This can solve Engineering

I think it would be waste of time to talk about engineering (everyone knows about it)

War weight should be counted like this:
If someone upgrades townhall, his war weight will be calculated normally as current calculation.
But if his war weight is lower than maximum weight of lower TH, his weight will be set as max weight of lower TH.

So for example:
Max TH9 weight is 70 000
if anyone upgrades to TH10, his weight will be 70 000 and higher
(so TH10 engineers with real weight for example 15 000 will have 70 000 as minimum weight for TH10)

This is easy idea to solve this problem and also easy to implement

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by martas84

I think it would be waste of time to talk about engineering (everyone knows about it)

War weight should be counted like this:
If someone upgrades townhall, his war weight will be calculated normally as current calculation.
But if his war weight is lower than maximum weight of lower TH, his weight will be set as max weight of lower TH.

So for example:
Max TH9 weight is 69 000
if anyone upgrades to TH10, his weight will be 69 000 and higher
(so TH10 engineers with real weight for example 15 000 will have 69 000 as minimum weight for TH10)

This is easy idea to solve this problem and also easy to implement

---

See any of the many threads where this has been suggested for arguments as to why this would not be a good idea.

A max TH9 has a defensive weight of 70K BTW.

And a engineered th9 has a war wight of of a th5. Why a unfair advantage in war matching. So I say yes this would help bring back fair play to clan wars and is needed. Thank you original poster for a great ideal. Super cell should do something about those not following the spirit of fair play.

stop engineering base wars... i hate lost three wars because enineering base wars..i hate that...we can get stars on oppentant base but they easily get stars on top 5 bases (3stars)...it is not fair play...these things of losing wars make hating war among clan members..just spending 7lakhs on th7 after losing get only nearly 2 lakhs...
it is not fair play...losing continuously makes hurt and hate war not need..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

And a engineered th9 has a war wight of of a th5. Why a unfair advantage in war matching. So I say yes this would help bring back fair play to clan wars and is needed. Thank you original poster for a great ideal. Super cell should do something about those not following the spirit of fair play.

---

As an engineered TH9 does not have the war weight of a TH5 it is apparent that you do not know what you are talking about.

Fair play has nothing to do with engineering or not engineering, it is about not using TPAs.

Again? 10char0

I have seen many engineered bases th9 matched in war equal to th5. I do know what I am talking about!!!!!!!

But you are right engineered bases have nothing to do with fair play because that are not playing fair. What we the many think is reasonable is that SC make it so that engineered bases are made to play fair. A new rule that engineered bases would be against the rules. And would not be able to war until they get fixed.

You ASPEX seem to be the only voice against this new rule .

Let's put it up as a poll. Should engineered bases be against the rules. Then we could show SC that a rule is needed.

Every time someone says something about fixing engineered bases. You seem to be offended by it. You must be using one. imo.

So the only thing left to say is that engineered bases are playing unfair and need to be addressed by SC and to the Spirit of fair play that SC stands behind.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

I have seen many engineered bases th9 matched in war equal to th5. I do know what I am talking about!!!!!!!

But you are right engineered bases have nothing to do with fair play because that are not playing fair. What we the many think is reasonable is that SC make it so that engineered bases are made to play fair. A new rule that engineered bases would be against the rules. And would not be able to war until they get fixed.

You ASPEX seem to be the only voice against this new rule .

Let's put it up as a poll. Should engineered bases be against the rules. Then we could show SC that a rule is needed.

Every time someone says something about fixing engineered bases. You seem to be offended by it. You must be using one. imo.

So the only thing left to say is that engineered bases are playing unfair and need to be addressed by SC and to the Spirit of fair play that SC stands behind.

---

You have seen no TH9s matched to TH5s in war as that is not how matchmaking works. Mirrors are not matched, a base's map position only shows its defensive strength relative to its own clan. A base's offensive strength is not apparent from it's map position but is taken into account by the MM.

I do like your opinionated fallacy that as I am not anti-engineering I must be engineering myself. It must be a whole week since someone used that and it is as wrong now as it was then. There are plenty of people other than myself who are not anti-engineering but who do not engineer, just as there are people who engineer but are anti-engineering. To assume someone's base from their arguments is ridiculous.

Despite your continued assertions that engineering is unfair, it is not. Engineers are playing within the rules, anyone can create a base and progress it as they wish. Since the last round of MM changes offence has been given more proportional weighting leading to to more equal matchups.

Engineers base or rush base is not a problem for me I understand that, the problem is there is a huge advantage and a huge disadvantage for some people in war that the problem that need to be addressed is ether you make to different type of war

#1 simple equal or heads up war

#2 Engineering war

Gives us the change to choose war and used are war clan strategy . But don't just say is not a problem because it is.

My other idea I forgot to say is , can we get a chance to cancel war in preparation time if we don't like are opponents in war . Just like we do farming we decided who to attack . Same here let us choose who we going to war with.