War forfeit option

Would it be a good option to give clan leaders a war forfeit option ???

Basically in doing so would lose them the war and give the other team a full house of stars, the winning teams players still have to take their turns in order to score any loot from the war but once their leader decides they have had enough they can cancel the war completely in order to start a new search. All loot would be identical loot as if they battled properly and won the war.

So both leaders have to cancel the war for it to immediately finish its just that the clan who's leader initiates a forfeit cannot gain loot from the war and the other team can grab some loot then cancel and go for a proper war where the other clan leaders isn't a mmmmmmmmmmmmmm how do I put this? Wimp ?

Also put a time on how long since war starts that a forfeit can be used, like 2 hours after search finishes, after that it cannot be used.

No, just no!

If you don't want to fight the war then you should be made to sit through prep day and battle day before searching for a new war. Otherwise clans would look at the match-up, not fill CC's, forfeit the war and start a new one immediately.

Thats my point, some clans do that and you have to go through a full war before you can start a search again to have a proper battle.

I hate it when clans dont fill or try, it's like there's no fun in the war.

Best wars are those that are nail biting close and require good tactical moves in order to win by using your players to their strengths and knowing their limits.

The easy wars are just boring.

I would be ok with this if it immediately put the forfeiting clan back in the war search queue with no way to cancel...

And yet somehow I don't see SC implementing it for some reasons that I don't yet see but someone smarter will make clear later in this thread...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ex3cuti0n3r

Thats my point, some clans do that and you have to go through a full war before you can start a search again to have a proper battle.

I hate it when clans dont fill or try, it's like there's no fun in the war.

Best wars are those that are nail biting close and require good tactical moves in order to win by using your players to their strengths and knowing their limits.

The easy wars are just boring.

---

I see where you're coming from - I think it could be an option if the forfeiting clan had a 48 hour cooldown so they can't just cherry pick easier wars by throwing in the towel and searching again immediately.

No, this will be abused a lot!

If nobody gets any stars or loot out of it - then it might work.

Maybe a forfeit option when there is less than 12 or 6 hours in the war or all battles have been taken.

I don't know about "forfeit" but maybe a "reject" button. I don't think a clan should be given "free stars". IMO that would encourage engineered clans even more. I would like some kind of "reject" option so you could reject engineered clans. I cooldown of some kind would be needed to keep down just rejecting because they are hard issues.

No forfeit button you joined war you do war period. Would be nice if war can be ended when both sides use all attacks just did war all attacks on both sides were done in first 4 hours then 20 hours twiddling thumbs

You have the option now to not fight if you don't want to, but the 48hrs war period must be adhered to. Even if you had a 'forfeit' button or 'reject' button, the minute you use it your clan should go into 48hrs war cool down whereas the opposing clan you rejected goes back into the war search immediately.

Anything else and it will exploited.

Yup should 100% have this, so many times we have gotten full stars (or close to full stars) and enemy clan have not bothered at all and we sit there for 6 hours waiting for the war to end 119-27 (happened 3 wars ago)

We could have gotten a jump start on our next war not wasting our time cause they cant be bothered to put up a real fight!

I want every war to be followed through by both sides, whether its a mismatch or not, i would never bail out of a war without giving it out all regardless, but for a war not fought both sides is lame lame lame

Been brought up many times in many forms, and I agree with it just about everytime. Put some sort of limit on it if needed, like all attacks must be used and all cc's must be filled or not in the first 12 hours, but somehow there should be a way to end a war sooner if both sides want it.

If some were to exploit it, why would I care? Their clan gets perks faster, or loot not stolen from me....neither effect me.

Belongs in Ideas and Feature requests

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fette

You have the option now to not fight if you don't want to, but the 48hrs war period must be adhered to. Even if you had a 'forfeit' button or 'reject' button, the minute you use it your clan should go into 48hrs war cool down whereas the opposing clan you rejected goes back into the war search immediately.

Anything else and it will exploited.

---

Yes I agree with this, there should be some form of penalty for leaders who use the option so it cannot be exploited.

If you get a match that's that bad, just suck it up, and use war attacks for practice.

Here's a better idea. SC fixes cwm instead of adding this feature.

No I don't like it
If you don't want to play then sit back and enjoy the rest
Remember more pain more gain

How many "youthful clans" would forfeit war after war after war. Think of the sweet young souls now that blissfully get free co then move happily along, seemingly unaware of that whole war timer thing. So the clan leader forfeits war until the next crew of free co dreamers arrives. Then it repeats again.

While the war may not be the challenge a clan would like, it is the starter clans that would be faced with these forfeits most often.

In the last couple of weeks, we've had two clans that never attacked and right now are in a war with just under 2 hours left. Out of 40 attacks they have taken 13 and most of their clan castles were not fully filled. Some not at all. Pretty clear these guys decided right away not to try. In a situation like this, it would be nice if they could just quit. :) They are engineered but not good at it. We failed to three star only one base. :) I think they saw it coming.