Make Recruitment Better , Kill Spies [Solution Included]

I don't want to keep my Clan Closed all the Time because we do Non-stop wars, Spies affect our recruitment rate hence I'm posting this idea.

1.The Members with "New" Tag Cannot Spectate Wars. (Look below the name of new members)


http://i.imgur.com/tkGR2MZ.jpg

2.The New tag erases in few days and they can Spectate the War.

3.There is a Separate clan setting like Public War log. If you want the new members to Spectate the Wars then you can disable this feature.


FAQ
1.Why can't you Keep your clan Closed?
A:I can't because we are a Non-stop war clan. Keeping Clan closed makes our recruitment Worse and we couldn't get some Loyal Members.

2.I Don't Like your Idea! I want my new Members to spectate War.
A:Just disable the Feature just like Public Clan war log


3.They can Still spy Using the old war replays .
A: You can just switch layout for each war , War details get deleted after 2 wars So you can cycle between 3 Bases (This is only to the One who likes the Feature ) and Still the spy can't see the current war's CC Troops.


Note: Any Trolls or Non-constructive Post will be Reported . If you have any questions or Concerns read FAQ First . For those who likes the idea , Let me know by your reply :)

Feedbacks Taken from most Recent thread:https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-the-war-clans

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jaibansal24

I run a war clan level-10 with daily wars

Situation: We keep clan on "Invite Only" or "Closed", to avoid enemy "SPY" from becoming a member and knowing our war-bases' traps.

Problem: As a result, we are not able grow our clan. When clan is "Open", many new people keep coming and we can Recruit easily. But since we have wars "Back-to-Back", we never get new members :(

Solution = Any clan members who are "Member-only" Should NOT BE ABLE TO SEE THE TRAPS !!
i.e. only Elders, Co-Leaders, Leader can see friendly war-bases' Traps !

Result: So, we can leave over clan as "OPEN" all the time, and just not promote any new-comer for 1-2 days.
Clans will grow easily + Players will find more Open Clans to join = Better growth for both the game and the gamers !!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrSteveSomething

This and variations have been requested many times. For example, people with the NEW status should not be able to click on the War icon. Simple, easy to implement, not done.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Faruque

yest this must be implemented - its a great idea. pls pls pls supercell respond.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SharkyFinn

Agreed. I've never understood why spying is still permitted. Even if it weren't a little underhanded and not really in-line with the family friendly atmosphere, it really hampers the social aspect since it cuts down on players moving between clans.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by plaverty24

Yes. Do it, Supercell.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Midblue

Great idea, should have been implemented yesterday.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheFuzzyLumpkin

I have requested a similar fix once before (basically, new members cannot see the bases for a war that has already started when they join). We are in the same situation, we war back to back so we can never accept new members. It would be such an easy fix. I hope SC will eventually come around and do this so our clan can start growing.

---

Why have supercell fix a problem you can easily fix yourself. .i like how you excluded the opposing arguments from the thread you referenced.
Also please don't create muiltiple threads for same idea.
Enjoy your day

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

Why have supercell fix a problem you can easily fix yourself. .i like how you excluded the opposing arguments from the thread you referenced.
Also please don't create muiltiple threads for same idea.
Enjoy your day

---

>Is it going to be problem for anyone(except spies) if implemented?
No
>Is it going to help many people in game?
Yes
What's your problem?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by M4sterCh1ef

>Is it going to be problem for anyone(except spies) if implemented?
No
>Is it going to help many people in game?
Yes
What's your problem?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

Problem is that even if this does happen people will complain about different ways of spying then another idea will be implemented then people will discover another way to spy then people will complain again and then another solution will be implemented until all we have left is a totalitarian game.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SharkyFinn

It's possible what you say could be true, but the current loophole keeps clans from admitting new members or visitors for fear of being taken advantage of. I say we close this loophole and look at or deal with others down the road. More interactions between players should be encouraged and the spying loophole discourages them.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

I like your response.
I think maybe a waiting list feature might help.recruiting from global or using feeder clans is the best way to not to recruit spies.

---

to summarize there would probably be a floodgate of complaining because people would expect all forms of spying to be stopped

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

to summarize there would probably be a floodgate of complaining because people would expect all forms of spying to be stopped

---

I still can't understand what's your problem? People will complain to Supercell not you.

And it's same like lopsided/engineered bases. Some people are taking advantage of loophole this game has. And as Supercell is promoting fair play, eliminating those loophole going make this game more fair and better.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by M4sterCh1ef

I still can't understand what's your problem? People will complain to Supercell not you.

And it's same like lopsided/engineered bases. Some people are taking advantage of loophole this game has. And as Supercell is promoting fair play, eliminating those loophole going make this game more fair and better.

---

Fair play means playing within the ToS.
Please read the times I i quoted myself.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

Fair play means playing within the ToS.
Please read the times I i quoted myself.

---

I know what fair play means and that's why I gave example of lopsided/engineered bases which is within ToS, but Supercell still addressed those.

You quoted your response which you think is right. Doesn't has to be right for every one. And mostly new clans face these spying issue because they need new (loyal)players and they can't go through the process you suggested. OP suggestion works better for everyone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by M4sterCh1ef

I know what fair play means and that's why I gave example of lopsided/engineered bases which is within ToS, but Supercell still addressed those.

You quoted your response which you think is right. Doesn't has to be right for every one. And mostly new clans face these spying issue because they need new (loyal)players and they can't go through the process you suggested. OP suggestion works better for everyone.

---

They can still recruit through global. You wouldn't let anyone in your home would you? No you would invite them first. Would you rather someone you never met walk right into your home/clan or would you rather have them ring the doorbell and wait to be let in after you make sure who they are?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

They can still recruit through global. You wouldn't let anyone in your home would you? No you would invite them first. Would you rather someone you never met walk right into your home/clan or would you rather have them ring the doorbell and wait to be let in after you make sure who they are?

---

Again you're talking about something which doesn't work with new clans. If a low level clan invite you in global to join them, will you join? No because it's a low level clan. You'll not get 1 or 2 level higher troops. Your troop request cool down time will be much higher. So those clans mostly rely on players who want to join them by themselves.

It's good to see you comparing your clans with your home. But you forgot you're not looking for guests whom you have to invite you're looking for home/clan member who'll become a part of family. And family don't need an invite they ring doorbell, though you can invite them also.