Add war weight to TH level

Due to some recent mismatches in clan wars I have thought of an idea to add a base war weight to town hall levels. At the very least this weight should be equal to 75% of the weight a max th would have at the previous level.

Example: player upgrades to th10 with a handful of defenses, no walls, midlevel heroes, max th9 troops. Assume for the sake of argument that this player can easily clear any th 8 and 9. Due to the lack of defensive buildings he may be matched near the bottom to a th7 or 8, but clearly doesn't belong there.

I believe this would even match ups significantly and penalize anyone gaming the war system. Make it known early on that upgrading your th may hurt you in war if your base is not up to par.

Last war our opponent had 2 th11's sitting at 16/17 out of 30, they easily cleared our top th10s. While they can be easily 3 starred, that does little to help win the war when stars gained typically at the top is what wins the war.

These matches are killing morale in my clan [level 11] and we can'tbe the only ones that feel this way.

Your thoughts?

I think instead add more war weight based on the account's strongest troop. A TH10 with no defences is not an issue if it only has tier 1 troops.

I've been saying war weight should be bases off town hall then go up from there. Easy fix. Example. If you just turn a th10 you have max war weight of a th9. As you add or upgrade defense it goes up for there. So a th11 would carry max th10 weight and add fro there. That would be a lot better then what we have today.
Pat Fear Deez NUTS!
Join us if your a 3 star attacker. Great clan. Look at our war record 220-30. GOAT NUTs Is the leader.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

I think instead add more war weight based on the account's strongest troop. A TH10 with no defences is not an issue if it only has tier 1 troops.

---

Agreed, it's got to start somewhere. It can't just be based off defensive buildings.

Update on current war: cleaned 2 th10s for a whopping 330k gold/elixer. Could've received the same amount plus 1k de from a th8 that was ranked higher than both.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vaen

Due to some recent mismatches in clan wars I have thought of an idea to add a base war weight to town hall levels. At the very least this weight should be equal to 75% of the weight a max th would have at the previous level.

Example: player upgrades to th10 with a handful of defenses, no walls, midlevel heroes, max th9 troops. Assume for the sake of argument that this player can easily clear any th 8 and 9. Due to the lack of defensive buildings he may be matched near the bottom to a th7 or 8, but clearly doesn't belong there.

I believe this would even match ups significantly and penalize anyone gaming the war system. Make it known early on that upgrading your th may hurt you in war if your base is not up to par.

Last war our opponent had 2 th11's sitting at 16/17 out of 30, they easily cleared our top th10s. While they can be easily 3 starred, that does little to help win the war when stars gained typically at the top is what wins the war.

These matches are killing morale in my clan [level 11] and we can'tbe the only ones that feel this way.

Your thoughts?

---

I think you're someone who can't stand out that people are strategically building up their base. That's like what the game's all about.
I myself like the mini-maxing and Th X.5, I'm familiar with it and use it on one of my accounts.

X.5 is one thing. But going to th10 or 11 with one level one cannon while maxing troop levels is a little obsurd. Literally rank 26-30 on our opponents side had no walls at all. No defences = no loot. It's frustrating. They have no place in war and ruin it for clans that don't go that route.

I second this. And give supercell this solution.

Each town hall has a min-weight. If you choose to upgrade early you will be immediately set to the min-weight until you build enough to surpass that min-weight. This would solve all the problems. Keep in mind this min-weight would not be the max-weight of the previous th level but instead maybe th11's min-weight is that of a max th8. That way you can still X.5 and all the no wall no defense th 11's would be much higher in the war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LabeIed

I second this. And give supercell this solution.

Each town hall has a min-weight. If you choose to upgrade early you will be immediately set to the min-weight until you build enough to surpass that min-weight. This would solve all the problems. Keep in mind this min-weight would not be the max-weight of the previous th level but instead maybe th11's min-weight is that of a max th8. That way you can still X.5 and all the no wall no defense th 11's would be much higher in the war.

---

This is a better idea. This way mini-maxing won't be over the top. But I do want the Th X.5 stay in the game, its just a way to not get someone with a xbow or inferno against you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LabeIed

I second this. And give supercell this solution.

Each town hall has a min-weight. If you choose to upgrade early you will be immediately set to the min-weight until you build enough to surpass that min-weight. This would solve all the problems. Keep in mind this min-weight would not be the max-weight of the previous th level but instead maybe th11's min-weight is that of a max th8. That way you can still X.5 and all the no wall no defense th 11's would be much higher in the war.

---

This idea is a good one it should be done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LabeIed

I second this. And give supercell this solution.

Each town hall has a min-weight. If you choose to upgrade early you will be immediately set to the min-weight until you build enough to surpass that min-weight. This would solve all the problems. Keep in mind this min-weight would not be the max-weight of the previous th level but instead maybe th11's min-weight is that of a max th8. That way you can still X.5 and all the no wall no defense th 11's would be much higher in the war.

---

That's fair. I also agree that X.5 should not be taken away. A th10 or 11 should never have the equivalent war weight of a 4 or 5.