Better punishments for those that leave during clan wars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zuras

I read all the above comments, I agree it can be fixed by better leadership. But a lot of people don't want to wait 7 days for the new to go away, So they just leave, that is one con of the current sit. But I think SC should just let a clan cancel a war if a certain amount of people leave that were in war, because even people who have been in clans for a long time have left during wars, and then u have an unfair war and then bad stats for an unlucky clan, and a lot of people look at stats when searching for a clan.

---

Great idea so if it's looking bad for your clan just have some of your members leave so you can cancel and then they can return. There by screwing the other clan out of time and resources already spent on the war. All because you can't run your clan properly

That totally won't be abused

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zuras

I read all the above comments, I agree it can be fixed by better leadership. But a lot of people don't want to wait 7 days for the new to go away, So they just leave, that is one con of the current sit. But I think SC should just let a clan cancel a war if a certain amount of people leave that were in war, because even people who have been in clans for a long time have left during wars, and then u have an unfair war and then bad stats for an unlucky clan, and a lot of people look at stats when searching for a clan.

---

It doesn't take 7 days for new status to disappear. Most people recommend newcomers sit out a war or two, which may be longer or shorter than 7 days.

Regardless, they are an unknown entity.

With Fair Play Clan Wars edition announced the other day, it is even more critical clan leadership get to know their inductees. Good clan leadership and management covers a raft of events that affect clans. "Fixing" one issue through SC intervention is a band-aid on clan life. Acting as a clan, bonds the clan, strengthens the clan and enables the clan to cover truly unpredictable events and issues.

It could only be allowed before battle day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zuras

It could only be allowed before battle day.

---

My Point still stands.
What about resources used to fill cc?
What about the almost full day wasted for prep day?
Why should the other clan be punished cause your clan is poorly managed?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monkeyhole

My Point still stands.
What about resources used to fill cc?
What about the almost full day wasted for prep day?
Why should the other clan be punished cause your clan is poorly managed?

---

Sometimes even when u do not add new members to war: Long time members can suddenly leave during a war prep, for there own reasons. I have seen it happen to the best lead clans, sometimes a couple of long time members leave for whatever reason maybe to make there own clan, whatever the reason its just something that happens, and it may be nobody's fault. Is it really cool to win a war where the other clan had no chance in winning? What does that win mean? Can we be proud of winning an unfair war?

Fixes:

*Refund the resources in full.

Well the other clan is not really being punished I mean there just not gonna have to waste costly armies on an unfair one-sided war. (can we be proud of winning an unfair war?)

The wasted prep day is nothing compared to the whole time it takes for the war to end for the clan that now has no chance in winning because of the members that left.( of course more than 1 member ) :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zuras

Sometimes even when u do not add new members to war: Long time members can suddenly leave during a war prep, for there own reasons. I have seen it happen to the best lead clans, sometimes a couple of long time members leave for whatever reason maybe to make there own clan, whatever the reason its just something that happens, and it may be nobody's fault. Is it really cool to win a war where the other clan had no chance in winning? What does that win mean? Can we be proud of winning an unfair war?

Fixes:

*Refund the resources in full.

Well the other clan is not really being punished I mean there just not gonna have to waste costly armies on an unfair one-sided war. (can we be proud of winning an unfair war?)

The wasted prep day is nothing compared to the whole time it takes for the war to end for the clan that now has no chance in winning because of the members that left.( of course more than 1 member ) :)

---

Again why should the other clan be penalized cause some people left your clan?

Also it would be terribly abused by clans that do not think they have a chance of winning a fair war.

Be able to report people who have left your clan and that report can be viewed by others who might recruit them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Frost86

I've plan playing the game for a few years now and the original group I ran with mostly have died off and we try to recuirt new members and when we war with them they up and leave during war not just one but between 5-10 members and try do t even attack or anything. I think COC needs to do more to punish those that leave during war. I know they got like a 1 day ban from war but they should go further and not allow them to even join a clan for a couple days to give better incentive for members not to leave during war. What does everyone think. Right now my group is in a 30v30 and we had 10 members drop out with no attacks within the first 5 hours of the war.

---

If you have 5-10 people leave per war. My guess would be you are probable doing something wrong.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Frost86

I've plan playing the game for a few years now and the original group I ran with mostly have died off and we try to recuirt new members and when we war with them they up and leave during war not just one but between 5-10 members and try do t even attack or anything. I think COC needs to do more to punish those that leave during war. I know they got like a 1 day ban from war but they should go further and not allow them to even join a clan for a couple days to give better incentive for members not to leave during war. What does everyone think. Right now my group is in a 30v30 and we had 10 members drop out with no attacks within the first 5 hours of the war.

---

It's your poor leadership. No need to change anything. I love finding a clan that self implodes during a war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monkeyhole

Again why should the other clan be penalized cause some people left your clan?

Also it would be terribly abused by clans that do not think they have a chance of winning a fair war.

---

Why would someone think they don't have a chance at winning a fair war.