Team MVP

Originally posted this in general chat, but figured it is more appropriate here...

The most heroic stat doesn't always reflect true heroism in war. Sometimes a heroic attack can be a mass drag from a lower guy on someone higher. Yes, the algorithm flags this as heroic, but it is just mindless dragon spam. Also, on defense it is rare to see 0 star defenses, but a very crucial 1 star defense goes unnoticed in the algorithm.

I propose a new system (either in addition to or replacing Most Heroic) where your clan can vote on the team MVP. It's an optional vote, but it would allow your team to annonomysly select the top performer of each war, and the winner would get a little notice on the victory/defeat screen after war. Maybe they could even get a badge/war MVP tally on their profile. You could even open up the voting and have it extend to the enemy clan, allowing them to select who they think was the most impactful on your team.

This system would make the heroic stat much more meaningful in my opinion. What do you guys think?

I think that sounds pretty cool. For attack and defense. Since it only accepts a 0 star as a defense but if a base doesn't get 3 starred, sometimes that can be considered the heroic defense. It's a great idea. Adds an annonymous social aspect to the group. Which the game seems to be lacking now.

Hope supercell reads this. Would love to give my clanmates props in a more official manner. Also would add an extra, fun surprise at the end of each war when we get to find out who was voted MVP.

I think this is a great idea. It could get more ppl to try harder at war so they might become MVP and it sounds like a fun thing for clans to do.

This is a good idea. Would it allow the whole clan or the clan war team to vote?

I like the idea for your clan voting for your clan, I wouldn't open it up to the opposing clan, too many griefers out there. . Too many times we have a base that gets attacked 4-5 times and never gives up the 3 star, but that base is never chosen as the most heroic. The current formula is valueless.

It would be good...if only war participants vote

Yay! Now in global the clan with one guy in it can say, "Cila, plzzz join here for war. I will give you co and make you MVP." I am loving it.

But that does not discredit the suggestions at all. I think there is great merit to it. Like previous suggestions have covered naming "War Leader" and other titles of honor within a clan.

I want to be titled "Kingslayer" or "The Hound" or "Arya Stark" or something equally as awesome.

Someone was watching too much of Game of thrones

Although its a noble idea it could end in a popularity contest and could create a lot of problems for the clan. A member who did really well might not get votes because the best looking female privately asked your members on KiK for votes. Said member gets angry and leaves. It seems like a silly scenario, but it could happen. You need to improve the idea to make it fair. I would love some special titles ingame.