Printable View
Stop people from leaving clans during war and make it so if you are on the war team that your with that clan till the war is over. Only ones that can throw people out on war team during war would be co-leaders and leaders. That way people will not leave clan in the beginning stages of war or at least stay and fight
Bad idea, will never be implemented.
Locking people into war will just lead to 2 1 barb failed attacks and a base that is setup to offer an easy 3 star.
Take the suggestions from your other thread on the subject and stop trying to get the game changed to compensate for your clan's problems.
+1Quote:
Originally Posted by Aspex
Manage your clan better and the problem will largely resolve itself.
+2Quote:
Originally Posted by Aspex
This^^^^^Quote:
Originally Posted by ProfChaos
What clan is this happening to? Can I see your clan tag so I can figure out what is happening?
Wow so much hate for an idea. All Iam saying for a clan to have those in war that your not sure what their intentions are even though they had followed a cool down period ect ect and they final get into a war and leap out for what ever reason. Just make it so they can't quit the war. Or if they sucked or become unruly in the clan let co leaders and leaders be able to remove them if they were on the war team.
I understand your intent, still 100% disagree with it but, let's think of it this way...
A player enters a clan, yours perhaps, gets into a war and realizes "wow these guys suuuuuuuuck!" Should this player be forced to stay there and watch the emu stable slaughtered while being ridiculed/ derided for not wanting to waste their time and attacks on a failing war?
Again manage your clan better and this will not be an issue, or if it's not an issue for you stop posting on behalf of the other poor SOBs that can't manage their clans.
Stop with the "hate" nonsense. Pointing out why an idea is bad, with reasons, is not hate.Quote:
Originally Posted by Frost86
Locking people into clans is unacceptable, full stop. There are numerous reasons why this would never be implemented. It is down to your clan to vet recruits, the game does not need changing in this respect.
Easy said then done I've done vetting and people bail out before war prep is done still. That alone hurts team morale seeing that we are short attacks going into battleQuote:
Originally Posted by Aspex
So if someone comes by your clan and you choose to put them in war by accident or whatever, then they should be locked to your clan for 47 hours? Hmm I guess you would have a bad war then, the guy cant leave, so he/she will start filling any war-request with goblins, throw wallbreakers on the warboard and generally be a pain in the ... by spamming the clan-chat for the next 47 hours. Ohh and do two drop barbs as his/shes 2 attacks. You really want that?Quote:
Originally Posted by Frost86
I do understand why you have the idea, but the solution ain't going to work.