This change should be there as all war players want it��

Is this a troll? The 30% loot you want so bad can be had in one farming raid. Easily.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Roas

I'm with Aspex on this. Why spent so much time coding for something that really matters so little. One farming raid should give you more then the 30% war-loot you are talking about.

BTW who goes to war for war-loot? (except members of a farm war alliance.) War cost more then you bring back in war-loot anyway, so it is a bad way of earning resources.

---

Who told u that ur cost is more in war . I m @th8 I attack with dragon that cost me 400000 -402000 elixser rest gold & dark r my earnings & for all lower town halls it work as a support of resource for upgradation. U tell there is so much of coding but this will help all new & growing players & probably everyone would be happy. And when u want ur game should be best among ur competitors & its not everytime that what u do u should get the same in back . For eg. In ur paper there r objective & subjective how much u write for ur subjective which is for 5marks & for objective for 5marks. So every mark will score u better so don't tell about coding plzz if u all cant do any changes than stop fooling people & don't waste their time by making this ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ forums

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

Is this a troll? The 30% loot you want so bad can be had in one farming raid. Easily.

---

But what if the player harldy finds time to play war & have resource but not to that extend that will start an upgrade so at that time that 30% will surely work . In 99 when only 1 is added it becomes 100 so dont ignore that one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mabhay

Battle day is for 24 hrs so how twelve hours??? & of I attack asap I will get my 30% back

---

In average 12h, if you attack late there will be no difference in time. But thats not the point, the point is that it doesnt matter and it will just shift

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Maximilian99

In average 12h, if you attack late there will be no difference in time. But thats not the point, the point is that it doesnt matter and it will just shift

---

When u need resource for upgradation & u only do war & u know u will get the required resoure why to wait for even 12hr I will make my attack in first 2-3 hrs

The idea wouldn't be a bad one if it had been implemented as clan wars started. But at this point, I think it's such a useless feature that I would not want to see SC spend their time on it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

The idea wouldn't be a bad one if it had been implemented as clan wars started. But at this point, I think it's such a useless feature that I would not want to see SC spend their time on it.

---

All r not at th11 and if SP cant spend their time on adding new features than what we all r made that we give u ideas that to free of cost however SP gets benefited and earns from it how selfish u all r. First u all say all new idea welcomed & when we give u say ohh SP foes not have time ♥♥♥ is than SP doing???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mabhay

All r not at th11 and if SP cant spend their time on adding new features than what we all r made that we give u ideas that to free of cost however SP gets benefited and earns from it how selfish u all r. First u all say all new idea welcomed & when we give u say ohh SP foes not have time ♥♥♥ is than SP doing???

---

Alright, I'll break this down.

Your thread title says all players want this. Then in your posts you say it's beneficial for TH 6-8, which is a blink of the eye compared to TH9-11.

To give you an idea of why I don't like this, imagine there's a request for the archers hair to be orange at level 7, instead of purple. Is it a bad idea? No. But it's pretty silly and meaningless, and there are a hundred other things on this forum I would rather see. That's how I feel about this idea. I can see why a person would like it, but in my opinion, it is so trivial that I don't want it added.

Nowhere did anyone say all ideas are welcome. There are a great deal of ideas that are actually already ruled out and should not be posted. Thankfully, this is not one of them. However, just because we welcome new ideas to the forum does not mean we have to automatically like them all. Some ideas are good, others don't gain as much traction. But you won't know if you don't post.

Don't take the criticism personally. I don't like your idea, but I have no problem at all with you. I would be more than happy to read about any other ideas you have, and give my opinion on each one in turn in their respective threads. But you can't take criticism personally, or you'll face a lot of disappointment whenever you post. Nobody has a perfect idea, and everyone gets criticized.

Cheers

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

Alright, I'll break this down.

Your thread title says all players want this. Then in your posts you say it's beneficial for TH 6-8, which is a blink of the eye compared to TH9-11.

To give you an idea of why I don't like this, imagine there's a request for the archers hair to be orange at level 7, instead of purple. Is it a bad idea? No. But it's pretty silly and meaningless, and there are a hundred other things on this forum I would rather see. That's how I feel about this idea. I can see why a person would like it, but in my opinion, it is so trivial that I don't want it added.

Nowhere did anyone say all ideas are welcome. There are a great deal of ideas that are actually already ruled out and should not be posted. Thankfully, this is not one of them. However, just because we welcome new ideas to the forum does not mean we have to automatically like them all. Some ideas are good, others don't gain as much traction. But you won't know if you don't post.

Don't take the criticism personally. I don't like your idea, but I have no problem at all with you. I would be more than happy to read about any other ideas you have, and give my opinion on each one in turn in their respective threads. But you can't take criticism personally, or you'll face a lot of disappointment whenever you post. Nobody has a perfect idea, and everyone gets criticized.

Cheers

---

I m trying to say that when the player currently of th11 was once th7,8,9 so at that time he might felt for this feature of my idea but as he has moved ahed he felt that okk if this happens doesn't matter much if its there good or else fine so if there is no default in my idea than why don't u like it. See the colour example u gave that idea was a little childish ah the player wanted that archer would look more good . But u tell me why cant u just code my idea when its going to help many player. And leave all that title & all just look at idea not the title

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mabhay

Lol, u don't want this now but when u where at below at th6,7,8 u felt that what loot comes from war after that u will keep something on upgrade common nothing is wrong in the idea u will definitely get sooner or later so if u want so why not sooner. Once in ur history of coc after reading this idea recall back u mist felt that yaa it should be there.

---

I'm at th7 and I still don't want it