Wall levels and Earthquake spell

So it's kind of frustrating to see your hard earned lvl 9 and 10 walls flored by 4 lvl 1/2 earthquake spells. And in my opinion that seems a bit unfair.

Earthquake spells do up to 25% of damage per spell depending on the level. Which gradually diminishes on buildings (100%>75%>56,25%>etc)

So here's my idea, you actually need better level earthquake spells to destroy higher level walls.

The earthquake level
1 14%
2 17%
3 21%
4 25%

So the wall's capability of defence should be (level^10)-10 of it's actual level

I'll start at wall lvl 6
6 = 50%
7 = 60%
8 = 70%
9 = 80%
10 = 90%
11 = 100%

For lvl 6 walls 4 lvl 1 earthquake spells will do the trick, as 4x14% damage cuts 56%, 6% over the required destroy ratio
However the same 4 lvl 1 spells on a lvl 7 wall won't bring it down, because you are 4% short of it's destruction criteria. Thus requiring at least 2 level 2 earthquake spells.
This goes on. For the level 8 walls, 4 level 2 EQ spells won't bring them down 68% out of 70% meaning you'll need at least one donated lvl 3 earthquake spell.
For the level 9 walls 4 level 3 spells is sufficient (4*21=84%/80%).
However for the level 10 and 11 walls you need 4 maxed out EQ spells.

This certainly brings some more challenge into just dropping 4 EQ spells and trampling someone's base. Really requiring people on higher tiers to have CC donation's in order to execute a succesful attack

Sorry if i wrote some things a bit sloppy. But this is the concept i'm thinking about

Fellow clashers what's your opinion.

I never understood how lvl 1 eq spells can knock down max walls. I like the idea. Right now the only reason to max eq is because it will do more % damage to buildings & defenses. I didn't check your maths but it looks good.

Thanks! It's a really good concept. Requires people to upgrade EQ spell + having a clanmate donate a higher level EQ spell. It also stimulates upgrading walls to a higher level before rushing to TH11

Instead make it so EQ and jump should not overlaps like the current situation, it is not neat at all. Maybe give EQ higher % damage but remove the 4x wall destruction.

There shoul be a correlation between wall and EQ levels. Level 1 or 2 EQ should not be able to destroy high level walls

Remember that EQs do increasing dmg on walls and decreasing dmg on buildings.

Love this idea OP, I've been suggesting the same thing for a very long time.

It'd also make the base building process a lot more interesting a) am I making this base to protect itself against trophy hunters? b) am I making this base to protect itself against war attacks c) is this a farm base? d) will it force them to use jump instead? e) is this base for higher leagues with better equipped players?

I definitelly think this would bring more challenge into the game, a challenge that would be in my opinion most welcome!

Thanks for the positive response!

I guess I'll be the first to disagree.

Sorry OP. This idea may be good, but a bit too complicated imo. SC has easy instructions on every spell and troop, and I think this'll ruin it.

A more simplistic method is:
Eq lvl 1 - walls 6 and below
Eq lvl 2 - walls 7
Eq lvl 3 - walls 8+9
Eq lvl 4 - walls 10+11

But i think the first idea uses more aspects that makes it more challenging

nice one :) agree with OP eq :)