with people complaining to them about undeserved down votes. Personally, I would change this over to be anonymous and I would require 10 up votes for every down vote. The very number of required up votes will offset the undeserved down votes and also cause people to be more cautious with which posts to down vote, probably using them for actual posts that deserve it.

I don't post much. I mostly pop on here for new idea's. Check to see where the game may be headed. Stuff like that. I would like to see this system replace a lot of the "this 10 chars" post. Digging thru some of the longer threads can be a chore.

Didn't the forum used to have a thread rating system where users could rate the thread out of 5 stars? If so, can someone tell me why this was removed?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Manyolo

The end goal of this feature is to give an incentive to forum members to be more helpful, provide quality posts/threads and receive some kind of "recognition" from other forum members.

Off topic, as mentioned before, has nothing to do with the actual games. I frankly cant see how upvoting a post in off topic, where all non game related discussions are, could somehow benefit Clash of Clans, CR, BB or Hay Day.

---

How does OT not fit any of those 3 criteria. The rep systen isn't to help the game, it's to help the forums and there's plenty of great posters that do deserve to be recognized. Just one example is tull, the forumer currently running the "forum titles" (not sure that's the name). He should be able to get rep for that specific post (after all it helps others) without people having to find a completely different post to give him rep.

We already have a system that's used to show knowledge of the games (GASPs and sometimes even custom titles), what this should be aimed to do is to highlight reputable forumers (the people who can help you out if you need it, whether it's game related, forum related or something else entirely).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RoyaleV

For anyone wondering why Radiating edited their last post it said this. (And mods can check if they wish)

Also @the person who down voted me- if you're going to downvote me, at least have the guts to say why I'm wrong or being condescending in the thread... I know who you are but I won't witch hunt you.

Exactly why this rep system is a joke as immature and egomaniacal people simply can't handle it.

---

How does this display immaturity? Rad is simply asking said person to say wby he/she gave a negative rep. It's not as if he will (as rad put it) witch hunt the person.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by N1NJ4W4RR10R

How does OT not fit any of those 3 criteria. The rep systen isn't to help the game, it's to help the forums and there's plenty of great posters that do deserve to be recognized. Just one example is tull, the forumer currently running the "forum titles" (not sure that's the name). He should be able to get rep for that specific post (after all it helps others) without people having to find a completely different post to give him rep.

We already have a system that's used to show knowledge of the games (GASPs and sometimes even custom titles), what this should be aimed to do is to highlight reputable forumers (the people who can help you out if you need it, whether it's game related, forum related or something else entirely).

---

Very well put. The rep system should show your maturity and overall quality of your posts. OT is fine because as you said, we already have GASPs and other titles for people to use to get useful info. Rep should simply reflect what kind of posts you tend to make, with people with good rep contributing to the forum in thoughtful, positive ways, which can be done in any subforum.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by N1NJ4W4RR10R

How does OT not fit any of those 3 criteria. The rep systen isn't to help the game, it's to help the forums and there's plenty of great posters that do deserve to be recognized. Just one example is tull, the forumer currently running the "forum titles" (not sure that's the name). He should be able to get rep for that specific post (after all it helps others) without people having to find a completely different post to give him rep.

We already have a system that's used to show knowledge of the games (GASPs and sometimes even custom titles), what this should be aimed to do is to highlight reputable forumers (the people who can help you out if you need it, whether it's game related, forum related or something else entirely).

---

It's not about showing knowledge about the forums. It's about making the forums a better place.

Manyolo does have a point. OT has nothing to do with any of the Supercell games. So why do we need a rep system? Popularity is already a thing in OT, we do not need a rep system for that.

But there's another side to the story. The whole point of the rep system, IMO, is to discourage toxicity and to make the forum community a better place. Look at the cesspool of general, and compare it to OT. OT is literally heaven if you compare it that way. We don't need a rep system, because we are already well behaved. We don't need a rep system to encourage that.

Just my 0.2$

So, here's the conclusion that I've drawn outta this whole thing :
The rep. system has a trial run of 60 days. If it's successful, it'll be continued.
The rep.system has been introduced to (according to my observation) provide recognition to helpful and valuable forumers.
The rep. to a poster will be given after deciding the quality, content and value of the post.
According to some people, this will benefit the Forums, and according to some other people, this will result in abuse of the people whose opinions differ from the contents posted by the forumer.

Now, here are some of my doubts :
What will be done if the rep.system fails to click with the forumers?
Will it be removed?

So, if anyone has any suggestions or opinions regarding my post, feel free to express them. I'll be more than happy to rectify my mistakes if I've done any.
Thanks.

/Xtremegamer234.

How low can I go?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheClap

How low can I go?

---

Just for the name i think people will down vote, no one wants that :smirk:

What will be the benefit of the system???

This is a classic lol
so many forums have this and after a week, everyone knows they mean nothing as easy manipulated.
Then ppl forget they are even there lol
Good old Supercell trying to stay hip

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Megacool

What will be the benefit of the system???

---

So you can be Supercool... wait.. Megacool.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Megacool

What will be the benefit of the system???

---

Per the announcement on page 1... "It also allows members to show their appreciation/admiration of your posts and give you reputation points. On the flip side, it also allows users to give negative points if your post is not great or if you are being a toxic rudey pants!"

Often we have people who come to the forums and speak for the entire playing community as in "we want this". This system will allow people to either agree or disagree without having to have hundreds of pages of comments and occasional bickering. Imagine what it would have been like last Dec if we had this ability.

Not saying it's good or bad but I do see how it could become a way to "poll" the current atmosphere of the forum without everyone having to make an actual post...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

Can ya please clarify what are ya exactly talking about?
That is, my query or the rep. system?
Thanks.

/XtremeGamer234

---

I meant the rep system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hhggff

After all these year, still alienating mobile version users.
Can't wait to see pro engineering ganging up on anti engineering. Or rushers ganging up on maxxers. More drama!!!

---

I'm personally not a fan of the mobile site. I use the desktop version on my mobile devices.

Bad thing is I use mobile site so I can't down vote people. Good thing is I can't see if I get downvoted.

On the positive side it seems to me that this system will not give any special rights, it will just be for "showing off".

However today we already have some wanna-be-Sheriffs running around and I think it will be getting worse. Some people will just be online daily and make use of all their points and have a huge impact on the rating. This could even result in bullying. I think there is a very good reason why facebook (which I actually despise) has only the like button. I think if you are starting a trial, just do it without the negative feedback.

Especially for the negative points, posts in the idea forum should be ignored. As I understand the idea forum is a brainstorming area. If you post an idea, that for some reason is not considered "good" by the always-online-users, you will just crash your rating. Right now without getting feedback from SC the idea forum is already frustrating enough.

reputation system icon walkthrough:

Green: positive reputation (+1)
Red: negative reputation (-1)
Gray: *unknown

can someone explain the Gray icon?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

reputation system icon walkthrough:

Green: positive reputation (+1)
Red: negative reputation (-1)
Gray: *unknown

can someone explain the Gray icon?

---

If I remember correctly the"Grey Icon" is for people not eligible to vote yet.
IE-They don't have a high enough post count yet (50 I believe it's the starting point) to use the rep system (it was always like that on previous forums I frequented)

From OP
How does the reputation system work, and what limitations are there?


Everyone starts with 10 reputation points.
Members must have 10 reputation points to be able to affect other people's reputation. In other words - if you have -200 reputation points, you would have to earn back 210 points before you could vote on anyone.
Members must have 50 posts before being able to use the reputation system to vote on other people, however you can still earn reputation while under 50 posts.
Members can only click the reputation button 10 times per 24 hours. Choose wisely!
You must vote on 15 different users before giving reputation to the same person again (This is to help stop people voting up their friends for no reason!)

I believe the grey will change one they hit 50 posts.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

reputation system icon walkthrough:

Green: positive reputation (+1)
Red: negative reputation (-1)
Gray: *unknown

can someone explain the Gray icon?

---

did some try to down vote and not give a reason? Are you currently at 13 points or 12?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goonerwinone

If I remember correctly the"Grey Icon" is for people not eligible to vote yet.
IE-They don't have a high enough post count yet (50 I believe it's the starting point) to use the rep system (it was always like that on previous forums I frequented)

From OP
How does the reputation system work, and what limitations are there?


Everyone starts with 10 reputation points.
Members must have 10 reputation points to be able to affect other people's reputation. In other words - if you have -200 reputation points, you would have to earn back 210 points before you could vote on anyone.
Members must have 50 posts before being able to use the reputation system to vote on other people, however you can still earn reputation while under 50 posts.
Members can only click the reputation button 10 times per 24 hours. Choose wisely!
You must vote on 15 different users before giving reputation to the same person again (This is to help stop people voting up their friends for no reason!)

---

He has a gray in his log. Not the dot under the name.

Lach has all three colors in his log. Look there for the full spectrum of what Sakibirislam is talking about.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

He has a gray in his log. Not the dot under the name.

---

Just visited his profile and I see what you mean.
It can't be a neg rep as I don't think it allows you to neg someone without leaving a comment.?


Try it on my post.
Give me a neg rep, but leave no comment martvol(I'm not bothered about the food just want to know what causes the grey. ☺

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goonerwinone

If I remember correctly the"Grey Icon" is for people not eligible to vote yet.
IE-They don't have a high enough post count yet (50 I believe it's the starting point) to use the rep system (it was always like that on previous forums I frequented)

From OP
How does the reputation system work, and what limitations are there?


Everyone starts with 10 reputation points.
Members must have 10 reputation points to be able to affect other people's reputation. In other words - if you have -200 reputation points, you would have to earn back 210 points before you could vote on anyone.
Members must have 50 posts before being able to use the reputation system to vote on other people, however you can still earn reputation while under 50 posts.
Members can only click the reputation button 10 times per 24 hours. Choose wisely!
You must vote on 15 different users before giving reputation to the same person again (This is to help stop people voting up their friends for no reason!)

---

someone (don't wanna mention) with 8 reputations gave me a gray reputation now, it says no comment made... confused :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

did some try to down vote and not give a reason? Are you currently at 13 points or 12?

---

my reputation tab says i got 4 of them (3 Green, 1 Gray) but the total point is 12... may be i'm not clear about this system yet...

honorable mention: Mods (don't wanna say who) explained why one of my Green reputations will not be counted. :cool:

I tried to down vote with no comment. It did not go through.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

someone (don't wanna mention) with 8 reputations gave me a gray reputation now, it says no comment made... confused :(

my reputation tab says i got 4 of them (3 Green, 1 Gray) but the total point is 12... may be i'm not clear about this system yet...

honorable mention: Mods (don't wanna say who) explained why one of my Green reputations will not be counted. :cool:

---

Maybe it does not count of they are under 10 points?
Or it could be one that the mod said would not count is now very.

I do remember the grey icons have always been around with the rep voting system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

I tried to down vote with no comment. It did not go through.

---

Then I think it must be from the person with under 10 points or the one amended by mod/s (The fair play ones, not the banable 3rd party one's)

sounds like a good idea at first glance, it would be nice to be able to have a system to negate all the negativity and comments that are not so productive. In my opinion a forum is for those who are looking for positive feedback to help them or the game, not someone who continues to post just for the sake of posting and being nasty. Hope this works out and we see a positive change. :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Goonerwinone

Maybe it does not count of they are under 10 points?
Or it could be one that the mod said would not count is now very.

I do remember the grey icons have always been around with the rep voting system.

---

well, i think there's no gray icon for reputation... it's something like this:
"if someone don't have minimum 10 points and he gives a green or red reputation, the reputation is gonna add to whom he voted... but the system can't (or doesn't) show the red or green because the voter doesn't have enough points to vote, therefore the system comes with gray icon referring no reputation at all, but the vote still counts"

***i can be wrong about this concept :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

well, i think there's no gray icon for reputation... it's something like this:
"if someone don't have minimum 10 points and he gives a green or red reputation, the reputation is gonna add to whom he voted... but the system can't (or doesn't) show the red or green because the voter doesn't have enough points to vote, therefore the system comes with gray icon referring no reputation at all, but the vote still counts"

***i can be wrong about this concept :(

---

You could also be completely right about that concept. I believe that is the case...

The gray icon is from someone who gave you a reputation vote but who does not have 50 forum posts under their belt (hence it doesn't count one way or the other). I'm fairly positive this is the case.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nerfedname

The gray icon is from someone who gave you a reputation vote but who does not have 50 forum posts under their belt (hence it doesn't count one way or the other). I'm fairly positive this is the case.

---

he has 100+ forum posts... so i came out with this concept: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...=1#post9585210

hope Mods will clear the clouds about this :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nerfedname

The gray icon is from someone who gave you a reputation vote but who does not have 50 forum posts under their belt (hence it doesn't count one way or the other). I'm fairly positive this is the case.

---

I 99% sure this is the case

Edited
Confused now that we know the person has over 100 posts and will stick to above posters concept.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

he has 100+ forum posts... so i came out with this concept: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...=1#post9585210

hope Mods will clear the clouds about this :)

---

Changing the subject a bit but does yours show you who voted? I can't see on mine, only votes and comments if they've added one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BlindHaze

Changing the subject a bit but does yours show you who voted? I can't see on mine, only votes and comments if they've added one.

---

. I have names on mine. Both positive and negative.

Edit: that is my reputation I see names on. Not other players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BlindHaze

Changing the subject a bit but does yours show you who voted? I can't see on mine, only votes and comments if they've added one.

---

yes i can see the name... (only mods and I can see who gave reputations to me, but you can't see it... same rule for everyone)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BlindHaze

Changing the subject a bit but does yours show you who voted? I can't see on mine, only votes and comments if they've added one.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

. I have names on mine. Both positive and negative.

---

For me it depends where I look. If I click on the notification of a reputation change, it takes me to my settings page, which shows no names.

But, if I go to my profile it shows pretty much the same thing, but this time with names.

There are two types of member who can't affect your reputation - those who have too few posts (50 required) and those whose reputation is too low (I think 10 required).

Either of those trying to give reputation (positive or negative) will result in a gray icon and no actual change to your reputation.

You will also get a gray from anyone under 10 reputation points, according to alexheney. So, it is not just people under 50 posts on the forums.

Ninja'd by Alex. lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OnyxDS

For me it depends where I look. If I click on the notification of a reputation change, it takes me to my settings page, which shows no names.

But, if I go to my profile it shows pretty much the same thing, but this time with names.

---

Ah, that's done it. I can see now. I was getting there via the notifications.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakiborislam

well, i think there's no gray icon for reputation... it's something like this:
"if someone don't have minimum 10 points and he gives a green or red reputation, the reputation is gonna add to whom he voted... but the system can't (or doesn't) show the red or green because the voter doesn't have enough points to vote, therefore the system comes with gray icon referring no reputation at all, but the vote still counts"

***i can be wrong about this concept :(

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alexheney

There are two types of member who can't affect your reputation - those who have too few posts (50 required) and those whose reputation is too low (I think 10 required).

Either of those trying to give reputation (positive or negative) will result in a gray icon and no actual change to your reputation.

---

seems like this concept was right :cool:

I like this thing. Not only does it gives people like me a reason to post in general, it also has the flaws covered (mostly)

This should be good. Will be very useful, and hopefully not misused.

I thought the intention was to have this be anonymous, but it still isn't. Is this a mistake? Or was I just mistaken

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BlindHaze

Ah, that's done it. I can see now. I was getting there via the notifications.

---

Can you walk me through? I can't see any names

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

Can you walk me through? I can't see any names

---

goto ur profile than reputation tab (it'll not be shown if u don't have any reputation vote yet) :cool:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

Can you walk me through? I can't see any names

---

top right go to "my profile". If you have received any points there will be a reputation tab in your profile.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

Can you walk me through? I can't see any names

---

Go to the My Profile tab on the Full Site and click on ‘Reputation' tab and you'll be able to see the names of those who downvoted you and those who upvoted you.

/XtremeGamer234

ok I went to my profile but I don't see the reputation tab :/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

ok I went to my profile but I don't see the reputation tab :/

---

It means that no one has given you any kinda reputation yet.

/XtremeGamer234

But according to this thing I have 12 points! :heart:

I can see the down/ up votes in settings just not in my profile. No names there though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

But according to this thing I have 12 points! :heart:

I can see the down/ up votes in settings just not in my profile. No names there though.

---

You can see the names of those who gave you a rep in the My Profile tab, but yeah, you can see your upvotes and downvotes in the Settings tab too.

/XtremeGamer234

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

You can see the names of those who gave you a rep in the My Profile tab, but yeah, you can see your upvotes and downvotes in the Settings tab too.

/XtremeGamer234

---

Yes but my problem is that I don't even see a reputation tab in profile :/
So I can't see the names.

Ok I just got a vote notification...what do I do?, I clicked profile and I see no reputation tab

I see a reputation tab for you. I am surprised you can't see it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

Yes but my problem is that I don't even see a reputation tab in profile :/
So I can't see the names.

---

I think that you're on the mobile site right now, so you've just got to switch to the Full Site option and then go to My Profile and there you'll surely find the rep tab. Thanks.

/XtremeGamer234

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

I think that you're on the mobile site right now, so you've just got to switch to the Full Site option and then go to My Profile and there you'll surely find the rep tab. Thanks.

/XtremeGamer234

---

No I'm in full site.
There's only 5 tabs in profile: My Activity, Visitor Messages, About Me, Friends and Infractions.

I guess there's only space for 5 tabs so no Reputation tab for me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

No I'm in full site.
There's only 5 tabs in profile: My Activity, Visitor Messages, About Me, Friends and Infractions.

I guess there's only space for 5 tabs so no Reputation tab for me.

---

Might be possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

No I'm in full site.
There's only 5 tabs in profile: My Activity, Visitor Messages, About Me, Friends and Infractions.

I guess there's only space for 5 tabs so no Reputation tab for me.

---

thats kinda strange since we all can see your rep tab, what size tablet or phone are you using, are you sure reputation tab isnt below the first tab? That is to say not in line, 1 line lower than my activity/visiter messages?

Your on 14 points now.

edit, if you using a mobile phone, why not close the page, open again and chose desktop version.

Yeah, this is really a little strange. I also saw your votes and I saw that you are on 14 points right now. But I don't know why it's not visible to you, maybe because of the Infractions tab that you said.

/Xtremegamer234

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

Yeah, this is really a little strange. I also saw your votes and I saw that you are on 14 points right now. But I don't know why it's not visible to you, maybe because of the Infractions tab that you said.

/Xtremegamer234

---

Doubt it. I have the infractions tab and the rep tab side by side. It looks a little squashed but it's there.

That's a really nice feature, well done guys

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by N1NJ4W4RR10R

Doubt it. I have the infractions tab and the rep tab side by side. It looks a little squashed but it's there.

---

Next to Infractions tab I have the customize my profile button :/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

Next to Infractions tab I have the customize my profile button :/

---

Are you on mobile? If you're not, that's pretty odd.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Are you on mobile? If you're not, that's pretty odd.

---

I have tried on both my computer and phone. No Reputation tab still

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

I have tried on both my computer and phone. No Reputation tab still

---

screanshot so we can see how it looks different to our screens?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

I have tried on both my computer and phone. No Reputation tab still

---

That's super odd. Try clearing out your cookies and then logging back in. We can see your rep tab; can you see others'?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

That's super odd. Try clearing out your cookies and then logging back in. We can see your rep tab; can you see others'?

---

No I can't see anybody's tab either :/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

No I can't see anybody's tab either :/

---

That's really weird, try clearing out your cookies and see if that helps.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicantRachel

I have tried on both my computer and phone. No Reputation tab still

---

Can you go to settings -> My Account -> General Settings and check of its there.