Printable View
I call Engineering "Smart Rushing"
It's totally OK to engineer . Ofcourse their war weight will be low and that's where your problem is. You can easily beat an engineer's base. I don't see how it is invalid ?!? Isn't Engineering very strategic yet valid.
why is it invalid? It is cheating. Imagine that you have 15 vs 15 and both of clans have for example 6x TH9, 6x TH8 and then some lower THs.Quote:
Originally Posted by PokeManiac
And opponent has 2x engineered TH10 in position where your clan has TH7.
Then it is easy for them, to 3 star your first 4 villages.
Can your TH7 destroy nr1 and nr2 ? No!
You can say that it is easy to destroy engineered TH10s, but it is also easy to destroy your low not engineered THs
Edit: something like this happened, and unfortunately it is quite common :-(
Request A change TPA or rules so Engineering does contravene that. This will encourage more fair play or result in action.
It is time some addressing of the rules for clarification of them so that engineered bases are addressed.
Unfairness in clan wars do to these bases that are effecting fair matchmaking still needed so balance can return to clan wars.
I don't think that 'not upgrading' your base can be called cheating. It's just taking advantage of the current war weight system. If Supercell feels that it is disturbing the game's balance , they might change the system.Quote:
Originally Posted by martas84
Your TH7 can destroy that engineered TH10 however, because their defense is usually very low, like mine. I'm a TH9 engineer and below all my th8 fellows and a th7 and my mirror can always 3 star me. Also, in your scenario, you are losing because your top players are not beating their mirrors, which you are so obsesed about. Your TH7s are also at fault if you cant dragon down a low defense th10.Quote:
Originally Posted by martas84
Imaging that instead of that low defense TH10 who is an easy 3 star you get matched vs maxed bases all the time... What will happen now ? If you can't beat almost defenceless bases how do you expect to defeat more maxed out defensive bases ?'
This is why weighting the th, which is a glorified storage, is such a bad idea. It adds absolutely nothing new when you upgrade, on the defensive or offensive side. I'm not even going to adress how you are wrong in engineers being cheaters, because Apex and some other members made a good job explaining. You need to adress your teammates attack skills if you cant win these wars easily.