Introducing: The Forum Reputation System

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Th9Point75

How do I see someone who downvoted me? I am on desktop and can see the notification but cannot see who did it.

---

Go to my profile, then look for the reputation tab on the far right.

Thanks for the help.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Th9Point75

Thanks for the help.

---

Btw, you need 50 posts and a rep level 10 or above for your vote to count. Otherwise it just shows up gray with no effect on the person's rep.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tomville

Btw, you need 50 posts and a rep level 10 or above for your vote to count. Otherwise it just shows up gray with no effect on the person's rep.

---

Il write that down.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Champi192837465

One question, can you recieve more than one reputation in one comment or the ammount is limited to one per comment?

---

You can receive multiple votes per comment from different people. Hatchloff's post on the habits of wizards earlier today has garnered quite a few!

FYI mods, erased rep up vote notifications are also erased when a thread is deleted. So that works

Sadly, that was a lot of good rep for me long gone. Or was it? I was quite sleepy when I checked.

Anyhoo, note to self, do not spend time making forum gold when there's a good chance the thread will be 86'ed

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zegaloft

Dunno if Rep system will actually work or not, the forums is constantly on any issue on different ends of a threads with different opinions and I can hardly imagine anyone giving a positive reputation to someone who opposes their own.

---

I've up voted several people I diagree with, not by accident either, and stated such in the comment. I've up voted based post quality, thoughtfulness of post and/or the passion expressed in the post.

Earlier I up voted a fresh spawn who necro'd an old thread because A) he used the search feature successfully B) made a relevant thoughtful post, but I disagreed with the post itself, and said as much in reply.

People can disagree civilly and give each other a :thumbsup: at the end before walking away, this doesn't need to be any different.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alexheney

The rep is not negated, it just can't be seen on your profile any more. The points (+ or -) still count.

I can see why it disappears from your profile - because the display on your profile is also a link to the relevant post. Which will no longer be a valid link.

---

Thanks for clearing that up alex, good to know.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by forever10

In that case I should give downvote to anyone who I feel that has less knowledge about the subject. Many times I see people giving their opinions in problems and bugs. Their provided solutions don't exist in reality. So it will be fair if they get downvote for less knowledge. The person who downvoted me was actually your friend. He couldn't resist himself when i argued on your comment. So he decided to give a downvote with a very weak excuse.

---

In the case of those who consistently give wrong information in Bugs and Problems, I'd say you should definitely be downvoting. Incorrect information is as clear cut a case for a downvote as it gets. Personally, i wouldn't downvote on just one instance, I'd post a correction at least once and if they then continued I'd downvote. Every time they posted it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wysiwyg

FYI mods, erased rep up vote notifications are also erased when a thread is deleted. So that works

Sadly, that was a lot of good rep for me long gone. Or was it? I was quite sleepy when I checked.

Anyhoo, note to self, do not spend time making forum gold when there's a good chance the thread will be 86'ed

---

See alex's post that I quoted above. It's just the notifications that disappear, the rep remains.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tomville

I think you are likely to believe whatever you want to believe and assert it as true without actually knowing or stopping to look for alternative explanations. I was the one who downvoted you. I did it because you twice stated the removal of th sniping was definitely connected to how legends/ high cups league players are found in multiplayer searches by players in far lower leagues quickly, then followed it up by suggesting it took the lower league player 10 seconds to find a 58 cup offer, after misreading what someone more experienced (Aspex) had explained for the OP. So it was actually 3 posts cumulative effect in that thread rather than just one post that earned you a downvote in my eyes.

---

Perhaps you didn't read my full post. Your this justification is completely different from what you stated in the comment. I was already against this system. One can't vote discussions which have both agreements and disagreements and some people misuse this system by keeping their own view about downvoting just because the friends are involved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aspex

In the case of those who consistently give wrong information in Bugs and Problems, I'd say you should definitely be downvoting. Incorrect information is as clear cut a case for a downvote as it gets. Personally, i wouldn't downvote on just one instance, I'd post a correction at least once and if they then continued I'd downvote. Every time they posted it.

---

They don't actually give incorrect information. They try to help. But if a person comments in Lost connection issues to check your internet connection, it's your internet, does that person deserve a downvote just because Poster knows less about the subject? Crazy comment it is. I would prefer no comment than giving weak justification.