Th Rushers and Intent Advantage in Clan Wars Matching

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OnyxDS

The war might or might not be fair - it's hard to tell from TH numbers. We've certainly won wars where the enemy has a load of low defence TH10s and stuff down the bottom.

One observation: you have 1 TH11, 5 TH10, 14 TH9 (or under) as I understand it? Therefore in a war against an identical clan all TH9s will end up being 3*ed. You then say they have an advantage because their low TH11s can easily 3* a TH9... but actually that's a complete waste. If they're any good they can do that with their TH9s and TH10s/11s at the top of the list.
In your line up, it's likely to only be results on the TH10s that matter. If those low bases have 40/40/20 heroes and can flatten TH10s, then you have a problem. If they have quite weak heroes, they might be irrelevant.

But the point from my first post, was just the technical one that they haven't matched your low bases. In theory they matched some of your higher bases when it chose them as an opponent. Now there do seem to be problems with this - especially the way it accounts for their 1-cannon defence (assuming that's what they have). But the problem isn't them matching your lowest bases.

---

I've only enumerated the th as emphasis to the why we are on the disadvantage..and yes currently speaking, 2 of our th th10s are already wiped out by the lower th11. That 3starring of th9 is only to put it mildly. I am venting out, that this is quite offensive but it seems you are onto it and others have gone ahead of me. And for us disgruntled player, it seems like the only option is to wait or just give up on the game when enough is enough.😊

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flubber41

1. This is one of the forms of "clan engineering " that some find troubling/0ffensive and others view as smart strategy . There are a thousand threads debating the fairness of this many on this first page.

2. SUpercell has indicated that they want to address the matching of these "lopsided bases" .. ones with super high offense and low or no defense . MAny believe that since the October and December updates , the matching has gotten MUCH better . THere are still matches that give the engineers a big advantage but it is also possible they get matched with a disadvantage as well .

3. TRy your best and good luck

---

Thanks...yes, that or quit.

i did not sign up in the forum to know how to properly assess a war match up. My point is i am quite frustrated with this so called engineering or strategy that does not encourage fair play and mismatches on clan wars. so thanks (pun intended!!!)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dinds

i did not sign up in the forum to know how to properly assess a war match up. My point is i am quite frustrated with this so called engineering or strategy that does not encourage fair play and mismatches on clan wars. so thanks (pun intended!!!)

---

Where was the pun?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dinds

i did not sign up in the forum to know how to properly assess a war match up. My point is i am quite frustrated with this so called engineering or strategy that does not encourage fair play and mismatches on clan wars. so thanks (pun intended!!!)

---

You are frustrated about something (a mismatch I assume), yet you don't know how to assess that something nor want to learn on how to assess that something. Not sure this will solve your problem being closed minded like that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dinds

Thanks...yes, that or quit.

---

QUitting is always an option I guess . OUr experience is that sometimes you win one of these "mismatches " when the opponents play poorly . OTher times they have adequate skills and crush you . personally I learn and move on .

If all all you want to do is Vent , I guess I can understand that .. I have seen hundreds of threads of people venting on this very issue but many of them were more emphatic or entertaining .

Good, now you realise that maxing isn't the only and right way to play. Aren't maxers the ones who shun and hate on rushers? Stings right, when they bite you back

This is not cheating. Engineering is just another way to play the game. War MM however needs to improve. Stop complaining about engineering being cheating.