Might make engineer acct to c if my opinions r true

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJackrabbit

Actually both side have extra attacks up top since engineers give up an easy attack by a very low th. The bottom gets 2 attacks also. Thats what i do vs engineered bases and then my top get multiple shots at the top so the advantage that people think is there is gone.

---

Not always true. If one side has 2 max townhall 11s and 2 mid level 10s while the other side has 5 10.5/11s and 3 max 10s, one side has very little margin for error while the other side can slip up here or there and can still win handily.

For example, 2 wars ago, the top 6 was like this

US:
Base 1: near maxed townhall 11 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: near maxed townhall 10 (30/38 king and queen)
Base 3: mid level townhall 10 (28/32 king and queen)
Base 4: low level 9.5 (27/29 king and queen)
Base 5: maxed 9 (30/30 king and queen)
Base 6: low level 9.5 (15/15 king and queen)

Them:
Base 1: near maxed 11 (40/45/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: new th 11 (40/42/1 king, queen, warden)
Base 3: 10.5 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 4: townhall 10 (40/40 king, queen)
Base 5: townhall 9.5 (36/38 king, queen)
Base 6: townhall 9.11 (36/38,14 king, queen, warden)

It was possible for either side to win but the matchup was 70/30 in their favor in my opinion.

They had a weak 11 at base 8 and we had a defenseless 11 at base 20.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheWarDictator

Not always true. If one side has 2 max townhall 11s and 2 mid level 10s while the other side has 5 10.5/11s and 3 max 10s, one side has very little margin for error while the other side can slip up here or there and can still win handily.

For example, 2 wars ago, the top 6 was like this

US:
Base 1: near maxed townhall 11 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: near maxed townhall 10 (30/38 king and queen)
Base 3: mid level townhall 10 (28/32 king and queen)
Base 4: low level 9.5 (27/29 king and queen)
Base 5: maxed 9 (30/30 king and queen)
Base 6: low level 9.5 (15/15 king and queen)

Them:
Base 1: near maxed 11 (40/45/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: new th 11 (40/42/1 king, queen, warden)
Base 3: 10.5 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 4: townhall 10 (40/40 king, queen)
Base 5: townhall 9.5 (36/38 king, queen)
Base 6: townhall 9.11 (36/38,14 king, queen, warden)

It was possible for either side to win but the matchup was 70/30 in their favor in my opinion.

They had a weak 11 at base 8 and we had a defenseless 11 at base 20.

---

Who won the war ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LittleMoon

Who won the war ?

---

They won. Good bases. Good attackers too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheWarDictator

Not always true. If one side has 2 max townhall 11s and 2 mid level 10s while the other side has 5 10.5/11s and 3 max 10s, one side has very little margin for error while the other side can slip up here or there and can still win handily.

For example, 2 wars ago, the top 6 was like this

US:
Base 1: near maxed townhall 11 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: near maxed townhall 10 (30/38 king and queen)
Base 3: mid level townhall 10 (28/32 king and queen)
Base 4: low level 9.5 (27/29 king and queen)
Base 5: maxed 9 (30/30 king and queen)
Base 6: low level 9.5 (15/15 king and queen)

Them:
Base 1: near maxed 11 (40/45/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 2: new th 11 (40/42/1 king, queen, warden)
Base 3: 10.5 (40/43/20 king, queen, warden)
Base 4: townhall 10 (40/40 king, queen)
Base 5: townhall 9.5 (36/38 king, queen)
Base 6: townhall 9.11 (36/38,14 king, queen, warden)

It was possible for either side to win but the matchup was 70/30 in their favor in my opinion.

They had a weak 11 at base 8 and we had a defenseless 11 at base 20.

---

One thing ive learned in life is an exception to the rule dosent change the rule. Perfection only works in theory nowhere else.
Btw what was the score ans as you mentioned they knew what they were doing. Something i dont often see. Ive only had 1 bad matchup in 81 wars. Well 2 now but when someone jumps to the next th on prep day and drops the new defenses is something i consider a one off.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kimchilove

O I defo understand y its done n it is a strat I admit. Just not my style but everyone is different. Even tho my remarks might seem negative towards engineers I am simply talking facts. Its not like I dislike engineers. I recognize that style of play is legit just its not respected by me. I have no problems with engineers bc I usually put in maxed or near maxed accts so I avoid em usually so no biggie to me. I understand both sides of the argument tho n I feel both sides r more or less right in their views (minus the ridiculous claims lol)

---

No offense taken. I do like how open you are about this. People want different things from this game which is good except when one side is tell the other side how wrong they are. Keep it going.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJackrabbit

No offense taken. I do like how open you are about this. People want different things from this game which is good except when one side is tell the other side how wrong they are. Keep it going.

---

No doubt. Ty n I will. With that said, current war even tho on paper we r disadvantaged not worth complaining about imo. If we hit well we have good chance to win. Sc defo made changes to war mm n for the better. The.advantages engineers, low th fillers, n .5 used to get has been diminished. Still advantages but not overwhelming. Keep up the good work sc

Ok even tho on paper we were disadvantaged we won war. Their 5 th10 with fernos n bows vs our 3 th10s wit fernos n bows. We made up disadvantage by having better heroes. So far my experimenting has led me to believe no one should b complaining about war mm anymore. Lets c if trend continues. Stay tuned..bum bum bum

That is what I'm seeing too. With both my clans. My max clan just got a perfect score vs a highly engineered clan. We will see how skilled they are. It a win or draw for me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJackrabbit

That is what I'm seeing too. With both my clans. My max clan just got a perfect score vs a highly engineered clan. We will see how skilled they are. It a win or draw for me.

---

I think most engineers r not that skilled overall (of course there r exceptions to rule) hence y they engineer so they have chance to win lol

War carter the saga continues....

Since I decided to put in lower weight n manipulated bases we r 4-1 now. Should b undefeated but that loss was my fault as I got overconfident bc enemy didnt fill cc. Took em for granted. My bad. Anyways even without putting in many manipulated bases wars seem easier but defo mostly fair. Whether advantage is us or them u still have chance to win. From my experiences seems like it is best to not try n manipulate war mm to get more stable matches. Continue to think sc did amazing job reconfiguring war mm.