Fixing the engineered base problem in war matchmaking

So there is an obvious issue in wars as of lately. Enough to where there are MANY disgruntled players in clan wars. This is because many are now facing engineered clans and bases where a th11 matches at the war weight of a th7 with maxed royals and troops. This is slowly becoming increasingly popular as it provides an obvious advantage in war.

I know there is a ultra secret method to calculating war weights for defensive buildings and structure's lol.

What if you used this same exact secret method to provide war weights to offensive troops and heroes at each level. Enough to have a max offense (including royals) weigh almost identically to a max defense.

Then, when you start war, whichever weighs heavier (offensive weight vs. defensive weight) is used as your weight in the war lineup.

This would bring these engineered bases with maxed royals and troops to the appropriate th11 levels while still keeping maxed th11 bases in the same spot they currently sit.

This is a very vague solution but wondering your thoughts.

Would you weight every troop individually then, like the defenses?
That would mean someone could still go to TH11, defenseless, and only max lets say bowlers and healers, and still have a good advantage and low weight.

Defence weight X offence weight X town hall level X TT (PI)(3.141579.......) devided by speed of light squared= WAR WEIGHT

If it comes out a negative number you not allowed to war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cayumi

Would you weight every troop individually then, like the defenses?
That would mean someone could still go to TH11, defenseless, and only max lets say bowlers and healers, and still have a good advantage and low weight.

---

You're right but without upgraded heroes that would still be at a severe disadvantage as you can't take many high level th9,10,11 bases with ONLY those troops and no heroes unless rushed or a bad design.

All offense would have to factor in, heroes, spells, troops & appropriate levels

There will be methodes of streamlining your base in any way of warweight-calculation.
But make the clanlevel rise and fall with success like single players do in league. MM could be done like always but only clans of even level would be put against each other - pros would battle pros and hobby matches hobby.