Close but not there yet

So my war clan has recently started actively running our farm clan again. I have started recruiting and we have a great bunch of new people shaping up. We are teaching them how to attack properly, redesign their bases with specific attacks in mind to defend against and becoming a unified force to be reckoned with. The current war match we are in is with a clan that is at the very least breaking the spirit of the game.

They clearly stuck a spy in our clan...he is currently back in his own clan and probably having a good laugh. Considering they have three starred our entire roster on their first attack each, except my map, are probably using some sort of mod to practice with.

This leads me to the point of my post. SC has put in place the restriction that players from the opposing side not be able to see war maps before the war starts and I would like to propose we go one step further where any new member joining the clan after a war starts not be able to see anything of the war at all.

maps...battles.....anything. The game should lock them out totally from anything war related if they join after the fact.

I realize this tactic does not violate any rules but when you war 3 times a week it gets hard to recruit that one day only. So do we just not recruit during war and eliminate 6 of 7 days a week and grow at a snails pace? I would ask that SC consider my request as we all know that recruiting is getting harder and harder as time goes on.

Thanks :)

when we recruit we ask any new member to show there most recent defense. clearly states there what clan they came from. if they dont post said defense in less than 60 seconds, its kickville...

that is actually an EXCELLENT idea. it will at least help with some of the spies(the stupid ones) trying to slip in.

glad i could be of assistance

Just taking issue with your assertion that your opponents "are probably using some sort of mod to practice with". If their spy screenshotted your bases cw trap locations and CC contents on prep day there would be no need to use a TPA as they could use the FC feature, which is perfectly acceptable. Also, spying is not "breaking the spirit of the game".

This type of thread gets posted every so often, you should search for some of the previous threads on the topic to see multiple suggestions of how you can still recruit whilst keeping your clan closed during war.

Lastly, this thread should properly be in the Ideas and Feature Requests sub-forum as it is requesting a change to the game.

I think if you're talking about spying and making new people not able to do that.
I would only restrict them to not seeing the base. They won't have any help when seeing the stars gained on the map, but they will probably be judging how good you are as a clan when they aren't spies.
Seeing the replays won't help them either if they are spies, because they can see those as well in their own clan. For people who don't spy and really want to join your clan, they will be able to help you with improving your base or seeing how good you've made your base.

1. this whole complaint shows no quality or fact. you get 3 starred doesn't mean you are being spied on or botted.
2. in some clans there are no war pattern like mirror attack etc. you simply go for the highest you can 3 star. you don't feel cheated if they all make 3 stars on our first strike because they choose opponent with a base design convenient for their attack style.
3. unless your defences are really bad, even a spy should not make a big difference (proof is that in challenge you sometimes try the same base multiple times without trippling it).
4. even if you meet a clan with bots and spies, it is just one war. lose it and win the next against a normal clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hillbillythegre

when we recruit we ask any new member to show there most recent defense. clearly states there what clan they came from. if they dont post said defense in less than 60 seconds, its kickville...

---

Great idea, my compliments. :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hillbillythegre

when we recruit we ask any new member to show there most recent defense. clearly states there what clan they came from. if they dont post said defense in less than 60 seconds, its kickville...

---

What if they just make up a clan? How do you know for sure they came from the clan they claim to?