When people leave the clan they can put a reason.

I actually like it. I was co-leader in a clan once, and we often have elders and members moving to and fro between our feeders frequently. Sometimes new members and existing ones will get worried about whether the clan is falling apart or whatnot, so a little message along with the leaving log wouldn't hurt.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverSky

So you actually don't care if the strongest guy in you clan or the most loyal elder in your clan suddenly left without any reason?

---

No i do not care if somebody left my clan on a game from the App Store, do you really need to ask that?

i swear some people take this way too seriously, do people who do take it too seriously actually have things going on in their real life, bills, a job, family etc? Because i have all that stuff going so i will say it again, no i do not care if somebody leaves my clan even if it is the "top player" or "most loyal elder".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tavs

What's the point? If they want to leave your clan let them, its a bit sad to go running after them to "get them back".

Anyone who leaves my clan is not welcome back anyway.

i get the impression you are one of the guys on global chat that begs people to join your clan, to be brutally honest, it is pathetic!

I started a clan and it took me 2 days to get 50 members, i kicked people without a shield as this shows inactivity. More people join and more people leave, now 10 days after starting clan i have 45 members who have each already donated over 300 with 7 people donated over 2000.

i did this using a simple tactic that ANYBODY can do. I did not go on global chat once!

---

How do you get first 5 people in your clan without global chat?

Very nice idea man!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tavs

What's the point? If they want to leave your clan let them, its a bit sad to go running after them to "get them back".

Anyone who leaves my clan is not welcome back anyway.

i get the impression you are one of the guys on global chat that begs people to join your clan, to be brutally honest, it is pathetic!

I started a clan and it took me 2 days to get 50 members, i kicked people without a shield as this shows inactivity. More people join and more people leave, now 10 days after starting clan i have 45 members who have each already donated over 300 with 7 people donated over 2000.

i did this using a simple tactic that ANYBODY can do. I did not go on global chat once!

---

That's not the point. The goal is to make it easier like when we ask troops, instead of saying what we want before requesting, we say it IN the request. So intstead of saying "guys i'm gonna leave the clan to visit my friend clan" it would just be "ex: Clayton left the clan because: i'm gonna visit my friend's clan so please keep a spot for me. Thanks"

And that would be simpler, I really aprove that idea!

Thx for the feedback guys hopefully a mod will see this and like it, because my clan could really do with this

I like it +1

I think this idea would be useful in most situations, and would definitely help point out mistakes for clans. For those of you hating on this idea, the real question is not why, it is why not? And yes, people will sometimes leave nasty messages when they leave, but usually when someone has something like that to say, they just put it in clan chat prior to leaving. I think this is another good feature that supercell should definitely add to the game.

If they actually cared to give a reason they could do so in chat prior to leaving.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

If they actually cared to give a reason they could do so in chat prior to leaving.

---

Im the only one i know that does that, so thats why i came up with the idea.
If load of other people do that the idea would have been thought of years ago