no way, then people will pick and chose weaker clans which will equate to the same things that sandbaggers do. I do not refer to them as engineers. I engineer my base by building stronger, bigger and more effective defenses.Quote:
Originally Posted by DavidPumpkins
Maybe a stupid question.. but what r th5 doing in your line up..? isn't this a sort of engineering ? Are you complaining about engineering when doing it yourself ? In my book putting down a few th5 is pulling down the warweight of your clan.. same as an engineerd base..Quote:
Originally Posted by jerdiya
totally agreeQuote:
Originally Posted by arfanstar
We are having the same issue. Currently in a 25 man war where we have 7 th11s, they have 14 including their number 25. We were at a 5 war win streak so I guess we were due. We are pretty evenly spread with 2 th8s at the bottom. They have th11 at 25, th10 at 24,23 and 22. Sure the defenses are weaker, but not weak enough for a th8 or th9. They currently have 16 attacks in and are at 45 stars. We are threed up to number 10 an hour into the war.
Equally annoying, after we end up lossing this war, we will get matched against an awful clan, which will also be a pointless war.
This will be our 5th loss since that patch. Prior to the patch we hadn't lost 5 wars in the previous 10 months.
Whether its the ups and downs of defensive vs offensive strength changes or truly a new matchmaking system, the game is dramatically differnt this patch. Air attacks consistently getting in the high 70's-80 percent on maxed th11s is kind of silly.
Change is always welcome, but I think the inconsistentences are driving peole away. Can't find anyone decent in any global chats and lots of our guys are quitting the game. Kind of a bummer since we've been playing together since 14.
Oh well, all good things must come to an end eh?
Done. Nice clan and awful mismatches.Quote:
Originally Posted by Badzmaru
done
Went over to your clan and it's a typical engineered clan to manipulate the war weight, a few low th4 and 5s with no defences, and yourself as a th9 with very weak defences to bring your clans war weight down to gain advantage... your war log is basically evidence that supercell is failing to provide fair war matches.
As as I stated earlier, if supercell makes it that if the th level doesn't contain certain level of defence then you shouldn't be able to upgrade to the next th level. If you're to allow this, then those th are not allowed to participate in wars until they reached a fair amount of defence level that matches at their th level...
We didnt have th4-5, but thanks for making that mistake anyways. I'm the only engineered account in my clan because it allows me to rush while still being in war. I believe rushing is better if you want to max out walls and royals asap.Quote:
Originally Posted by Badzmaru
Instead of your suggestion with is horribly constraining I suggest you dont bring low level ths to your wall. I visite your clan it has a spread of a single th11, some th10s, th9s and th8s in war. It is no wonder you are getting mismatched.
Move the th8s to a th8 only clan. Maybe bring the th9s with them and that will clearly help. If you have your rooster so spread out this mismatches will surely happen. When I saw your enemy clan they had some low level ths in the bottom, about 3-4 th6 accounts, but besides that the accounts where solid high defense accounts. They did not look as engineered as me.
Yes, I agree, Does not need to be a th11,10 to 3 star a th9, But max th9, and not upgrading to th10? Could also be said to be another form of engineering? Being a perma th9,10 is another way of "exploiting" the system to gain an advantage.Quote:
Originally Posted by MJPB
(BTW, theses so called "exploits" are ok with me, hell, its a strategy game!
Hahahaha thats seems funny to me that their opponents is having max th11s or th10s becuase their own clan is having high war weight bases so opponents should be tough its proved. Engineered bases you can also make it who is stopping, you also can make engineered so dont blame engineered for losing the war.Making engineered bases are too tough for a clasher.
'That means you get fair (or in your favor) matches almost 85% of the time. You're complaining because you get an unfair match 14.28% of the time?"
Your logic is: why should we have police when 85% of the people are honest and hard working?Just because of 15% that are criminals?
My point is: there should be no unfair matches. Not even 1%!
Do you ever see boxing matches Heavy vs Feather?
Your logic is: lets make 15% of the boxing matches Heavy vs Feather. It is ok because it is only 15%.
Lets make 15% of the soccer matches Premier division vs 5th League. It is just 15% so it would be ok.