Introducing: The Forum Reputation System

I love Hay Day. :) So much more peaceful then CR and CoC and Boom Beach

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Johnnyfsullivan

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...utation+system


https://forum.supercell.com/faq.php?...vb3_reputation

---

Cheers Johnny, not sure I could really give a damn.

I'd probably drop the negative side though, it will go through the roof when an update comes out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rbot14

...What is your feeling about these reputation points and your experience so far? What do you think needs to change?

---

Worthless. I have received 2 up votes. People need to realize it is worthless and forget about it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tribul

It's forced my posts to be much less sarcastic than normal and that's probably not a bad thing.

---

I'm going to downvote you just for that! :D

Down with the system!!!😂😂

What I find odd is that I put on my work evaluation that I log hours of clash each day and because of it and my time in forums i have a positive reputation here... and after my performance review I was fired?

But my rep here is positive???

So... it has not helped me.




By the way, this is not true. Just in case....

If you post in the wrong sub-forum knowing it's the wrong sub-forum a downvote is probably the good outcome. It will make you think twice about posting on the wrong part of the forum. I don't want to sound like the forum police and I'm clearly not a wannabe mod, but I see it so much to the point its irritating, especially if its war related. There is already a war sub-forum for that.

I'm not sure what link you posted, but if it has anything to do with spencers data, that has been showned to be wrong since the dawn of time, so maybe someone took offense of it. So far the reputation system has been solid. It's has made some very aggressive, sarcastic old time members switch their tones and I like that. They are not report worthy, but irritating enough that a downvote puts them on check. The solid members I expected to have tons of reps have them, like OnyxDS and SinOfDusk :).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rbot14

For example I created a post about war weight. It had over 1500 views and 50 replies. I received both a demotion and a promotion for that post. The demotion was because I spread wrong information? I simply put up a link to a website about war weight for people to discuss and well discussed and some great replies occurred that help us re analyze the war weight guide. So I get penalized for that? It does not make sense.

---

Well, that war weight guide is so wrong it's ridiculous...
Not saying it deserves a negative reputation, but it doesn't deserve any more attention.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LondonCocWisdom

Cheers Johnny, not sure I could really give a damn.

I'd probably drop the negative side though, it will go through the roof when an update comes out.

---

As with any update forumers will pick sides and draw lines and bicker back and forth. Votes will be cast both ways by both sides and at the end of the day unless you were overly rude toxic or insulting your rep will likely remain mostly unchanged.

Fwiw this seems to already be the case in the never ending maxer/ rusher/ engineer debates.

And as stated in other posts without the ability to down rep the up reps would be bloated and the social engineering aspects of it would fail making it all the more pointless.

I'm not a fan of it, then again I'm not a fan of Politics period. I've seen a number of unnecessary down votes & the only solution is to report it to a Mod. Do you really think the average forum user will be willing to do that? I think not, it's a bit much. A simple like & dislike button would of been fine imo.