Out Engineered by a better maxer roster?

Last war, we r outengineered by a rushed TH11, and ready to lose our winstreak

Ours

TH10 87k 38/40
TH10 70K 40/40
TH9 51K 9/5 only Drag lvl3 +Double zap5quake
TH9 38K 10/11 Drag Lvl4 + double zap5quake

theirs
TH11 97K 13/19/5 with eagle+Infernoes Lvl1 with lvl6 drag+Lvl3Bowler+Lvl4Healer
TH9 54K 7 only Drag lvl3 +Double zap5quake
TH9 53K 5 only Drag lvl2

I am thinking their *1 will be able to 3* out top 2 with almost all maxed th11 troops and spell

turn out he attacked our #2 for 1*
and the most hilarious was when he attacked our #3 very low defense tH9 with lvl6 drag for 2*

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by samratulangi

Ours
...
TH9 38K 10/11 Drag Lvl4 + double zap5quake
...

---

What kind of match up did you expect bringing lopsided bases like that? You are put in the lopsided matchmaking pool where you are pretty much guaranteed unfair match ups, in your favor or the enemies.

P.S.: OFC your enemy did the smarter engineering by putting a really strong th11 anchor on top of very weak th9 bases. they most likely had a few weak bases (<= th7) to balance the anchor.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by alienwombat

What kind of match up did you expect bringing lopsided bases like that? You are put in the lopsided matchmaking pool where you are pretty much guaranteed unfair match ups, in your favor or the enemies.

P.S.: OFC your enemy did the smarter engineering by putting a really strong th11 anchor on top of very weak th9 bases. they most likely had a few weak bases (<= th7) to balance the anchor.

---

My point is base engineering advantage is very low compared to roster engineering, yet most people complain is .5 minimax or other engineered base. most of our bases is engineered, but still from time to time, maxer with a better roster has a better advantage

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by samratulangi

theirs
TH11 97K 13/19/5 with eagle+Infernoes Lvl1 with lvl6 drag+Lvl3Bowler+Lvl4Healer

---

I'm not sure why you expected him to clear you - that's a disaster account. A TH11 with bad heroes is often no great threat; certainly not to a strong TH10. And his defence score is too low for an eagle base: if it's down at 97k it's definitely vulnerable to 3* by a TH10 attacker.

And seriously... your #1 is a strong TH10 and your #4 is 38k (non-max TH7) ???

Something smells funny Onyx.....

Sorry, that wasn't very clear from your first post. "base engineering" was never really advantageous, expect for a period last year, when offense wasn't considered in matchmaking. This sort of "engineering" is now punished by the matchmaking, putting you in very unfair matches. It's probably 50:50 whether it's in your favor or not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by samratulangi

My point is base engineering advantage is very low compared to roster engineering, yes most people complain is .5 minimax or other engineered base. most of our bases is engineered, but still from time to time, maxer with a better roster has a better advantage

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OnyxDS

I'm not sure why you expected him to clear you - that's a disaster account. A TH11 with bad heroes is often no great threat; certainly not to a strong TH10. And his defence score is too low for an eagle base: if it's down at 97k it's definitely vulnerable to 3* by a TH10 attacker.

And seriously... your #1 is a strong TH10 and your #4 is 38k (non-max TH7) ???

---

no it is a 38K TH9 with 4 lvl3-5 AD
He has teenage heroes, yes, but mostly maxed TH11 troops, so I really expect, at least 2* our #1 and 3* an infernoless TH10 like me, 97K with eagle and inferno yes most of other defense is not maxed, but at lvl10-11, so if he designed it well, I dont think we can clear it

My non-max TH7 comment... I meant that 38k is the weight of a non-max TH7. Whatever the TH and offence, that's an awful low defence for #4 if #1 is a near-max TH10

So your roster is:

#1 Maxed TH10
#2 Perma 9.5 with th9 defense upgraded to th10 levels
#3 8.5 (all defenses no xbows)
#4 9 mini

Whats the rest of your roster look like?

I would not call your roster a maxxer roster. Not even sure theirs is. Looks like a whole lot of nonsense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuperStorm103

So your roster is:

#1 Maxed TH10
#2 Perma 9.5 + 3rd xbow
#3 8.5 (all defenses no xbows)
#4 9 mini

Whats the rest of your roster look like?

---

#2 only 2Xbow, but maxed other point defenses

#5 TH10 35K, 14/10 Lava3, Drag5 Zap7
#6 TH9 35K 11/10 Drag2 double zap5quake
#9 TH9 22K 12/13 Drag3 doble zap5quake

other bases is defenseless or minimax with low troops from TH4-8 in 30v30

That #1 account wasn't engineered it was rushed. Accounts like that have always been a big disadvantage. I would rather have your th10 with those big heroes on my team any day over that rushed th11 with the baby heroes. It wasn't an engineering clan. It was a clan that doesn't know how to upgrade their accounts at all and that usually means you are about to see poor attacking as well.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2222

That #1 account wasn't engineered it was rushed. Accounts like that have always been a big disadvantage. I would rather have your th10 with those big heroes on my team any day over that rushed th11 with the baby heroes. It wasn't an engineering clan. It was a clan that doesn't know how to upgrade their accounts at all and that usually means you are about to see poor attacking as well.

---

Agree, but on prep days it make me nervous because most rushed base dont upgrade troops, but he has mostly maxed th11 troops, especially max bowler, healer, drag, Pekka, Wiz, etc

I was editing my post when you quoted me for the record. My only comment to this nonsense is that you got lucky this time. Your number is coming up with a line up like that.