Supercell PLEASE find a solution to roster engineering

Or max your heroes before your defenses to get a better war match-up. The logic doesn't hold up when extended. Everyone likes to have their hands clean but we are all guilty of searching for unfair advantages in some way.

(In response to smokenbooze1 )

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smokenbooze1

Do you farm in lower leagues one could argue it to be a dirty tactic since you are trying to gain an unfair advantage over less developed bases?

---

I don't. It would feel wrong for me personally.

Porky, do you max your heroes before you build new defenses when you go to a new town hall level?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Johnnyfsullivan

One is against the ToS, one isn't.

---

True though hardly relevant. Both are underhanded. Legal highs are legal, so was slavery once. Legal doesn't mean ethical.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by osuchemnerd

Or max your heroes before your defenses to get a better war match-up. The logic doesn't hold up when extended. Everyone likes to have their hands clean but we are all guilty of searching for unfair advantages in some way.

(In response to smokenbooze1 )

---

already maxed my def and royals was just responding to a comment about moddig being eqaul to engineering since they are both "gaining an advantage"

But if you max your heroes before you build new defenses at a new TH lv this also leads to an unfair advantage in war. Would you agree?

And therefore maxing your royals before building any new defenses as a new town hall level would be the same as modding right?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by smokenbooze1

Do you farm in lower leagues one could argue it to be a dirty tactic since you are trying to gain an unfair advantage over less developed bases?

---

Sound logic if we were playing Clash Royale, however we're not. We get "penalized" for being in lower leagues due to the low loot bonus, loot penalty for hitting TH lower than us, and there are inactive dead bases in lower leagues to make for easier farming. I've been matched up with many th10 and th11 in Silver league that are just as maxed as I am at th10.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by osuchemnerd

But if you max your heroes before you build new defenses at a new TH lv this also leads to an unfair advantage in war. Would you agree?

---

Yea isnt that what a X.5 is? To me gaining an advantage through a method available to all players is fair game, I like maxing my base personally and farming similar bases but if people wanna go through the work of engineering a roster or their base I got no issue with it. War searches can go either way, sometimes you're the bug and sometimes you're the winshield either way you gotta play it out since at the end of the day this is just something we do to have some fun.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by osuchemnerd

Porky, do you max your heroes before you build new defenses when you go to a new town hall level?

---

Man you are really scraping the barrel now. Next you will be asking me if I've ever raided someone with unloaded defences.
The subject is in the title please try to stick to it rather than deviate with petty point scoring. Manipulating the system to give an advantage in war is dirty and low. Try and justify it to yourself if you like (if you do it) but you won't convince me that unfair play is justifiable with silly questions like that. I see your angle and its weak at best.

If I have misunderstood I apologise, if you you're not trying to convince me dirty play is ok or justifiable than my reply is a little toxic and wrong.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ellimist325

Sound logic if we were playing Clash Royale, however we're not. We get "penalized" for being in lower leagues due to the low loot bonus, loot penalty for hitting TH lower than us, and there are inactive dead bases in lower leagues to make for easier farming. I've been matched up with many th10 and th11 in Silver league that are just as maxed as I am at th10.

---

I agree there are a lot of th10s and th11s in lower leagues I was simply using that as a point of reference in gaining an advantage in the game was not saying its not a fair method ect.