Printable View
Lev 10 Clan with all that Benefits. Supercool. But whats Next?
Clan level 11 and more. But why dont u come up with new benefits!! War win bonus/storages/donations or gems(its too much😉) like that. M sure many new ideas can flow in.
Why dont you come up with a idea of rewarding Most Heroic Attack or defence?
Comeone Supercell, bring on something new except troops n spells.
BDW thanks for the game.
If they continue to give better perks, then it will be difficult to attract people to make new clans
Ideas of different badges or special badges for higher levels is the best suggestion I have seen, but if you give more perks people will stop making new clans
The problem with adding more perks is that new clans already struggle to attract members everybody wants the free perks someone else already took the trouble of earning adding more will make this worse unfortunately
^thisQuote:
Originally Posted by 9333
SC has already stated it to be the reason (in the Ideas section). But I think they would consider opening up more art designs and skins for clan badges and shields. That would at least be something
No more bonuses.
There is enough bonuses for lvl 10 clan already
I think the idea for rewarding most heroic is war is a great idea. 1 gem for each.
I think the donation perk should be reworked. Instead of receiving +1 or +2 level, you can receive max for +1 TH level or max +2 TH level. The downside to that is you should then only be able to receive max for your TH if your clan hadn't earned the perk. The outrage would be too high, but I think I would help from making attacks too easy because you have a maxed troop all the time no matter what. It would be a real and significant perk.
I'm all for adding more bonuses or perks. Our clan spent quite a while leveling up to 10, and during that time it gave us all something to look forward to. Now at level 11 the fun of getting xp in wars to level clan up has gone. Add more badges, designs, colors, flashing, etc. Refund on donations could increase without making the higher clan levels OP.
Yep ! no more bonuses.
A soldier will fight long and hard for a bit of colored ribbon. Napoleon BonaparteQuote:
Originally Posted by ninja636rider
Why dont we get new perks for lvl 10+ clans. It is getting really boring now. Specially with lot of engineered bases around, i dont see why we should keep war after lvl 10. There s no motivation to do wars now.
When will we get new perks....?
We won't. It is nearly impossible to start a new clan now and adding additional perks would make it worse. Now as a leader of a level 12 clan, I would like to see something for the achievement, maybe special decorative stuff or unlock new badges.
This was just brought up in General (should be in Ideas sub-forum). SC has stated they will not because of the impact to starting new clans and recruiting at lower levels. But I think they are open to perhaps having more badge designs.
As was stated in the Developers' QnA, new perks would only make the game unbalanced and, as hillbillythegre said, it would be nearly impossible to start a new clan...
No more clan perks IMO.
Right now if a level 10 clan comes against a level 3 clan in war almost definitely the level 10 clan will win.(unless they feel that they should help the other clan level up).Even more perks will make the game worse.Although I agree that you should get more clan badges and/or decorations.
Right now my clan is at level 9 trying to get to level 10 ASAP.
What if they try adding some bonuses and reducing some bonuses at the same time.
Lets say they add 1% attack to troops but reduce 1% from defences......
Next perk..
Add 2% to deff n reduce something rhey come up with......
So on.......
Just an idea.....
And what about some bonusses which'll only affect clan war? No extra loot or troops lvls. Just a buff of about in defence or attacking, in clan war only. Of course then the matches of the clans should be fair, no lvl 11 clan against lvl 9 then for example.
But when the game started and Clans started, players became a kind of family to take the clan higher. Now no one cares as anytime they can make a new one and Reaching lev 5 clan is no more big deal.
May be in war it was causing problem, but Higher the level and better the perks were showing a dominance even outside war.
But when the game started and Clans started, players became a kind of family to take the clan higher. Now no one cares as anytime they can make a new one and Reaching lev 5 clan is no more big deal.
May be in war it was causing problem, but Higher the level and better the perks were showing a dominance even outside war.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sheedy17
Quote:
Originally Posted by 9333
Clans should be harder to build. Too many clans means too many bad clans.
Too many bad clans means players get bored and quit.
This makes it hard for the good clans too.
Building a clan requires effort and style. If you do not have it - do not build a clan.
Exactly...
So many Clans out there who encourage cheats for game. Discourage players. Force to stick to one kind of attacks. I have been to some clans while roaming, who dont even know whats Hybrid attacks. They get bored soon.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sheedy17
Quote:
Originally Posted by OrdinRiff
I don't disagree with this, but to add further tangible incentives is a bit much.Quote:
Originally Posted by OrdinRiff
Skins badges and other status symbols that do not effect gameplay is fine.
Also shouldn't the reward of war beyond perk 10 be the same as before perks were introduced... We all forget it's fun?
Anyone? ...........Quote:
Originally Posted by Colombo
Quote:
Originally Posted by 9333
With limits, plays should be able to take clan XP with them when they go. A fraction of the clan XP they they helped to create.
I suggest:
- Half of their share of the clan XP earned in wars in which they participated. Eg. The they participated in one war, 40v40, and the war yielded 160 XP, their share of that would be 1/40 x 160 = 4. Half of that is 2. When they leave (and here, we need a more permanent form of leaving than going to visit other friends), they take the 2XP with them. The clan loses 2 xp. When they sign up with another clan (again, needs to be more serious than just joining), that clan gets the 2 xp, permanently. Permanently, as in the player can't take it away again.
I don't suggest discriminating between good, better and bad war participants, it is too complicated for an algorithm, and it would encourage selfish behaviours by hoppers. However, SC would have to keep a secret tally of a players accumulated portable war XP.
This fractional portable XP would not encourage silly clan swapping, as it is very lossy. If the whole clan took their XP and started a new clan, the clan XP would be halved. Do it again and it is halved again. However, it is a lot better than getting nothing.
For new clan perks, the main thing I want are social perks.
- More members
(they said 50 is a lot to manage. True. But when you get your clan to level 10+, you kind of have some experience)- Designated sister/daughter clans, with cross-clan chat and cross-clan donations.
(NB we have this now but with massive practical tedious difficulties, players have to leave, enter, talk&receive, leave and enter the first clan again)
Non-game changing but nice game features that might be nice and workable might include:
- Faster hero recovery.
- Even more troops per donation
- Even less time between donations.
Supercell can reduce clan xp amounts up to lvl 5 by 50% and upto lvl 10 by 20%. Like they did December 2016 update to some buildings....
So new clans can lvl up fast n clan lvl 10+ can hv some fun. Its really boring now.
Early days our members did wars really well. But now some of them not even participate. They were bored.