Re-balancing of the relation of Earthquake-Spells and Walls.
Itīs quite unfair, if 4 Earthquake-Spells of every level breakes every Wall.
It has to be a reasonable relation between spell level and Wall level.
My idea to solve this problem is based on the numbers, we already have and will not change a lot for serious and reasonable gamer, but it will punnish those, who disregard their walls.
We can use the existing demage % we have now for all buildings, but different to the buildings, on walls, we use the total demage.
So if you put an Earthquake-Sell level 4 on a Wall, it wil take 25% of the Hitpoints, but when you put the 2nd, it will not take 25% of the remaining 75%. like on a building, it will take again 25% of all Hitpoints.
To give it a sense, we need to define whats 100% Wall. I would take the Hitpoints of a level 11 Wall as 100% and leave the relation of the Walls to eachother like they are.
So a level 10 Wall would have about 79% of it (5500 HP to 7000 HP), a level 9 Wall 57% and so on.
To break down a Level 11 Wall, you will need like this still 4 spells , but level 4 (100% Wall/100% spell).
If you only have the spell on level 3, you would need 5 for the lv. 11 Wall (100% Wall/105%spell), but 4 are enought to break down a lv. 10 Wall (79%Wall/84%spell)
and for a Wall lv. 9 you just need 3 (57%Wall/63%spell).
If your spell is only lv.2 you will need again 4 spells for a lv. 9 Wall (57%Wall/68%spell).
At Townhall level 8 you will normally only need 3 Earthquake-Spells then for the Walls roughly on this level, but I think itīs only fair, because they donīt have a lot of spells anyway.
At TH lv. 9 the variation of Walls and spells will make the competition inside the same TH lv. more interesting.
For TH lv. 10 and 11 will not change a lot, if your village is up to date, but it will be fatal, if you Walls are to weak or your spells are not updatet.
I donīt think we will see a lot of pink- or blue-walled TH 11 on Campion or Titan then.
I think it this sould be quite easy to set up and also reasonable to explain.
Iīm lookin forward for your feedback.
To appaise your answer, please write also TH-, Earthquake-Spell- and Wall-level.
Michael
TH 9/ Earthquake 3/ Walls 9 and 10