Printable View
I am asking to Clashers. I don't want to wait 23 hours for a war.
We ready for a war and we have to wait 23 hours, WHY?
If a button exist and only CLAN LEADERS can push this button to start war in 30 minutes.
"We are Ready!" for LEADERS.. :confused:
One side push button and other side see that, if OK for them, they accept this.
No a bad idea but both clans would need to click "I'm ready". In my clan we make use of the 23 hour wait to train cc troops, discuss strategies and practice attacks.
I said the same thing. Both side accept that, then war start in 30 minutes.
Bases are hidden. Discussing strategies is useless.
1-2 hours for training troops is enough for me.
We like to start wars at 9pm EST time. Sometimes back to back wars with long search times get us off track and we decide to take a day off to get back on schedule. The we are ready button give us an chance (assuming the other clan is ready as well) to start at our preferred hour.
Interesting idea. The 23 hours aren't needed for practice and troop training as the bases aren't revealed until battle day anyway. And any good attacker bases their attacks around the base, not the other way round.
You can't copy a base and practice it anyways.
This is Needed. If they add it it would be so much better. Preparation Day Is For 23 hours Just For Donating In War Clan Castle? At Most Donating Takes 2 Hours. Other Con For The Game will Be How To Balance the Resources Won because More Wars Mean More Loot Which Would Unbalance the Game And Unfair For the Clashers who have Collected limited Resources Until Now. So What I thought Was Add a Cool down. A Clan Can Only Start War Every 2 Days. This is essential So That Fair play is Still Valued.
Also The We are ready Option should Not Just Be For Leaders But For Everyone Participating In War. If Everyone Votes In Favour Then The War Should Start. If Like My Thoughts Then Add it To Your Idea.
and what about the peeps who are not ready for war?
like in a 10v10 war, 5 from our clan and some from their clan are ready including leader ,
so what about others ? they may leave clan or the leader will wait .
So this would create a mess between the members .
Also consider that many clans are made up of different nationalities from different time zones. All members might be ready or even awake! This goes for the opposing clan too. If there's a big difference in time zones then this won't work.
I agree with this and for that not to happen there needs to be a voting system for all war participants which dosent seem like a good idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by DeadPoool
Timezones is always a problem thats the reason for the 23h prep day and battle day so every timezone can scout or attack them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigdome757
Post in EnglishQuote:
Originally Posted by akamtork
Yes. You don't have to use this feature everytime, just needed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Creatine
Thanks for your support.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stjimmy127
2 days for a war. If you want, you can do this by yourself. Leaders and Co-leaders will decide that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dvs
No, I don't think so. Many noobs are playing CoC. Only leader and co-leaders can start a war, so if a decision will made this must be a leader.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dvs
Then think about war. You are not ready but leader or co-leaders include you in a war. Who asked? If you obey them, then obey if leader want to start war in 30 minutes.Quote:
Originally Posted by DeadPoool
No one sleep 23 hours. They can attack any time, time is not a problem i think.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigdome757
https://www.timeanddate.com/time/map/
I Agree. The clanmates need to co-operate with the administrators. And this would be optional anyways.Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesKeziahDelaney
I agree 24 hours waiting is way too long. I believe the options for "friendly war" should be available on normal clan wars too. In friendly war, you can set time for preparation and war too. You can have the same options for clan wars, but both clans must agree to it. One part can send their suggestions, and the other part should either accept or edit the suggestion. If not agreed, then default time perids 24 hours preparations and 24 hours war.
this is different idea, open new thread.
not possible to apply your idea, enemy was found first..
war time must be 24 hours to everyone will attack.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesKeziahDelaney
As someone who's been in war-clans all their clashing-career, I agree with u on most of this, however, this could be abused?
-What if not everyones ready?
-What if the other clan's leader isnt active before war
-Is there a cancel button?
I am just pointing out some things u could explain better, but apart from that, great idea! :)
I think there is a process to vet an idea whether it is implementable or not. First, ask the question whether it is good. And i think your idea passes very well. It is a good idea. I personally like it.Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesKeziahDelaney
But Second, Can this idea be abused? I really think it can. It allows clan to cut the preparation day and therefore, over the long term, accelerate their gain, whether clan xp, war stars or loot. Maybe this is not a big deal. But it needs to be discussed first.
I think its a bad idea, it will give some clans being able to advance faster then othersQuote:
Originally Posted by JamesKeziahDelaney
I do agree somewhat with this. Supercell won't just give farm wars more then they have now. So for this to happen they will have some kinda drawback on the XP earned and the warloot won.Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperKai
Might be something like this:
Both clans choose to end prep-day after 1 hour.
This means that the complete wartime (prep day + war day) = 25 hour.
Amount of XP = ((25 hours) / (47 hours)) * (normal amount of XP for the war)
The same goes for war-loot.
I'm not really sure that this is what OP had in mind when he came up with the suggestion.
Bad idea. Not everyone is always ready. My clan is full of adults who have full time jobs, kids, take college classes, etc. Just because someone is a clan leader doesn't mean he knows the situation of everyone in the clan. We do war searches Tuesday and Friday evenings because we all know we can do war attacks Thursday and Saturday evening. If we do a war search Tuesday night, the clan members will expect the war to start Wednesday night and last until Thursday night. We don't want to log on Wednesday evening to help make sure CCs are filled only to find out someone started the war early and there's only 3 hours left. This will screw over a looooot of people.
Also, what happens if you press the ready button, but the enemy clan doesn't push the ready button for another 6 hours? That throws a lot of people off and could potentially cause 80-90% of the clan war time to occur during a time people are at school/work and sleeping. That's why my clan does rigid war times.
This idea seems unlikely to be implemented because supercell made the game to last that's why it takes 48 hours. This feature could have been added in the last update when friendly wars were introduced but it didn't. I want this to be a feature but doesn't look like they will listen.
If you urgently want to have this, do friendly wars, there you can set time for prep and war day.
for normal war i think the system at the moment is good.
I cant agreed who against this idea.
If a clan want to quit wait time and gain their XP, so they earn it.
If a clan want to wait 23 hours, so be it.
ALL MEMBERS MUST OBEY THEIR CLAN LEADER!
If they don't want to attack, so they can leave..
Nope and nope. This would not be helpful. What happens when an unforseen event occurs such as a player becoming inactive due to work or something like that?
I dont see this happening.