Printable View
I know you can set your war log to not public but there should be an option for the clan leader to hide the war log from its members!
Some clans are so bad that when a new guy comes in, takes one look at the war log and then they're off!
Makes recruitment so much more difficult! 😉
that's a stupid idea.
Why would you want to have a new member waste a few days in the clan if they want to be in a decent war clan?
Sorry, but this is kind of a goofy suggestion in my opinion. Don't mean to be rude, but...c'mon! :)
I'd call that natural selection at work....Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
Well, for clans with good war logs like mine, it makes recruitment so much easier!
Wouldn't want clans to be able to fib about their war log and mislead new recruits...
You want to misrepresent your clan?
So let me reverse the question for you...
You are really keen on war and looking for a new clan where people actually know what they are doing. You join a new clan and they say that they are great and win every war. Would you not like to know if they are telling the truth before you commit to joining them until they start their next war and for two days after that?
lol, what else are you going to hide?
if the clan is so bad, maybe it's time to play farmville
Nonsense. I love being misled and lied to. Is that not a common pleasure?Quote:
Originally Posted by Istencsapasa
Hmmm so how do bad clans become decent then?Quote:
Originally Posted by th94life
Lol, gamer Darwinism!Quote:
Originally Posted by Polaris
Improve the war log. Even if your overall record is 10-50, if I see your previous 10 wars are 8-2, I'll be much more likely to stick aroundQuote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
So give clan leaders more power ! That seems like great ideal since most are under 15 but very mature since they are the leader . I agree with others if a person is in you clan they should be able to see the war log ! It's their clan too
Hey, why not hide donations, too... 😂
If you can put together a good stretch over a month or so, you can represent yourselves as having turned things around. Hiding war log from members is just shady.
They start with their current members, and get them on track, becoming decent attackers and turning that red log green. Then, they recruit new members.Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
So few clans want to be introspective anymore. Always pointing the finger at something else. Their is a reason that the war log looks the way it does. Treat the illness, not the symptom.
For starters, I'm not talking about my clan. I recently went wandering and come across clans that had pretty bad war logs but for whatever it's worth, it seems that if you had a bad start it's pretty hard to turn it around if it's on display to all who wanders by.Quote:
Originally Posted by cnaf
It's like having a criminal record, hard to get a second chance.
Anyway, am just bored with nothing to do so just thought I'll kick this around and see if anybody can relate to this "problem".
Obviously for those who have sterling war logs you have the option of displaying your war log as proudly as you want so it doesn't affect you.
Hiding a war log isn't the answer. A new mate that comes in will quickly learn he/she was lied to. You think they want to stay after that?Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
There are many other steps a bad clan should attempt, when trying to better themselves....than fib about their abilities and results in wars.
Not the best idea I have seen and certainly not the worst one. I think that being a clan member, you gain access to the clans information and what is to be expected of you and so forth.
But hiding a war log just because it is bad is kind of a cowardish move, don't you think?
What? No thanks. Don't like it.
It's like having a criminal record as a chronic thief/kleptomaniac. But rather than stop stealing, you just tell people you've stopped, but haven't.Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
If a bad clan wants to quash their poor war record, the solution is simple...improve the war record
A war log is not the end all, be all decision in whether players stick around in a clan or not. I've been a part of, or see far too many with nothing but green have players come and go.Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
Yes, it can be difficult to turn around. But lets not lose sight of one important thing- not every clan can, or will be successful. Every TH7 thinks he can build a clan up and be the next OneHive. The odds are so not with you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
Back in late 2015, we lost 9 wars in a row. Not good! As with many things, get back to basics such as building proper anti 3 star bases (TH9), focusing your clan on key offence war troops and Hero levels etc. It takes time, and effort... but the rewards are all the sweeter, when you start seeing a wall of 'mostly' green!:)Quote:
Originally Posted by ElectroWizzard
Look once your in the clan everything should be accessibleQuote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
Bad war log sucks bad ik but what can you do right
(except get better)
What they should add is the ability to keep it semi-public, but allow it so that the enemy in wars cannot see it.
I know this will never gain any traction here since most forumers are either elite players or leaders of elite clans but to a certain extent i do sympathise with the leader of a clan with 50 wins and 239 losses who laments it's hard to get good players to even stay for 1 war. Lol..Quote:
Originally Posted by RedHuntress
Yup..natural selection as someone says, the good gets better the bad gets worse...such is life.
Lots of kicking.....no jokeQuote:
Originally Posted by patrickpatrick
That's true but if nobody wants to start building clans the game will be so much the poorer for it?Quote:
Originally Posted by cnaf
Another suggestion is to create some minis to help you win wars
There is a option to hide it, Not from your clan but from global..