Easy Fix for Friendly Clan Wars

Just like revenging (because it rarely works), the friendly Clan Wars is also broken simply because all you walk away with is bragging rights or a sore bum which translates to a waste of time.

The Fix:

A Wager System.

• The Proposing Clan's challenge also includes a resource value of Gold, Elixir and Dark Elixir that the other clan must match in order to accept the challenge. Once both clans contribute X amount, war can begin.
• The total pot is split amongst the winning team's particpants.
• Per JohnnyPC's abuse idea, a max of 2 challenges (with wager value > 0) per month with the same clan is needed.

Please please please consider this. This alone would elevate this game to a new level.


Cheers,

Agester

Why? do the two clans both pay a fee and then the winner gets the loot? is that what you meant.

Yes, you both match the challenged resource amount (winning pot). The winning team has the pot split amongst those who participated.

Hmm....a good idea but not the best one.
Idk what supercell decides.
But we sure need
1. Either free army trainings
2. Or handfull of resources for participating or winning.

I think a better solution would be truly "free" armies. Clan castle troops on offense and defense wouldn't be used up.
Just like Jaspreet said

Easily exploitable:

1. Everyone in the clan makes a mini account where they simply collect resources from the pumps.
2. Create a new clan for all of the mini accounts.
3. The 2 clans have a friendly war with your "wager" system.
4. The main clan wins and takes all the loot.
5. Repeat a million times.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

Easily exploitable:

1. Everyone in the clan makes a mini account where they simply collect resources from the pumps.
2. Create a new clan for all of the mini accounts.
3. The 2 clans have a friendly war with your "wager" system.
4. The main clan wins and takes all the loot.
5. Repeat a million times.

---

That's what I'd say too. My clan does exist out of a main clan and a feeder clan. Though the feeder is serious, they aren't as strong as the main. + What if you have an imbalanced war? If wouldn't be fair.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

Easily exploitable:

1. Everyone in the clan makes a mini account where they simply collect resources from the pumps.
2. Create a new clan for all of the mini accounts.
3. The 2 clans have a friendly war with your "wager" system.
4. The main clan wins and takes all the loot.
5. Repeat a million times.

---

You're right, you could do something like this, but still each clan has to come up with the loot. And mini's can't exactly come up with a lot of resources anyway. Sounds like it would take some work to get some accounts high enough to make it worth it. And I'm sure supercell could find ways to prevent this as in adding a cap in the number of challenges you can have with any given clan. Say maybe 2 challenges a month to the same clan?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kiddy0012

That's what I'd say too. My clan does exist out of a main clan and a feeder clan. Though the feeder is serious, they aren't as strong as the main. + What if you have an imbalanced war? If wouldn't be fair.

---

Well then you wouldn't accept the challenge obviously. And there could be a value of 0 placed on the challenge as well.