SC - Please Break Your Silence On Engineered Bases

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ekm5015

1. Sure, the old MM took offensive weight into account...but it was barely a factor. That is why people only cared about defensive weights before the october changes when worrying about war weights. Don't try to pretend that offense was a significant factor before october.

2. It is obvious something was changed to deal with lopsided bases. Maybe it doesn't take the higher of the two off/def weights, but you also conveniently left out the part where i said it at least skews your weight towards the higher of the two weights. How else would supercell be able to account for lopsided bases in war MM? It is only logical to think this.....

---

1. it was barely a factor? really? ive been camping on forums for a long time, it was never just a tiny factor.
it only SLIGHTLY favoured defense.
if they were BARELY a factor as you claimed, there would be a ton more complain of engineers.

2. heard of nerfedname's weight tax?
im sure JfS will link you up

You need to get a life if you have nothing better to do than complain about something in a game that you have the same opportunity to create, but don't.


Coming from a TH11 Engineered w/ max offense. Do you have endless hours of time to play a game on one account? Do you have the temperament to farm only to lose it all in one raid if you don't spend it in time?

obviously not cuz you're on hear whining like a little.....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Luckycharmed

You need to get a life if you have nothing better to do than complain about something in a game that you have the same opportunity to create, but don't.


Coming from a TH11 Engineered w/ max offense. Do you have endless hours of time to play a game on one account? Do you have the temperament to farm only to lose it all in one raid if you don't spend it in time?

obviously not cuz you're on hear whining like a little.....

---

The same might be said of complaining about complaining.

One thing is certain, SC eventually listens to most, to the chagrin of some. Any advantageous technique is ultimately nerfed. Only a matter of when.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Luckycharmed

You need to get a life if you have nothing better to do than complain about something in a game that you have the same opportunity to create, but don't.


Coming from a TH11 Engineered w/ max offense. Do you have endless hours of time to play a game on one account? Do you have the temperament to farm only to lose it all in one raid if you don't spend it in time?

obviously not cuz you're on hear whining like a little.....

---

Going by some of your previous post, your stay here will most likely be a short one. Complaining about the complainers, who needs to get a life?

You don't lose all the loot you've farmed. There is no way you're losing more than you're farming. You can farm a mil but only lose a portion of it. As I once said on an engineering thread, If you happen to come across an engineered base full of loot, that person isn't doing it right...

It has increased four of our last five wars we're with opponents with engineered bases and it simply takes all the fun out of wars. When you are hitting bottom bases with barch and no loot that is not beneficial and then the opponents bottkm players are able to attack your top two players something is wrong. This is not what coc used to be and I hope it's not what they want it to be because right now it sucks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pianodave

It has increased four of our last five wars we're with opponents with engineered bases and it simply takes all the fun out of wars. When you are hitting bottom bases with barch and no loot that is not beneficial and then the opponents bottkm players are able to attack your top two players something is wrong. This is not what coc used to be and I hope it's not what they want it to be because right now it sucks.

---

so your clan allows barch raids in war??? glad im not in that clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by heyya

1. it was barely a factor? really? ive been camping on forums for a long time, it was never just a tiny factor.
it only SLIGHTLY favoured defense.
if they were BARELY a factor as you claimed, there would be a ton more complain of engineers.

2. heard of nerfedname's weight tax?
im sure JfS will link you up

---

it used to be 50/50, then they made the big change & it was mostly D, with some kind of key troop weighting. That's when .5s & engineers went wild. Now it sounds like they are reverting back towards more 50/50.
Engineers have always been around, but they used to have to be smart, always calculating. Now they just build defenseless with max troops & don't spend any time agonizing about how to build the best "balanced" engineered account. Now they have to add even more to the algorithm to counter it IMO. They never should have based it mostly on D. And no one should be able to fool the match by tossing low weight ths at the bottom.
i thought the matching right before the big change was pretty good. Then they messed it all up & brought more problems in.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CosmicCharlie

No one cares if you have a lvl1 cannon only defense and lvl6 drags, were just asking supercell to match you in war with another lvl1 cannon lvl6 drag base instead of a th5. That way you get to play the game with like minded individuals who enjoy the challenge of going defenseless and only having one good troop.

---

Exactly. Do what you want, engineer all the bases you want since it's so easy to do but don't match my clan up with yours since all of our long time players have been working on our bases for a couple of years. I just don't see the fun in a th9 having to hit a th5 defenseless base in war. Match them up with each other since that's what they want. Instead they get matched up with clans who have worked to develop a base. 🙄

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wilsonatore

The same might be said of complaining about complaining.

One thing is certain, SC eventually listens to most, to the chagrin of some. Any advantageous technique is ultimately nerfed. Only a matter of when.

---

That wishful thinking and even if it is nerf there will be a different path to take that will still make the masses rush to complain. Also most people who play aren't on the forum.

SC are slowly learning not to pay attention to these threads, they have their own grand plan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deaf

That wishful thinking and even if it is nerf there will be a different path to take that will still make the masses rush to complain. Also most people who play aren't on the forum.

SC are slowly learning not to pay attention to these threads, they have their own grand plan.

---

No wishful thinking here, as I have no dog in the hunt. Rarely face an engineer, and never at the top of the map. As for the grand plan, can see no evidence of any. Fear the tweak existing or new troop, watch complaints, then subsequent nerf cycle is still the plan. If you notice something different, key me in.