an idea to resolve the war weight issue.

If each account linked to 2 villages. The Nprimary village is a fix rule that can not be upgrade the until reach certain defense . The 2nd village can do whatever u want except the lvl must be 1 th lvl lower than the primary one. In war, both account will be enrolled in but the war search will only based on the primary village and 2nd village will not be in the equation. In this case, worst case is half engineered clan verse a full max clan. This will eliminate the engineering clan. Plus, either the max clan or half engineering clan won't really have advantage as it still all about your attack on the primary village.

The only issue how the current village without maxed defense join the war? Coc may lost a lot of player by doing it.

One possible answer is start a new clan/war league for this type of clan/village and let the old war league continue on it own.

For the player already have a mini account, they are allow to merge 2 together as long as the primary met the criteria. Or the player can start a new Secondary.

For those rushed on defense, they will not be allow in the new clan/war system but stay at the old one. In other words, slowly phase in the new system and phase out the old system.

Cheers and have fun.

So you are wanting everyone to max out defence before anything else?

It should just be on wins and loses

should not matter who or what is in your make up

the more you win, the harder it gets, the more you lose the easier it gets

that way engineered bases will not matter

keep it simple is always the best way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRealMaximusPrime

So you are wanting everyone to max out defence before anything else?

---

The secondary village could be rush or max, depends on what the player like. As it town hall level is always lower than the primary, the primary account 2nd attack can cover it if needed.

Question is the primary village, I guess there are some guideline is needed which SC will need to provide based on their war weight. I will assume at least 80% of the defense (exclude walls) of his town hall level need to be there before th upgrade. Of course it won't resolve the .5 base but if sum up the entire clan war weight, it won't be as bad as the current system. Cause the secondary village won't be in the equation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TwoBouviers

It should just be on wins and loses

should not matter who or what is in your make up

the more you win, the harder it gets, the more you lose the easier it gets

that way engineered bases will not matter

keep it simple is always the best way.

---

No doubt make it simple is the best way. But the only way to make is fair is war search is 1 vs 1. That will make all engineering or defenseless bad go away.

However, as long as war search is 10 vs 10 with today system, the full engineering clan can took advantage.

For me, it doesn't really matter as I just enjoy the part I like. Just notice there are engineered hater always jump out in the form. Just just give my thoughts on what could be improve.