Printable View
I had this problem right after December update. Changed my layout to a triple ring base, it's really hard to avoid giants or goblins not to go around the base, so funneling must be really wide and will give by itself 30%.
Problem solved, I often offer marvelous loot but I've seen one goblin knife in 6 months (adapted the design for th9.5 and now th10). And it was a fail. However, good attackers can give me 16 hours shields from time to time.
I came across a ring base that had all 4 gold storages near the edge of base and elix in the core.. I goblined all 4 storages and 2 elix storages plus dark pumps and made like 400k gold, 2k elix and 600 dark.. The guy revenged me for 3 stars but was funny as I had nothing.. I gave him perfect 29% so he must have been annoyed.
i think it should be lowered to 20% or something or if all army is dropped then a shield is given.. If you get 29%ed 3-4 times on purpose it can make the game un playable if you loose 300k each 29% and it happens 3-4 times as a Th 10
I'm sorry but every th9 I saw in Titans I steamrolled, a th9 cannot defend in Titans. And I am terrible at this gameQuote:
Originally Posted by Chilli59
I'm quite surprised at the number of comments asking OP to move to higher leagues. It is quite ridiculous. You build your base the best way possible to defend your resources and actually win a defense while at it. Who wants to be steamrolled and get all your hard earned resources wiped out? Even the loading screen tips says "Building good defenses is just as important as aggressive attacking". The shield system is broken, and players shouldn't be punished for good defense.
That's fine. Stay in lower leagues and deal with the 29%ers. Like i said, can't have your cake (presumably easier loot on attacks) and eat it too (easy defences). Why move to higher leagues? Nobody in their right mind purposely does 29% attacks in high leagues if they want to stay there. Doing 29% attacks is more prevalent in lower leagues b/c low league attackers dgaf about the league bonus. That's the rationale anyways. It's a free world. Play however you wish - just giving some advice. Nobody needs to heed it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Yachi
Tbh the system works quite well. The high volume attackers attack each other in lower leagues and deal with the low league bonuses and 29%ers. The low volume attackers attack each other in higher leagues and get high league bonuses and get (occasionally) wiped out. Seems like a fair trade off.
Keep in mind there are two objectives in MP gameplay when it comes to defence - protecting loot and protecting trophies. Whilst it'd be great to be able to do both, realistically you can only protect on or the other. This is where base design comes into play.
I think it's hilarious. Buff 29%!!!
It use to be 40% and it isn't just 30%. If they don't use enough troops, you won't get one at 49%. I doubt it will be going to less than 30%
Well, it is a matter of base design, make sure you have your dark storage in center and CC and TH there as well with xbows etc, then make sure some of your collectors are inside walls and make sure that there are some low hp buildings on the way to the core also spread all other storages all over the base, that way only stronger attackers will attack your base and you are more sure of a 30+ percent destruction.
Or you could move to crystal where you should be farming as a TH9.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaosDenmark
I appreciate everyone telling me where I "should be" as a TH9. The fact is I am in Crystal I and still getting 29% Defenses. Supercell has said defense is just as important as offense. I'm thinking that my Defenses are about as good as it can get since I Defend just about half of my attackers, yet I'm losing more resources by having to defend twice to get a shield. That is the broken part.
i agree that it would be nice to see a 20% instead of 29% I hate getting hit multi times especially when saving for expensive things..Quote:
Originally Posted by Pluribus
As a th 9 I always went and farmed in the lower leagues.. It was more fun that way and barching was great! You can't expect people to push just so they don't get 29%ed
i used to get 29%ed as a Th 10 as people would drop in trophies.. I changed bases multi times and still had the same issue till my infernos got maxed and then people could not easy attack me.