Printable View
I don't agree with giving the town hall weight ever. It literally does nothing on its own attack or defense wise.Quote:
Originally Posted by porky1122
I like nerfed's weight tax as far as fixes go. That or having certain war troops/army space/spell capacity/hero levels will bring your weight to a certain level. That isn't to say give them more weight, because that raises EVERYONE's weight, but having certain offensive items brings your weight up to a certain point if it isn't yet there.
what do you know, another thread discussing something that is already being taken care of by supercell. :smirk: (Grabs popcorn so that reading the thread will be more enjoyable).
I have read most of this thread on & off, but haven't seen this SC answer. Checked the war section too. I did watch the video mentioned about having balanced bases as far as weight. Do you mean this?Quote:
Originally Posted by parjn
There is an Anoushka quote somewhere but I'm not sure where to find it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Freyja1
Only an unskilled player has an issue with engineered or .5 bases! And NO neither bother me nor do I use either!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Freyja1
Here you go: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...nd-III-AnswersQuote:
Originally Posted by LittleMoon
The crux of the debate seems to really be about whether it's a reasonable expectation to want more specificity on the matter than we got. Then of course there is a bunch of rubbishy stuff from people who didn't bother reading past the initial post (or perhaps just the thread title), plus assorted other irrelevant responses, bragging, unfounded assertions etc etc mixed with the better points made.
Ah, thx. That was an older answer. Thought there had been something newer.
SC's newer mm got us into this mess & only that can get us out of it. They aren't gonna tell us any changes except by broad strokes. I used to hate the threads with the old mm when ppl would scream about matches without looking at O or using common sense. Most matches that looked bad on the surface were almost always winnable. I'd just as soon go back to that. Matching D to D was a very bad idea. It reflected their whole D orientation. Maybe the response by keeping D lower let the gamers show, again, that we at least put O first.
They won't tell us the new mm except with a broad brush. Seems like dividing clans into engineered & non, cuts available wars for your style in 1/2. I'd be happy with being weighted by the higher of O or D, (instead of 50/50) but without AQ & bk being so heavily weighted , it puts you in a th above. They set the hero lvls per th. no one should be penalized for maxing their lvl.
Sounds like the next update is soonish. We will just all have to wait & see.
Having a couple of engineers in your enemy clan doesn't make much difference in the outcomes of a war. Having a fully engineered enemy clan will lose because at least one of their attacks will be botched somehow, whereas all of your clan's attacks will succeed with very little effort. The line between is very thin.
Sc can't define which is fair or not. We are human and we know by our common sense that which is fair not not but some ppl r not using there common sense in the name of sc.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKL2207
it depends on the roster man.now i want u and everyone anti loopside nerf to answer these.You start a 10 vs 10 war with 2 medium attack power th10(max war troops and 25 25 heroes and max defense) and the rest th9 and th8.Now u catch the same mirror oponents except their bottom player is a th11 with only th7 defenses and he hasnt unlocked the rest but his tropps are max and heroes 45/45/20.Now tell me who has the great advantage here?Why do u think that th11 in the bottom is in the war?What is his main reason?Now don't tell me oh wait he will be 3 starred too loool.he has a th7 defensive power of course he is being 3 starred.Don't come and tell me hey man those 2 th10 with 25 25 heroes should 3 star the enemy max defense th10 in a blink of an eye or don't tell me that those th10 with 25 both heroes should't war until they got max heroes.i have a defenseless th9 too but i would love the war matchmaking system to be changed by supercell.